Tippett: Symphonies Nos 3 & 4; Symphony in B flat review | Andrew Clements's classical CD of the week

(Hyperion, two CDs)
He may be unfashionable now, but Tippett’s Third Symphony still sounds robust and his B flat symphony is rarely heard, making an interesting survey

First performed in 1972, Michael Tippett’s Third Symphony was written during what was perhaps the most successful period of the composer’s career. The premiere of his third opera, The Knot Garden, at Covent Garden in 1969, had been a huge success. He had also tapped into a totally new audience in the US, which he first visited in 1965, and where he returned regularly for the rest of his life. The Third Symphony reflects his new enthusiasm for American culture, with its vocal finale in which a soprano soloist, partnered by a flugelhorn, sings a series of blues. It’s intended to offer a 20th-century response to the expressions of universal brotherhood proclaimed by the finale of Beethoven’s Ninth, which Tippett quotes in his own last movement.

Tippett: Symphonies Nos 3, 4 & B flat … album artwork.
Tippett: Symphonies Nos 3, 4 & B flat … album artwork. Photograph: Hyperion Records

So much of Tippett’s output has become unfashionable in the 20 years since his death, it’s reassuring to discover how well the Third Symphony still stands up, both musically and idealistically, in a far more cynical age. Martyn Brabbins and the BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra, completing a cycle of Tippett symphonies they began last year with the First and Second, propel it with an almost confrontational sinewy intensity, with every texture crisply defined. Rachel Nicholls is the feisty soprano soloist in the finale, which is almost a dramatic scena, looking back to the world of The Knot Garden, and especially to its character of “freedom fighter” Denise.

As this recording shows, though, the symphony is a far more robust, less modish achievement than the opera, and one much more likely to persist in the repertoire. But Brabbins and the orchestra cannot make such a convincing case for the birth-to-death span of the Fourth Symphony, premiered in 1977. It seems to lack the substance of its predecessors, being more an orchestral display piece (it was composed for Georg Solti and the Chicago Symphony) than a tough-minded symphonic argument.

Brabbins’ two discs now line up against the only previous cycles on disc, by Richard Hickox for Chandos, and a Decca set that’s shared between performances under Colin Davis (for the first three symphonies) and Solti (for the Fourth). All three have their different merits, but Hyperion offers a bonus with the first ever recording of Tippett’s Symphony in B flat, premiered in 1934 but withdrawn after a handful of performances, and not heard again until Brabbins revived it last year.

Fundamentally neo-Romantic, indebted to Sibelius and with few hints of the direction Tippett’s music might take over the next decade, it’s now a historical curiosity more than anything else, but rounds out the survey nicely.


Andrew Clements

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
BBCSSO/Brabbins: Tippett symphonies Nos 1 and 2 CD review – buoyancy and purpose

Andrew Clements

04, Jan, 2018 @3:30 PM

Article image
Prom 22: BBCSSO/Manze review – sparkling rendition of two London symphonies
After some initial hesitancy, Andrew Manze drew out delicate phrasing and fine detail in this pairing of Haydn and Vaughan Williams

Martin Kettle

01, Aug, 2018 @11:19 AM

Article image
Schumann: The Symphonies review – bombast and revelation | Andrew Clements's classical album of the week
The Staatskapelle’s sumptuous playing is hard to fault, but conductor Thielemann is too overblown at times

Andrew Clements

18, Apr, 2019 @2:00 PM

Article image
Beethoven: Leonore review | Andrew Clements's classical album of the month
Petersen/Schmitt/Ivashchenko/Johannsen/Freiburg Baroque O/Jacobs
(Harmonia Mundi, two CDs)
Leonore was Beethoven’s first version of Fidelio and René Jacobs eloquently champions the earlier score in this lithe live recording

Andrew Clements

28, Nov, 2019 @3:00 PM

Article image
Brahms: The Four Symphonies review | Andrew Clements' classical album of the week
Emulating Brahms himself with an orchestra of fewer than 50 players, these fresh, engaging recordings show that less can mean a lot more

Andrew Clements

11, Aug, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
Prom 51: BBCSSO/Dausgaard review – Nørgård's extraordinary symphony finally reaches the UK
In the hands of the BBC Scottish, Nørgård’s powerful Third Symphony was astonishingly gripping, while Malin Byström brought dark beauty to Strauss

Tim Ashley

22, Aug, 2018 @9:25 AM

Article image
Sibelius: The Seven Symphonies CD review – Järvi can't quite convince | Andrew Clements' classical album of the week
Paavo Järvi brings deep knowledge and affinity to this music, but the results don’t generate the thrills they should

Andrew Clements

17, Jan, 2019 @3:00 PM

Article image
Ives: Complete Symphonies review | Andrew Clements's classical album of the week
The conductor and his orchestra express the transcendental immensity of Ives, especially in a glorious Fourth Symphony

Andrew Clements

27, Aug, 2020 @2:00 PM

Article image
Henryk Górecki: Symphony No 3 review – minimalism made human | John Lewis's contemporary album of the month
The Portishead singer is not a trained soprano but her wracked style brings out the work’s eerie desperation

John Lewis

28, Mar, 2019 @3:00 PM

Article image
Schubert Symphony No 9 review | Erica Jeal's classical album of the week
Conductor Maxim Emelyanychev inspires the SCO in Schubert’s massive work, with grandeur and great washes of feeling

Erica Jeal

14, Nov, 2019 @3:00 PM