The Courteeners review – indie-rock underdogs defy the naysayers

Manchester Arena
The atmosphere is like a football match as this once-maligned band celebrate 10 years at the top with massed chants and singalong choruses

It’s 10 years since a British newspaper declared of the Courteeners debut, St Jude: “I confidently predict that exactly no one will be listening to it in 10 years time.” The quote is now cheekily emblazoned across the vinyl of the new “unplugged” version of the album and was being tweeted by singer Liam Fray this week. The band are entitled to feel vindicated. The intervening decade has seen them haul themselves up from small venues to become one of the biggest bands in the country. Their popularity gets – as Spinal Tap would say – more “selective” as one travels further away from Manchester, but especially in Scotland and the upper half of England they are so huge that this sold out 21,000-seater hometown concert is their smallest in the north-west for some time.

Scant support from radio or media has given them a powerful air of victorious underdogs, and they are greeted like a “people’s band”. The atmosphere is more football match than pop gig, with massed chants, flares (to the chagrin of security), people staggering with trays of beer and a jacket used as a beach ball. The entire crowd sing Oasis’s Rock ‘n’ Roll Star before the band are on, and the suspicion that Courteeners fill an Oasis-sized hole is furthered by chants of “Li-am” (at Fray, not Gallagher) and Fray’s entrance in the kind of bizarre, outsized, hooded outfit sported by his namesake.

The yearning for an Oasis-type, anthemic, communal experience is part of it, but musically, Courteeners offer a broad-brush, one-size-fits-all amalgam of various other indie rock touchstones: Arctic Monkeys, the Libertines, the Smiths and the Stone Roses. In Fray, they have a lyricist capable of Alex Turner/Mark E Smith-type acidic, off-kilter observations, but who can also speak directly to his constituency about their lives. The lovely Are You in Love With a Notion? tells of a girl planning to to quit Debenhams and elope. It’s an aural kitchen sink drama with its note of caution – “Have you really thought this through? / Is he really the one for you?” – delivered in a singsong chorus. Elsewhere, lines such as “You’re having a shit night, but I’m having a ball” or “They do my ‘ead in” are perhaps less poetic, but Fray effortlessly applies for the position of working-class hero: “Has anyone got work in the morning?” he asks the crowd. “Well, don’t go in. Tell them Fray said it was OK.”

Rudimentary but highly impassioned … the Courteeners.
Rudimentary but highly impassioned … the Courteeners. Photograph: Michael_Clement/Michael Clement

Like Smith, the bearded 32-year-old understands the power of creating a feeling of unity against everybody else, dedicating songs to “anyone who’s had someone look down on them” and the aforementioned newspaper while stopping just short of becoming boorish. No one seems to notice that not all the songs from St Jude hold up too well, but the likes of Not Nineteen Forever and the later The Opener – a love letter to Manchester via the thoughts of a man who’s worked away, and another chant-friendly singalong – generate extraordinary levels of crowd euphoria.

Although Fray does an acoustic solo section and there are forensic traces of funk and disco, the formula never strays far from singable, rudimentary but highly impassioned indie rock and perhaps it doesn’t need to: the Ford Cortina they got their punning name from was also ridiculed by critics, but became Britain’s best-selling car.


Dave Simpson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Courteeners: More. Again. Forever. review | Alexis Petridis's album of the week
Without abandoning the well-executed anthemics that form the basis of their success, the Manchester band’s sixth album weighs in on the subjects of ageing, alcohol and mental health

Alexis Petridis

16, Jan, 2020 @12:00 PM

Article image
The Courteeners review – homecoming heroes savour their big moment
Liam Fray and gang’s brisk guitar anthems and dry lyrics fill an Oasis-shaped hole, though their singalongs can feel formulaic

Dave Simpson

08, Jun, 2015 @1:32 PM

Article image
The Courteeners: 'Kids see passion in us'
The anthems, the bragging, the unwavering self-belief – Courteeners frontman Liam Fray has won himself a lot of fans, and a lot of enemies too. Caroline Sullivan finds out why

Caroline Sullivan

04, Mar, 2010 @9:45 PM

Article image
Kendal Calling review – indie singalongs in a merry Cumbrian mudbath
Lowther Deer Park, Cumbria
In a part of the UK not best served for live music, the Libertines served up a double whammy and northern frontwomen showed the blokes on the main stage how it’s done

Dave Simpson

30, Jul, 2018 @12:42 PM

Article image
Wild Beasts review – heart-racing, poignant farewell from indie originals
This glorious final gig by the fearless Cumbrians almost makes you wish bands would break up more often

Laura Snapes

18, Feb, 2018 @1:38 PM

Article image
The Wombats review – all hail the quintessential middling indie band
When they’re good, they’re OK. When they’re bad they’re woeful. But throughout, the indie-poppers put on a jovial, energetic show

Malcolm Jack

25, Jan, 2019 @3:19 PM

Article image
Rockaway Beach festival review – a blast of indie retox and roll
John Cale and Jesus and Mary Chain line up with newbies Black Country, New Road and Nova Twins in a January festival as bracing as the wind whipping off the Channel

Ben Beaumont-Thomas

13, Jan, 2020 @12:26 PM

Article image
Snail Mail review – vulnerability and honesty from teen indie rocker
Despite some teething problems on her first major tour, Lindsey Jordan delivers emotive anthems with lyrical flair

Dave Simpson

23, Oct, 2018 @3:03 PM

Article image
Y Not review – fast-rising festival gets stuck in the indie mud
Acts like Wolf Alice are a welcome break from the hordes of white blokes with guitars, who don’t reflect the eclectic taste of the crowd

Daniel Dylan Wray

29, Jul, 2019 @10:28 AM

Article image
The Courteeners: proof that four guys can still shake the world …

… for a little while at least. How the moody Mancs prove there's still life in mainstream rock

Mark Beaumont

15, Feb, 2013 @1:00 PM