Classical album of the week: La Clemenza di Tito review – Nézet-Séguin and Villazón return

Villazón / Rebeka / DiDonato / Chamber Orchestra of Europe / Nézet-Séguin
(Deutsche Grammophon)

In 2011, tenor Rolando Villazón instigated a project to record all the mature Mozart operas, complete with A-list casts, conducted by Yannick Nézet-Séguin at a concert in Baden-Baden. Five operas down, the series is a curious one, worth relishing on some counts but also frustratingly uneven.

Nézet-Séguin draws a performance from the Chamber Orchestra of Europe that nods to the historically informed movement and old-school, big-orchestra Mozart without quite deciding where in between it wants to stand. He and the excellent RIAS Kammerchor make light work of the crowd scenes, but among much propulsive and shapely playing there are episodes that sound heavy-handed. An example is Sesto’s pivotal aria Parto, Parto: the first section is excessively slow, so that Joyce DiDonato – drawing out each phrase dauntlessly – can convey the character’s turmoil but not his resolve; then the second section hurtles onwards as fast as she or anyone else could possibly sing it.

Extreme tempos notwithstanding, DiDonato’s Sesto is vibrant and memorable. So too is Marina Rebeka’s Vitellia, a larger-than-life performance that right away establishes the volatility of the character. Her top notes are searing and her low notes are fierce, which fits the role. The smaller roles are impeccably cast, with Regina Mühlemann dewdrop-sweet as Servilia, Tara Erraught making much of Annio, and Adam Plachetka as the commander Publio, who sounds rather more secure than his emperor.

The main idiosyncrasy is Villazón – and in this opera, where the tenor has the title role, that’s not easy to gloss over. Some listeners will find his warm, passionate portrayal of the merciful emperor an antidote to the generic, antiseptic style in which Mozart can be played today; others will balk at his expressive tuning, and wonder why he sounds as if he is limbering up for Nessun Dorma. This month, he and Nézet-Séguin will return to Baden-Baden for Die Zauberflöte; Villazón will go full Domingo and sing the baritone role of Papageno.

This week’s other picks

Also out this week are recitals from two pillars of the UK opera scene. On Come to Me in My Dreams, mezzo-soprano Sarah Connolly and pianist Joseph Middleton bring insight to a lovely collection of songs by composers connected with London’s Royal College of Music, including two previously unrecorded ones by Britten. Meanwhile, baritone Christopher Purves and Arcangelo have released a sequel to their 2012 Handel disc, Finest Arias for Base Voice, reminding us that Purves is not only an outstanding singing actor but also an outstanding singer.

Contributor

Erica Jeal

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Mozart: La Clemenza di Tito CD review – Allemano and Aldrich shine in otherwise undistinguished reconstruction

Andrew Clements

12, Jan, 2017 @4:30 PM

Article image
Mozart: Zaide CD review – unfinished harem opera reveals its deeply serious side
Ian Page and Classical Opera’s searching version of Mozart’s incomplete work is faithful to Mozart’s intentions, with stark notes of tragedy

Andrew Clements

14, Sep, 2016 @2:30 PM

Article image
La Clemenza di Tito review – delight to be back, but modern-dress production fails to convince
Richard Jones’s eagerly-anticipated new production of Mozart’s opera seria has moments of insight but overall too many incongruities, but there is much to enjoy musically, especially Nicole Chevalier’s Vitellia

Tim Ashley

18, May, 2021 @12:34 PM

Article image
Mozart: Die Entführung aus dem Serail - Nézet-Séguin/Villazón CD review: disappointing
The COE is its usual alert self, but this album sounds as if it could have been recorded 40 or 50 years ago, and Villazon often could be singing Verdi rather than Mozart

Andrew Clements

08, Jul, 2015 @3:30 PM

Article image
Classical album of the week: Bates: The (R)evolution of Steve Jobs review – tech god gets an all-American opera
Mason Bates’s first opera, about the Apple founder, is dramatically and musically assured, though there’s a sense he’s cramming too much in

Andrew Clements

12, Jul, 2018 @2:00 PM

Article image
Classical album of the week: Hindemith: Das Marienleben review
Banse and Helmchen’s 1923 version of Hindemith’s song cycle is a glorious achievement

Andrew Clements

26, Jul, 2018 @2:00 PM

Article image
2017 in review: Andrew Clements' top 10 classical CDs
From some delightful Debussy to a bewitching Berlioz opera, via a scintillating set of Schubert sonatas, here are the recordings that stood out this year

Andrew Clements

21, Dec, 2017 @3:00 PM

Article image
Mozart: Don Giovanni Juan – DVD review

Christopher Maltman is sensational as the artist-pornographer Juan in Kasper Holten's film version of Don Giovanni, writes Tim Ashley

Tim Ashley

12, Dec, 2012 @4:55 PM

Article image
Mozart: Don Giovanni – DVD review
Dmitri Tcherniakov’s controversial adaptation wanders too far from Mozart’s original for comfort, writes Tim Ashley

Tim Ashley

28, Nov, 2013 @9:00 PM

Mozart: Le Nozze di Figaro – review

Herbert van Karajan's performance of Le Nozze di Figaro on his return to Vienna was a typically starry one, writes Andrew Clements

Andrew Clements

16, Aug, 2012 @9:30 PM