SCO/Storgards: Missa Solemnis review – an intimate heart-to-heart with Beethoven

Usher Hall, Edinburgh
Even with the Scottish Chamber Orchestra bulked up for the occasion, this was a reflective performance of the mass, at its most powerful in the quiet passages

Beethoven famously wished it to go “from the heart to the heart” but in truth it can be difficult to love the mighty edifice that is the Missa Solemnis.

There’s plenty to admire in its audacity of scale and breadth of ideas but even the greatest performances leave one with the nagging suspicion that the whole does not quite add up to the sum of its parts.

If the Scottish Chamber Orchestra and John Storgards didn’t ultimately dispel this impression, they did make a compelling case that Beethoven’s greatest thoughts aren’t to be found in the bombast but in the quiet, reflective moments. Even with a bulked-up SCO and expanded chorus this was still a smaller scale, more intimate performance than most. Not that it was devoid of grandeur, as Storgards demonstrated from the outset with a Kyrie that was expansively phrased and measured. However, what lingered in the memory were the quiet moments: the delicate woodwind tracery weaving around the solo quartet in the Et Incarnatus Est and the transparent, glassy textures of the vibrato-free strings in the opening of the Sanctus.

It didn’t always work: there were times one missed the easy power of a larger ensemble and places where an otherwise excellent SCO Chorus struggled under the sheer weight, particularly towards the end of the unremitting Credo. But with Storgards bringing an overarching coherence to the work, an elegant quartet of soloists – Rachel Willis-Sorensen, Karen Cargill, Jeremy Ovenden and Neal Davies – and a silver-toned solo from leader Benjamin Marquise Gilmore, the trade-off of intimacy for might didn’t leave one feeling short-changed.


Rowena Smith

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Beethoven: Missa Solemnis – review
John Eliot Gardiner's detailed new recording of Beethoven's great choral monument certainly doesn't hang about, writes Andrew Clements

Andrew Clements

02, Jan, 2014 @10:00 PM

Beethoven: Missa Solemnis – review
For a conductor often associated with slowish speeds, this idiosyncratic Missa Solemnis is surprisingly uptempo and volatile, writes Tim Ashley

Tim Ashley

12, Apr, 2012 @8:46 PM

Article image
Royal Northern Sinfonia/Zehetmair review – this Missa Solemnis was as Beethoven wished
Zehetmair teased out the anxiety in Beethoven's mass and obeyed his instruction to perform it 'from the heart', writes Alfred Hickling

Alfred Hickling

08, Jun, 2014 @2:38 PM

Article image
BBC Philharmonic/Noseda at the Proms review – Missa Solemnis shakes with emotion
Choristers and soloists brought freshness and precision to the Beethoven mass in conductor Gianandrea Noseda’s keenly expressive interpretation

Erica Jeal

20, Jul, 2016 @11:42 AM

Article image
SCO/Robin Ticciati review – poised pairing of Schubert and Beethoven
The conductor brings his typical sweep, while the Scottish Chamber Orchestra provided nimble support to soloist Magnus Lindberg

Kate Molleson

08, Mar, 2015 @4:45 PM

Article image
SCO/Ticciati review – expansive, revelatory Bruckner
Robin Ticciati and the Scottish Chamber Orchestra lent limpid refinement to Bruckner’s unrelentingly heavy Teutonic stodge in a compact concert

Kate Molleson

06, Nov, 2016 @2:57 PM

Article image
Beethoven: Missa Solemnis CD review – Nikolaus Harnoncourt's masterly final recording

Erica Jeal

21, Jul, 2016 @2:15 PM

Article image
SCO/Knussen review – featherweight and fizzing for Mendelssohn, Henze and Martin Suckling
Oliver Knussen’s lightness and lack of pomp created an evening of wondrous moments, crowned by charismatic viola player Jane Atkins’s Britten

Kate Molleson

24, Apr, 2016 @3:13 PM

CD: Beethoven: Missa solemnis: Soustrot et al


Edward Greenfield

06, Dec, 2002 @1:59 AM

SCO/Benjamin – review
George Benjamin whipped the Scottish Chamber Orchestra into a refined performance, writes Kate Molleson

Kate Molleson

29, Apr, 2013 @5:48 PM