Così fan tutte review – lovers recoupled in impressive Mozart

Fikret/Mas/Kristoffersen/Sprague/Pizzuti/Vultaggio/RLPO/Pillot
Rubicon


Even the most inspired staging of Così fan tutte leaves a lot of disbelief to be suspended. In Mozart and Da Ponte’s opera, two soldiers are persuaded into a bet that the sisters they love will remain faithful, then lose said bet when they seduce each other’s partners in disguise, somehow unrecognised by the women until the grand reveal in the final scene. Audiences have gone along with the unlikelinesses and the fake moustaches for more than two centuries, because the profound truth this opera tells us about relationships is worth it. But what on earth was Mozart thinking? This recording – billed as “Mozart’s original thoughts re-created and recorded for the first time” – answers some questions, while posing a few more. It is taken from staged performances four years ago by the European Opera Centre, using an edition by Ian Woodfield based on close study of Mozart’s original manuscripts. The young cast don’t all yet have entirely “finished” voices but they work well together, with Nazan Fikret (Fiordiligi) and Alexander Sprague (Ferrando) standing out, and Laurent Pillot draws a lively performance from the Royal Liverpool Philharmonic. For Woodfield, the clues began with the fact that several times the pronouns in the manuscript had been filled in at a later date. Originally, it seems, Mozart intended the couples to start out as the opposite of what we’re used to, and to stay that way throughout. This makes sense, as in the standard version it’s only when the partners are swapped into the “wrong” couples that the musical depictions of each character are quite truthful. There’s also an extra aria for Guglielmo that’s arguably more in character, while the rant against female inconstancy that he usually gets to sing is instead given to bitter old schemer Don Alfonso. And yet Mozart must have realised at some point before the premiere that it was the friends’ betrayal of each other that gives the work its edge, and that the partners must be swapped. Ultimately, neither version is dramatically watertight: Così fan tutte stands as an example of perfect imperfection.

This week’s other classical pick

Mark Viner’s disc of Cécile Chaminade’s piano music is a follow-up to his revelatory disc of Alkan, last year. Few composers could throw off a salon piece as skilfully as Chaminade, but Viner also includes some études and tone poems of depth and Grieg-like soulfulness, all gorgeously played.

Contributor

Erica Jeal

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Così Fan Tutte – review
A sadness seeps into the music as the protagonists' sexual games spiral out of control in this gloriously played performance, writes Tim Ashley

Tim Ashley

31, Jan, 2012 @6:38 PM

Così Fan Tutte | Opera review

Royal Opera House, London
In its latest outing, Jonathan Miller's Così Fan Tutte gives us something more muted than we have experienced for a while, writes Tim Ashley

Tim Ashley

13, Sep, 2010 @8:45 PM

Article image
Così fan tutte review – Nicholas Hytner's irresistible production takes a bow
Hytner’s sunny, unironic staging of Mozart’s problematic comedy – about to tour for a final time – is one of the most intelligent and insightful around

Erica Jeal

08, Oct, 2017 @2:33 PM

Mozart: Così fan tutte – review
This concert recording of Mozart's dark comic masterpiece is full of life, writes Nicholas Kenyon

Nicholas Kenyon

31, Aug, 2013 @11:06 PM

Article image
Mozart: Così fan Tutte review – Currentzis’s take is wilful but fresh
The playing is wonderfully alive, and it’s well worth hearing –even if you won’t want to hear it that often, writes Andrew Clements

Andrew Clements

20, Nov, 2014 @11:24 AM

Article image
Così fan Tutte – review
Even the false noses fall apart in Mozart's visit to Blackpool, writes Rian Evans

Rian Evans

23, May, 2011 @5:20 PM

Article image
Mozart: Zaide CD review – unfinished harem opera reveals its deeply serious side
Ian Page and Classical Opera’s searching version of Mozart’s incomplete work is faithful to Mozart’s intentions, with stark notes of tragedy

Andrew Clements

14, Sep, 2016 @2:30 PM

Article image
Marriage of Figaro review – Ireland's new opera company opens with unfussy Mozart
Irish National Opera’s first bespoke show needed more emotional depth and complexity, but musical standards were high, with Máire Flavin’s Countess and Aoife Miskelly’s Cherubino particular standouts

Andrew Clements

23, Apr, 2018 @7:48 PM

Article image
Così fan Tutte review – impressive ensemble cast focus on the wider questions
Artifice is the key to Jan Philipp Gloger’s stagey production of Mozart’s comic opera, lucidly realised by conductor Semyon Bychkov and a committed team

George Hall

23, Sep, 2016 @12:21 PM

Article image
The Marriage of Figaro review – zippy Mozart for the #metoo era with gender swap
This revival of David McVicar’s wonderful 2006 production sees an uneven cast and John Eliot Gardiner’s conducting sometimes too overbearing

Martin Kettle

02, Jul, 2019 @2:10 PM