Madama Butterfly/Der Rosenkavalier review – Glyndebourne openers perplex, provoke and charm

Glyndebourne, Sussex
Annilese Miskimmon’s stripped-back Puccini update and an admirable but uneven Strauss revival opened this year’s summer festival

Glyndebourne’s new season opens with a pair of revivals. Annilese Miskimmon’s staging of Puccini’s Madama Butterfly, first seen during the 2016 tour, is new to the main festival. Richard Jones’s production of Strauss’s Der Rosenkavalier premiered in 2014. Both divided opinion when new, and both are essentially anti-Romantic in stance, stripping away the veneer of sentimentality that each work has accumulated over time.

Miskimmon’s Butterfly is more a reworking than a straight revival, though the basic concept remains the same. She updates the opera to the closing years of the American occupation of Japan, and places the narrative in the wider context of an exploitative system that offers local girls the possibility of escaping poverty by becoming GI brides and allows US servicemen to take advantage of conveniently dissolvable marriages. Two years ago, Miskimmon’s anger rode roughshod over the opera’s humanity, resulting in a hardness of edge that sat uneasily with the score’s emotive force. This time round, greater subtlety of detail combined with striking performances allows the drama fully to hit home.

Butterfly is played by the Moldovan soprano Olga Busuioc, whose exceptional way with dynamics and tone colour allows her to encompass both the naivety of the opening scenes and the tragic emotions of the later acts. We can completely understand her attraction to Joshua Guerrero’s handsome if weak-willed Pinkerton, and there’s a real sense of rapture in their love duet. But we also notice the telling streak of pride that lurks beneath her vulnerability in the way she loftily dismisses Simon Mechliński’s Yamadori and rounds on Elizabeth DeShong’s fiercely devoted Suzuki. Omer Meir Wellber’s conducting, meanwhile, has a tremendous, slow-burning intensity that draws us relentlessly into the opera’s unsettling world.

Kate Lindsey, Michael Kraus and Elizabeth Sutphen in Der Rosenkavalier.
Sounds exquisite... Kate Lindsey, Michael Kraus and Elizabeth Sutphen in Der Rosenkavalier. Photograph: Robert Workman

Musically, Der Rosenkavalier is equally strong for the most part, although conductor Robin Ticciati got off to an awkward start on opening night with an uncharacteristically lacklustre account of the prelude. Rachel Willis-Sørensen is the outstanding Marschallin, sumptuous of tone, witty yet sad. Kate Lindsey makes a comparably fine Octavian, and is gauche, funny, extremely touching in moments of bewilderment. Elizabeth Sutphen’s Sophie sounds exquisite, while Brindley Sherratt’s Ochs combines louche charm with genuine menace.

Jones’s staging, however, is by turns admirable and perplexing. As one might expect, he is strong on the class divisions that underpin the opera, sharply differentiating between a declining aristocracy, an emerging bourgeoisie and an urban proletariat on the make. His treatment of the protagonists has great clarity. Ochs’s humiliation of Sophie in act two has rarely felt more uncomfortable, and time really seems to stand still in the Presentation of the Rose and the final Trio. Against that, however, must be set a quirkiness that sometimes gets in the way. The designs, surreally jumbling periods from the 18th century to the 1970s, sit uneasily with an opera that is essentially a realistic comedy of manners. The Marschallin muses on her past as a psychoanalytic patient on Freud’s couch, which strikes an awkward note. And there are moments when parades of servants and flunkies, endlessly shifting furniture, prove intrusive. It doesn’t quite add up to a theatrically satisfying whole, though it is unquestionably beautiful to listen to.

• At Glyndebourne until 26 June (Der Rosenkavalier) and 18 July (Madama Butterfly). Box office: 01273 815000. Madama Butterly will be broadcast live in cinemas and on on 21 June.


Tim Ashley

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Sex, betrayal, suicide: is Madama Butterfly too sordid to stage today?
Puccini’s Orientalist story of the sexual exploitation of an Asian woman may seem repulsive in the #metoo era – but we shouldn’t flinch from a masterpiece’s savagery, says the director of Glyndebourne’s latest production

Annilese Miskimmon

05, Jun, 2018 @5:08 PM

Article image
La Bohème review – Death stalks Puccini’s lovers at Glyndebourne
Floris Visser’s new production puts a dark spin on this story of doomed lovers – which only heightens the life-affirming vibrancy of the music

Erica Jeal

12, Jun, 2022 @3:51 PM

Article image
Madama Butterfly review – engages the mind at the expense of passion
Annilese Miskimmon’s production for Glyndebourne’s tour presents a hard-edged view of Puccini’s romantic tragedy. Musically, Matteo Lippi’s Pinkerton is marvellous, while John Wilson excels in the pit

Tim Ashley

18, Oct, 2016 @1:44 PM

Article image
Madama Butterfly – review
The production's straightforwardness has become its strength, and its ability to retain its crispness is shown by this excellent revival, writes Andrew Clements

Andrew Clements

28, Jun, 2011 @5:01 PM

Article image
Manon Lescaut review – Puccini updated to the swinging 60s
Elizabeth Llewellyn is an exciting voice, but Karolina Sofulak’s uneven new production doesn’t quiet set the pulse racing

Erica Jeal

05, Jun, 2019 @11:15 AM

Article image
Giove in Argo; Madama Butterfly – review
A lost Handel opera proves a revelation. And Royal Opera’s Butterfly is a heart-breaker

Stephen Pritchard

29, Mar, 2015 @7:00 AM

Arts Diary, Charlotte Higgins: Glyndebourne lovers set a date

Charlotte Higgins: The diary is incredibly excited about the impending nuptials of Gus Christie, executive chairman of Glyndebourne, and Danielle de Niese

Charlotte Higgins

25, Feb, 2009 @12:01 AM

Article image
Salome review – petals, porn and dead ponies give Strauss a feminist reboot
Adena Jacobs floods her stage with blood in an English National Opera re-imagining that does not quite live up to its early intrigue

Tim Ashley

30, Sep, 2018 @10:35 AM

Article image
The Damnation of Faust review – seductive, beguiling and sinister
The new Glyndebourne season opens with a striking, albeit nihilistic and anti-Romantic staging by Richard Jones of Berlioz’s dramatic legend

Tim Ashley

19, May, 2019 @11:45 AM

Article image
Ariadne ducks the bombs at the Glyndebourne festival

This year's Glyndebourne opener Ariadne auf Naxos is getting a radical relocation, to a Blitz-time hospital. Director Katharina Thoma tells Tom Service how she drew on the history of the Sussex mansion

Tom Service

15, May, 2013 @6:00 PM