Carmen review – Bizet meets Busby Berkeley

Royal Opera House, London
Big numbers and bohemian loucheness characterise Barrie Kosky’s uneven production

Barrie Kosky’s new Royal Opera production of Carmen hails from Frankfurt, where it was first seen in June last year. It’s a curious staging, shot through with flashes of brilliance, though by no means cohering into a musical or dramatic whole.

As one might expect, Kosky aspires to postmodern radicalism. He has largely dispensed with Spain, apart from a few flounced frocks and matador uniforms. Don’t expect a tobacco factory or cigarette girls smoking, or indeed anything that smacks of particularly French naturalism. Instead, Kosky pushes towards the trappings of the Broadway musical or the Weimar Republic revue. Katrin Lea Tag’s set is a vast staircase out of Busby Berkeley. The costumes suggest the 1930s. Anna Goryachova’s Carmen is first seen, gamine and androgynous, in a pink toreador’s outfit. Later, her costumes hint at Hollywood or Weimar glamour, with overtones of Dietrich in Sternberg’s Blonde Venus and Louise Brooks as Georg Pabst’s waif-like Lulu in Pandora’s Box.

Anna Goryachova (Carmen), holding rope, in Carmen by Bizet @ Royal Opera House. Directed by Barrie Kosky. Conductor, Jakub Hrusa.
Striking imagery … Anna Goryachova heads the cast in Barrie Kosky’s production. Photograph: Tristram Kenton/The Guardian

Kosky’s choreographer for the big show numbers, of which there are many, is Otto Pichler, who has provided cast, chorus and six dancers with sinewy hand-jiving routines, some of which are very camp, though the Chanson Bohème at the start of act two has wonderful loucheness. Kosky’s imagery is often most striking, however, in the more intimate scenes. In act one, Francesco Meli’s José chillingly controls Carmen after her arrest by pulling her around with ropes from the top of the staircase, while she flails at the bottom. Later, his attempts to prevent her walking up it by standing on her train are the prelude to murder.

Kosky plays fast and loose with the score, arguing that Bizet never made a definitive edition of Carmen. He restores a number of passages cut before the 1875 premiere, so Gyula Nagy’s Moralès gets to sing his act-one couplets about fidelity, and Goryachova gives us both the familiar Habanera and the tarantella setting of the same text, which Bizet excised at the insistence of Célestine Galli-Marié, who created the title role. Kosky has also, however, replaced the dialogue with narration, whispered over a sound system by the actor Claude De Demo, and all too frequently proving intrusive.

Gyula Nagy (Moralès) and Kristina Mkhitaryan (Micaëla) in Carmen by Bizet @ Royal Opera House. Directed by Barrie Kosky.
Gyula Nagy as Moralès and Kristina Mkhitaryan as Micaëla. Photograph: Tristram Kenton/The Guardian

Musically, meanwhile, things are uneven. Goryachova and Meli are more convincing in the later scenes as their relationship sours, than earlier on when we don’t quite understand what draws them together. Goryachova radiates cool poise and self-assurance. Some of her high notes, however, can be a bit unsteady and vocally she’s at her best being suggestive with Kostas Smoriginas’s Escamillo or heaping scorn on Meli as he becomes too possessive. His singing can be ungainly, very loud or very soft, with little in between.

More consistently successful are Smoriginas and Kristina Mkhitaryan as Micaëla. He makes an attractive, silky voiced Escamillo. Mkhitaryan, with her warm even tone, sounds glorious. In the pit, conductor Jakub Hrůša favours extreme speeds; there’s plenty of panache in the dances and ensembles, though he dawdles over both Micaëla’s duet with José in act one and the Flower Song in act two. The Royal Opera Chorus, though, have a terrific time flinging themselves into the big routines with gusto and glee, and their singing is exceptional.

• At the Royal Opera House, London, until 16 March. Box office: 020-7304 4000.


Tim Ashley

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Bizet: Carmen – review
In this recording of Carmen John Eliot Gardiner conducts with fiery precision, while the period sound of the Orchestre Révolutionnaire et Romantique adds touches of rawness to the prevailing sensuality, writes Tim Ashley

Tim Ashley

09, Dec, 2010 @9:45 PM

Article image
Bizet: Carmen – review
It's a shame that married couple Simon Rattle and Magdalena Kožená aren't more daring in Bizet's hot-blooded opera, writes Tim Ashley

Tim Ashley

12, Sep, 2012 @2:59 PM

Article image
La Tragédie de Carmen review – opera on an unforgivingly small scale
Peter Brook’s take on Bizet squeezes all the famous tunes into an economic, stripped-down production for four, but demanded too much of these singers

Erica Jeal

05, Nov, 2017 @2:23 PM

Article image
Carmen review – Mid Wales opera rethink Bizet

Helen Sherman smouldered as the peroxide-blond heroine, but Jonathan Miller's production ultimately lacked fire, writes Rian Evans

Rian Evans

04, Sep, 2014 @12:50 PM

Article image
Fidelio review – Davidsen approaches greatness in uneven production
Tobias Kratzer’s new staging rips Beethoven’s only opera in two to bring contemporary resonance but little of the composer’s original vision, but the singing is superb

Tim Ashley

02, Mar, 2020 @11:17 AM

Article image
Billy Budd review – magnificently sung production is slow to focus
Deborah Warner’s version of Britten’s most conflicted opera takes too long to reach the dramatic intensity its superb singers merit

Andrew Clements

24, Apr, 2019 @11:02 AM

Article image
The week in classical: Carmen; Changing Faces: Stravinsky’s Journey; Satyagraha – review
Performers enjoy a nightly workout in Barrie Kosky’s refreshing if flawed new Royal Opera production

Fiona Maddocks

11, Feb, 2018 @7:30 AM

Article image
The Queen of Spades review – Herheim puts Tchaikovsky centre stage for stimulating frustration
Uninterested in the original story, the director stages the composer’s biography instead – leaving a big hole at the centre of this production

Erica Jeal

14, Jan, 2019 @1:40 PM

Article image
Agrippina review – DiDonato formidable as power-hungry empress
Joyce DiDonato gives one of her finest performances in Barrie Kosky’s witty and unnerving staging of Handel’s opera of political manipulation in ancient Rome

Tim Ashley

24, Sep, 2019 @11:32 AM

Article image
Kát’a Kabanová review – angry and compelling, and musically faultless
Amanda Majeski brings unflinching veracity to Janáček’s tragic heroine, while Edward Gardner - in the pit - is magnificent

Tim Ashley

05, Feb, 2019 @11:38 AM