The Winter's Tale review – striking sounds but not enough fury in new Shakespearean opera

Coliseum, London
Rory Kinnear debuts as director for English National Opera in Ryan Wigglesworth’s accomplished first opera, but the inventive music fails to take charge of the story

Ryan Wigglesworth says he has been obsessed with Shakespeare’s late play for 20 years, and that made The Winter’s Tale the obvious choice of subject for his first opera. It’s the product of his four years as English National Opera’s composer-in-residence, and he conducted the premiere himself, in a production by Rory Kinnear, making his debut as a director.

The libretto comes directly from the play text; Wigglesworth has done the job himself, preserving the essence of the plot and dropping a few characters (most notably Autolycus) in the process. The result – three acts lasting just over two hours including one interval – is certainly taut enough, though at the same time some of the texture of the drama and the depth of its characterisations have gone. The score ought to compensate for that – that’s part of the point of turning any play into an opera – but for all the striking orchestral moments, I’m not sure it ever really does, even though the dramatic grip tightens the longer it goes on.

The first act in Sicilia deals with terrible things – Leontes’ mounting, unreasoning jealousy, the death of his son and the apparent death of Hermione. But it is too staid and evenly paced to convey the psychological horror of what is happening, and falls so easily into the conventional template of many other well-behaved British operas of the last 70 years. Even though Wigglesworth’s orchestral writing especially is always transparent and inventive, there’s little sense of his music aspiring to anything more than accompanying the drama; it never takes charge, and because of the sheer conciseness of it all, the singers rarely get any set pieces or moments in which they can define who they really are.

In the second half – the second act set in Bohemia, the third back in Sicilia – the drama does take over, with the music reinforcing it more convincingly. There are further striking ideas in the orchestra, and an effective, brief monologue of self-reproach for Leontes, though ultimately even that doesn’t quite carry the emotional weight it should. Iain Paterson always makes Leontes a powerful presence, though portraying both him and Leigh Melrose’s Polixenes as modern-day military despots rather plays down the differences between the states they rule.

Otherwise the production is mostly sensible and effective in Vicki Mortimer’s circular set. It conveys the narrative without fuss, even if there’s a tendency to over-busyness at times, as if Kinnear feels that because the score calls for a chorus (sparingly used, but still a bit of an indulgence on Wigglesworth’s part) he has to use them as extras too. That becomes increasingly distracting, right up to the final scene, when Leontes, Hermione and Perdita seem to be at least provisionally reconciled.

Musically, the performances are uniformly excellent. As Hermione, Sophie Bevan gets only a few soaring phrases to really reveal anything about herself; Susan Bickley’s superb Paulina unswervingly upholds the core decency of the story, and Samantha Price and Anthony Gregory make fresh-voiced lovers, Perdita and Florizel. It’s all very accomplished, but really an opera has to be something more than just setting a play to music.

In rep until 14 March.

Contributor

Andrew Clements

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Lulu review – Kentridge makes Berg's opera a serious visual feast
William Kentridge and conductor Mark Wigglesworth underplay the humour as Brenda Rae proves a tireless, enigmatic heart to a production awash with projected imagery

Andrew Clements

10, Nov, 2016 @4:35 PM

Article image
Julietta – opera review

Martinů's most celebrated opera is rarely performed, but ENO's new version is a triumph, writes Andrew Clements

Andrew Clements

18, Sep, 2012 @11:12 AM

Article image
Partenope review – Handel on a night out with beardy bohemians
Despite the culottes and mustachios, ENO’s revival of its 2008 production retains enough substance to back up its arch styling

Erica Jeal

16, Mar, 2017 @11:37 AM

Article image
The Day After review – devastation, dead cats and godlike grandeur
English National Opera’s rehearsal space becomes a post-apocalyptic crater in an imaginative and strongly sung production of Jonathan Dove’s chamber opera

George Hall

29, May, 2017 @1:09 PM

Article image
Rigoletto review – ENO pumps up the volume on Verdi's violent tragedy
This revival of Jonathan Miller’s iconic New York mafiosi staging is as dramatic and complex as ever, even if the orchestra could usefully turn it down a little

Tim Ashley

03, Feb, 2017 @12:15 PM

Article image
The Way Back Home review – a pacy opera for kids
The ENO’s first production for children, based on Oliver Jeffers’s popular story, feels like 50 minutes inside a noisy but fun picture book, writes Erica Jeal

Erica Jeal

14, Dec, 2014 @3:51 PM

Article image
Don Giovanni review – Richard Jones takes us far from Mozart with touches of brilliance and BDSM
Jones’s new staging for English National Opera delivers clever insights and a shock twist but ducks the opera’s complexities and, at points, flies in the face of the music’s logic

Tim Ashley

01, Oct, 2016 @12:55 PM

Article image
Madam Butterfly review – Minghella's production still looks good but the words are lost
With its cherry blossoms and origami birds, this 11-year-old production is strikingly beautiful, and Rena Harms and David Butt Philip give strong performances

Erica Jeal

17, May, 2016 @3:49 PM

Article image
Charlie Parker's Yardbird review – beauty, anger and poetry, but the jazz great's genius eludes us
Daniel Schnyder’s ambitious classical-jazz fusion opera features a remarkable central performance from tenor Lawrence Brownlee

Tim Ashley

10, Jun, 2017 @5:28 PM

Candide – review

Candide is remarkable – it can transcend the shortcomings of any performance, writes Andrew Clements

Andrew Clements

07, Jun, 2011 @5:28 PM