LSO/Gardiner/Faust review – alert to Schumann's volatility and rigour

Barbican, London
Isabelle Faust’s heartfelt performance of the Violin Concerto was at the centre of an exquisite and convincing all-Schumann programme

This was the second concert in John Eliot Gardiner and the London Symphony Orchestra’s Schumann cycle, a major reappraisal of the symphonies and orchestral music, spread over two years. The Fourth Symphony, the Genoveva Overture, and the Overture, Scherzo and Finale, had long been scheduled in the programme, but its centrepiece, by a twist of fate, was the Violin Concerto, played by Isabelle Faust, a last-minute substitution for Mozart’s C minor piano concerto, K503, after pianist Piotr Anderszewski succumbed to flu.

Written in 1853, shortly before Schumann’s final breakdown, the concerto remains controversial. Clara Schumann, fearing that it exposed her husband’s worsening mental state, suppressed the score, which was not heard until 1937. “It’s not the work of a madman,” Faust stated emphatically as she and Gardiner addressed the audience before the performance, though you could argue that the nagging orchestral figurations of the first movement and the harmonic instability of the second suggest deep psychological anguish.

More important, perhaps, is the fact that it constitutes an attempt to rethink the concerto form itself along symphonic rather than virtuoso lines. Faust, who describes herself as a Schumann fanatic, played with fierce conviction, generating furious intensity towards the close of the first movement and investing the second with deeply felt lyricism. The arabesques and “pirouettes” (Faust’s word) of the polonaise finale were exquisite, though neither she nor Gardiner could disguise the fact that the movement itself is fractionally too long – as if Schumann didn’t know quite how to end it.

Gardiner remains one of the great Schumann interpreters, wonderfully alert to the music’s volatility and rigour. The LSO, on terrific form for him, played seated for the concerto, though, following 19th-century practice, the upper strings, brass and woodwind stood for the symphonic works. Gardiner opted for the 1841 version of the Fourth, as opposed to Schumann’s denser rewrite of 1851, and the textural transparency and rhythmic elan proved utterly beguiling. The Genoveva Overture swivelled between Sturm und Drang turbulence and elation, while Overture, Scherzo and Finale was electric in its tension and excitement.


Tim Ashley

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The top 10 classical shows of 2017
A magisterial Monteverdi cycle, Oliver Knussen’s adventures in haiku – and a hero’s return for Simon Rattle. Our critic picks his highlights

Andrew Clements

18, Dec, 2017 @6:00 AM

LSO/Gardiner – review

The Oedipus Rex was thrilling in this all-Stravinsky concert, writes Andrew Clements

Andrew Clements

26, Apr, 2013 @4:56 PM

Article image
LSO/Gardiner review – lovingly attentive Mendelssohn
John Eliot Gardiner and the London Symphony Orchestra celebrated the Shakespeare anniversary with a perfectly judged all-Mendelssohn programme

Martin Kettle

17, Feb, 2016 @2:15 PM

Portrait of the artist: John Eliot Gardiner, conductor
'Being accepted is the biggest challenge. Every time you stand in front of a new orchestra, you are on trial'

Laura Barnett

05, Oct, 2009 @9:05 PM

Article image
LSO/Rattle/Hannigan review – Abrahamsen's masterpiece soars
In an all-Nordic programme, the 2013 song cycle Let Me Tell You lost none of its ability to bewitch in a concert that also featured Sibelius and Nielsen

Andrew Clements

11, Jan, 2019 @3:37 PM

Article image
LSO/Rattle review – all-British programme sparkles and soars
The London Symphony Orchestra opened their new season with British music - a Birtwistle premiere alongside works by Holst, Britten and Turnage

Erica Jeal

17, Sep, 2018 @12:23 PM

Article image
LSO/Rattle review – lyrical Walton and outstanding Leila Josefowicz
Walton’s First Symphony was superbly played and conducted – as was Colin Matthews’s Violin Concerto, with Josefowicz as the fiercely committed soloist

Andrew Clements

15, Sep, 2019 @1:51 PM

Article image
Prom 44: LSO/Rattle review – Jungle Book-inspired scherzo delivered with verve
An all-20th-century programme showcased the wit and brilliance of Simon Rattle and the London Symphony Orchestra, although Belshazzar’s Feast lacked bite

Andrew Clements

21, Aug, 2019 @12:52 PM

Article image
LSO/Rattle review – volatile, politically charged Berg and Beethoven
Moments of insecurity made Beethoven’s Ninth feel fiercely relevant, with the Ode to Joy theme held to a hush, while soprano Iwona Sobotka soared

Erica Jeal

17, Feb, 2020 @10:34 PM

Article image
Prom 66: In the Name of the Earth review – gargantuan praise for the planet
Three orchestral choruses and five London choirs united to slightly muddying effect for this performance of John Luther Adams’s hymn to the world

Andrew Clements

08, Sep, 2019 @1:42 PM