Le Grand Macabre review – Sellars brings muddle but Rattle, beauty

Barbican, London
Peter Sellars’s reading of Ligeti’s opera as a post-Chernobyl parable weakens its anarchic humour; but, under Simon Rattle, the LSO and some very fine soloists, the music is radiant

London should have seen Peter Sellars’ take on György Ligeti’s only opera in 1999, when the production he had unveiled at the Salzburg festival two years earlier was due to come to Covent Garden. But the then newly renovated Royal Opera House was still having technical teething problems and the show was cancelled. We’ve finally seen it now, though, more or less: the semi-staging that Sellars has devised for the London Symphony Orchestra’s performances with Simon Rattle follows the same 20-year-old line, setting Le Grand Macabre in a world of nuclear catastrophe.

After the Salzburg production, for which Ligeti made the total revision of the score that’s now definitive, the composer publicly repudiated the reading of his stage work as a post-Chernobyl parable. Two decades on, Sellars, however, has stuck to his approach. But with the stage strewn with drums of radioactive waste, characters wearing white coats or decontamination suits and backed by video footage of nuclear power stations and mushroom clouds, demonstrations against Trident and survivors sifting through the devastation of Hiroshima or Nagasaki, the whole thing seems muddled. Is this a critique of nuclear power or of nuclear weapons, or is it just saying, in a kneejerk way, that everything “nuclear” is bad?

None of this helps the dramatic coherence of Le Grand Macabre either. The production by La Fura dels Baus staged at ENO seven years ago suggested the score had lost its subversive edge. Nothing in this performance contradicts that; in fact, it undermines what dramatic coherence there is, while the po-faced sermonising suffocates the anarchic black humour that is such a vital ingredient. From the grand macabre himself, Nekrotzar, who arrives in Breughelland to bring an end to everything but is too drunk to do his job properly, to the lovers Amando and Amanda, too wrapped up in each other to notice that anything apocalyptic is happening at all, everybody in the opera is a cartoon character. Turning them into nuclear operatives, besuited apparatchiks and victims adds nothing.

Musical triumph … Peter Hoare (Piet the Pot), Frode Olsen (Astradamors), Pavlo Hunka (Nekrotzar) and conductor Simon Rattle.
A musical triumph … Peter Hoare (Piet the Pot), Frode Olsen (Astradamors), Pavlo Hunka (Nekrotzar) and conductor Simon Rattle. Photograph: Tristram Kenton/The Guardian

Musically, though, the performance under Rattle is superb. From the opening toccata played on car horns which parodies the canzona from Monteverdi’s Orfeo, to the radiant passacaglia that supports the final scene, everything in Ligeti’s score is heard more vividly than it could ever be in an opera house, and the playing of the LSO is astoundingly good. So, too, are most of the solo performances – from Pavlo Hunka’s lugubrious Nekrotzar and Peter Hoare’s drink-sodden Piet the Pot, Frode Olsen and Heidi Melton as Astradamors and Mescalina the couple whose relationship is conducted entirely in S&M terms, to Ronnita Miller and Elizabeth Watts as the young lovers.

Only Audrey Luna as Gepopo, the chief of police, does not make the most of her coloratura nonsense aria. It’s normally one of the show-stopping moments, but then Sellars has Luna sing from a hospital bed, complete with one of his trademark drips. As too often in this production, the tired old message has to come first.

Contributor

Andrew Clements

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Debussy: Pelléas et Mélisande CD review – luxury casting and vivid performances under Rattle and Sellars

Erica Jeal

05, Oct, 2017 @2:30 PM

Article image
The Cunning Little Vixen review – Rattle and Sellars banish cuteness but drama and beauty shine
A strong cast and outstanding playing by the LSO power Janáček’s bucolic foray in a concert staging under video projections of teeming nature and humanity

Tim Ashley

28, Jun, 2019 @5:07 PM

Article image
OAE/Rattle/Sellars review – commitment and focus sharpen Bach's Passion
Peter Sellars’ staging of the St John Passion was magnificently realised by a cast led by Mark Padmore’s Evangelist and Roderick Williams’s Christus

Tim Ashley

03, Apr, 2019 @2:39 PM

Article image
LSO/Simon Rattle review – glorious season finale
Pianist Krystian Zimerman reunited with the conductor for a finely tuned programme than ranged from Rachmaninov to Beethoven

Andrew Clements

01, Jul, 2016 @12:16 PM

Article image
LSO/Rattle review – celebrating Bernstein's irrepressible versatility
The Leonard Bernstein centenary tribute ranged from his profoundly serious symphony The Age of Anxiety to the frothy, uncomplicated Wonderful Town

Andrew Clements

17, Dec, 2017 @1:50 PM

Article image
The Hogboon review – lively launch for Maxwell Davies' uneven folk opera
Professional and amateur performers join Simon Rattle and the LSO for opera premiere

George Hall

27, Jun, 2016 @11:26 AM

Article image
A Trip to the Moon review – majestic mystery in moonish
Simon Rattle navigates the LSO’s community choir through rocket crashes, kidnapping aliens and the terrific singing of a lyrical lunar language, in this family-friendly space opera

Tim Ashley

10, Jul, 2017 @11:57 AM

Article image
Simon Rattle and Peter Sellars on Pelléas et Mélisande: 'It's as creepy as Hitchcock'
The orchestra doubles as a forest and the heroine dies among the violins … Peter Sellars and Simon Rattle reveal how they’re taking Debussy’s dark and disturbing opera Pelléas et Mélisande to new heights

Interviews by Tom Service

07, Jan, 2016 @7:00 AM

Article image
LSO/Rattle; Adès Curates review – Berlioz's Damnation polishes halo for star conductor
Simon Rattle’s Faust was seamless and vivid, with astonishing precision from the LSO’s Chorus; Adès’s selection for Guildhall students was rather piecemeal

Erica Jeal

20, Sep, 2017 @1:07 PM

Article image
Pelléas et Mélisande review – Rattle's moving statement of intent
Preserving the power of Debussy’s symbolist masterpiece with wonderful subtlety, Simon Rattle and Peter Sellars go headstrong into a bright future with the London Symphony Orchestra

Andrew Clements

10, Jan, 2016 @2:43 PM