Why fans want to hear the hits not ‘one from the new album’

From Liam Payne to Gwen Stefani and (almost) Nadine Coyle, pop stars are increasingly relying on their old bandmates to shift tickets

Liam Payne recently said that One Direction might reunite for a tour – just two years after they broke up. Talking like a recently solo pop star with a clearly thought-through back-up plan, he suggested that 1D could get back together to perform their solo stuff and the boyband’s hits like “five concerts in one” before being forced to admit that he’d only actually spoken to Louis Tomlinson about the idea. But – aside from the fact that it will probably be a long time before we see Harry Styles and Zayn back in the band – Liam doesn’t actually need to restart that dormant “1D ladzzz banter” WhatsApp group just yet; you can trade on your old band’s reputation without going the full reunion.

Take Gwen Stefani, for instance. She has recently signed up to a Las Vegas residency, and it’s fair to say the imagery is very No Doubt era, right down to the oranges from the Don’t Speak video. The show’s even called Just a Girl. But now that Gwen’s former bandmates have formed a new group without her – Dreamcar, with AFI frontman Davey Havok – they’re not available. No matter: Gwen can perform the band’s hits without them, maybe even subbing in her country star boyfriend Blake Shelton for a duet on Hella Good, as she did at a recent awards show.

Then there’s Nadine Coyle, who earlier this year announced her Girls Aloud tour … without the rest of Girls Aloud. The fallout between them has been well documented but Nadine didn’t let that stop her, announcing plans to perform classics such as The Promise, Love Machine and Biology alongside her own slightly less successful solo output (the No 26-charting Insatiable anyone?). Sounds incredible: only a cynic would suggest that the tour’s last-minute cancellation was in any way connected to the fact that tickets weren’t selling as fast as they would for, I don’t know, an actual Girls Aloud reunion.

Pop stars using their back catalogue to try to pad out a thin solo career is not a new tactic: early in his solo live shows, Ne-Yo would sing all the songs he actually wrote for other artists as some kind of weird flex. Famously, Mike Love still tours as the Beach Boys, despite fans holding the band’s Wilson brothers much closer to their hearts; even Bluetones frontman Mark Morriss has toured Bluetones songs without the Bluetones.

So it’s settled, then: Liam Payne’s proposed solo One Direction tour will include him breathlessly trying to sing all five parts of What Makes You Beautiful, and him having an emergency lie-down backstage after attempting to dance and hit Zayn’s high notes at the same time. All that, plus awkward stage banter with just himself. Liam: sign us up.

Contributor

Issy Sampson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Gary Barlow and Madonna! Pop’s strangest crossovers
This month marks the 21st anniversary of Barlow’s solo album Open Road, which features a track penned by Madonna. From Beyoncé to Victoria Beckham and beyond, it’s not the first oddly matched musical venture

Louis Wise

20, Apr, 2018 @11:58 AM

Article image
Why Greatest Hits are back at the top of the album charts
Even in the era of streaming, Best Of albums are in rude health, benefiting from both comforting nostalgia and confusing chart rules

Eamonn Forde

07, Aug, 2020 @12:00 PM

Article image
Why fans want constant ‘content’ from their musical heroes – even in the afterlife
Music from late stars such as Mac Miller and Lil Peep prove that younger audiences don’t share the same reservations over posthumous releases

Hannah Ewens

29, Nov, 2019 @1:00 PM

Article image
Gwen Stefani’s Make Me Like You: the best of this week’s new music
Gwen Stefani | Tiggs Da Author ft Lady Leshurr | Hozier | XO ft James Chatburn | Rudimental ft Anne-Marie & Will Heard

Issy Sampson

26, Feb, 2016 @1:00 PM

Article image
Reclining album sales? Why pop stars are making sofas not songs
From Louise Redknapp’s footstools to Kylie’s Atmosphere Duvet, an increasing number of musicians are turning to home furnishings

Michael Cragg

02, Nov, 2018 @1:00 PM

Article image
Heaven or hell? The problem of the posthumous album
A new Cranberries album is due, featuring the vocals of Dolores O’Riordan. But the issue of what a late musician ‘would have wanted’ is often a dilemma for both bands and the fans

Gavin Haynes

06, Apr, 2018 @12:00 PM

Article image
Cottage industry: the enduring power of the ‘cabin in the woods’ album
From Bon Iver to Taylor Swift, artists and audiences continue to be drawn to the homespun allure of the isolation album

Sophie Harris

06, Nov, 2020 @1:00 PM

Article image
How Nicki Minaj became the Queen of the chaotic album campaign
From rap feuds to delays and odd allegiances – the rapper joins the likes of U2, Katy Perry and Rita Ora in the pantheon of buzz-killing album launches

Issy Sampson

10, Aug, 2018 @12:00 PM

Article image
Arctic Monkeys may have ‘saved rock'n'roll’ but can they save the album?
By eschewing pre-release whistles and bells with their new album, the band are boldly going back to basics

Sam Wolfson

11, May, 2018 @11:57 AM

Article image
'It's been cathartic': how Blanck Mass made a travelogue album in lockdown
With touring halted, the electronic musician incorporated recordings from around the world, as well as memories of a late loved one, into a ‘sad and nostalgic’ new work

Daniel Dylan Wray

19, Feb, 2021 @1:00 PM