2017 in review: Andrew Clements' top 10 classical CDs

From some delightful Debussy to a bewitching Berlioz opera, via a scintillating set of Schubert sonatas, here are the recordings that stood out this year

The imminent collapse of the classical recording industry has been predicted so regularly and so tediously over the last two decades that each year in which it remains in rude health seems like a bonus. Of course it evolves, as all cultural industries do, but while the predominance of the previously all-conquering multinational groups – such as Sony Classical, Warner Classics and Universal (Deutsche Grammophon and Decca) – continues to diminish, and the number of leading artists exclusively contracted to them declines, the vigour of newly created labels, often tailored to a niche, continues to generate a healthy spread of interesting releases.

Still very much with us too are CDs themselves. In the classical market at least, there remains a lot of ground for digital downloads to make up and there is little sign so far of discs being decisively superseded.

But the amount of the existing repertory made available online increases steadily, and the recent decision of ECM to make its entire catalogue available on Spotify shows the way that this forward-looking label thinks things are going. ECM’s output remains gloriously catholic – everything from medieval songs to 21st-century scores – but its faithful support for particular composers is admirable too, and the best example of that loyalty this year was its magnificent three-disc set devoted to György Kurtág’s vocal and ensemble works, a survey ranging across more than five decades of the Hungarian composer’s creative life in authoritative Dutch performances conducted by Reinbert de Leeuw.

Magnificent … György Kurtág.
Magnificent … György Kurtág. Photograph: Attila Kisbenedek/AFP/Getty Images

Winter & Winter is another label with a reputation for championing a quirky roster of contemporary composers, one of whom is Hans Abrahamsen. Its collection of Abrahamsen’s four string quartets, magisterially played by the Arditti Quartet, follows on from the releases of his elusive ensemble piece Schnee and the entrancingly beautiful song cycle Let Me Tell You. NMC continues its steadfast support for British composers, most notably this year with a bewitching disc of Simon Holt’s concertos – including the percussion piece A Table of Noises, and Witness to a Snow Miracle, for violin and orchestra – while a newer, British-based label, Another Timbre, offers a rather different perspective on the music being written today. My personal discovery of 2017 was the insistently haunting music of the US-born, Canadian-based Linda Catlin Smith, both in concert at the Huddersfield festival and on Drifter, Another Timbre’s disc of her chamber music, which includes two string quartets and a piano quintet.

If there’s one area of the repertory that has declined on disc, it is mainstream opera. There may be plenty of works from the 17th and 18th centuries still being explored, but new versions of later repertory pieces are much more sporadic now, and far more likely to have been recorded in the concert hall or opera house than in bespoke studio sessions, which have become financially unfeasible. Audio-only releases are now significantly outnumbered by DVDs of fully staged productions, too, even if those are sometimes of dubious quality. That made Erato’s Strasbourg-sourced version of Berlioz’s Les Troyens particularly noteworthy this year; new versions of repertory operas rarely seem to rival let alone supplant the established classic versions, but this Trojans, taken from concert performances by about as a good cast as could be assembled today and conducted by John Nelson, really has done that.

Raw-edged … Isabelle Faust.
Raw-edged … Isabelle Faust. Photograph: Felix Broede

Not that many new recordings of the mainstream orchestral repertory challenge what is already available either, especially when many classic recordings from the last 50 years are now available remastered and repackaged in bargain sets. For those familiar symphonies and concertos, only something really special is likely to upset longstanding recommendations – recordings like Isabelle Faust’s raw-edged, period-instrument performance of the Mendelssohn Violin Concerto, on Harmonia Mundi, with its minimal vibrato and generous portamenti, and Pablo Heras-Casado conducting the Freiburg Baroque Orchestra.

While the use of period instruments is taken for granted in many areas of the operatic and orchestral repertory right up to the early 19th century, and even into the early 20th century with the performances by François-Xavier Roth and his orchestra Les Siècles, the 19th-century keyboard repertory is proving more resistant; the Steinway still rules supreme for a huge proportion of new piano discs. Yet there are signs of change even there, and Krystian Zimerman’s wonderfully poetic accounts of two of Schubert’s late sonatas (Deutsche Grammophon), his first solo-piano disc in more than 20 years, uses a specially made keyboard that he designed himself, to enable the effortlessly light touch and subtle shading that illuminate these performances. The other outstanding piano disc of the year, Angela Hewitt’s second volume of Domenico Scarlatti’s sonatas (Hyperion), does use a conventional grand, though that is a Fazioli instrument rather than the ubiquitous Steinway.

Outstanding … Angela Hewitt.
Outstanding … Angela Hewitt. Photograph: Keith Saunders

But mainstream recordings still come along that would have stood out in any era. The Trio Zimmermann’s performance of Schoenberg’s daunting String Trio, coupled with two trios by Hindemith on BIS, is arguably the finest yet recorded, while Erato’s French-sourced Debussy collection, comprising the three late sonatas and the very early Piano Trio, with a starry lineup of instrumentalists that includes violinist Renaud Capuçon, flautist Emmanuel Pahud and pianist Bertrand Chamayou, is pure delight from beginning to end.

Top 10

1. Kurtág: Complete Works for Ensemble and Choir (ECM)

2. Berlioz: Les Troyens (Warner Classics)

3. Krystian Zimerman: Schubert Piano Sonatas (Deutsche Grammophon)

4. Debussy: Sonatas and Trio (Erato)

5. Holt: A Table of Noises (NMC)

6. Isabelle Faust: Mendelssohn Violin Concerto (Harmonia Mundi)

7. Schoenberg & Hindemith String Trios (BIS)

8. Angela Hewitt: Scarlatti Sonatas Vol 2 (Hyperion)

9. Abrahamsen: String Quartets (Winter & Winter)

10. Linda Catlin Smith: Drifter (Another Timbre)


Andrew Clements

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The top 10 classical shows of 2017
A magisterial Monteverdi cycle, Oliver Knussen’s adventures in haiku – and a hero’s return for Simon Rattle. Our critic picks his highlights

Andrew Clements

18, Dec, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
The best albums of 2017: the full list
St Vincent tops our countdown of this year’s most outstanding sounds, from complex rap to moody rock, alt-R&B, inventive grime and more

05, Dec, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
The best albums of 2017, No 1: St Vincent – Masseduction
Annie Clark makes a rock-star power play by embracing thrilling glam traditions while producing something strange, new and unequivocally moving

Rachel Aroesti

22, Dec, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
The best albums of 2017, No 2: Kendrick Lamar – Damn
With an incendiary beginning and deeply personal social commentary, Lamar’s fourth album reveals an artist at his real and metaphorical peak

Ben Beaumont-Thomas

21, Dec, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
The best albums of 2017, No 5: Perfume Genius – No Shape
Mike Hadreas’ genre-switching fourth album was breathtakingly original, his lyrics of personal pain spiking a shimmeringly sublime score

Kitty Empire

18, Dec, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
The best albums of 2017, No 9: Kelela – Take Me Apart
Alternative R&B found its emotional side in this striking study of a breakup, from separation to reconciliation to renunciation

Paul MacInnes

12, Dec, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
The best albums of 2017, No 8: Thundercat – Drunk
Deliciously surreal funk, squelchy soft rock, fart noise and a homage to his cat: ace of bass Thundercat’s breakthrough album travels from consciousness to conscience

Kate Hutchinson

13, Dec, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
The best albums of 2017, No 4: Lorde – Melodrama
The singer’s soaring overnight success should have made her second album a catastrophe. In fact it was a work of insight, strength and gloriously self-aware wit

Alexis Petridis

19, Dec, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
The best albums of 2017, No 3: SZA – Ctrl
This nakedly honest debut album, told defiantly from a female point of view, signalled an artist in complete ctrl

Tim Jonze

20, Dec, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
The best albums of 2017, No 10: Richard Dawson – Peasant
The Newcastle singer-songwriter’s avant-folk stories of a troubled medieval age have striking relevance to our own fraying society

Gwilym Mumford

11, Dec, 2017 @6:00 AM