Il Tabarro/Suor Angelica review – Opera North illuminate Puccini's dark visions of loss and pain

Grand theatre, Leeds
Michael Barker-Caven skilfully presents this dark double-bill as dual reflections on a single theme, as the outstanding Anne Sophie Duprels leads a strong cast

Opera North mastered the art of the aperitif in 2004 with Eight Little Greats, an operatic taster season in which you could mix and match one-act masterpieces of less than an hour’s duration. David Pountney’s production of Il Tabarro by Puccini was one of the highlights – or low-lights, considering how gloomy it was – and is well worth a second look. But the real draw is the company’s first production of Puccini’s only all-female opera.

It could be argued that Opera North have missed a trick in not putting together all three of the dramatic panels Puccini conceived as a single entity in 1918 (the company does have a Gianni Schicchi in stock, which entered the repertoire last year). Perhaps a complete Trittico is still to come. But Michael Barker-Caven’s production succeeds in emphasising how these two short operas provide dual reflections on a single theme: the pain of a lost child kept alive in the memory of a loveless stevedore and a penitent nun.

If Pountney’s concept for Il Tabarro was dark, Barker-Caven’s revival is, if anything, even darker; presenting this grubby tale of sexual jealousy among Parisian barge workers as if it were Puccini’s On the Waterfront. Giselle Allen’s Giorgetta smoulders with the circumscription of life “between the bed and the stove” (which in Johan Engels’s unremitting design is actually a dirty black shipping container); David Butt Philip unleashes a revelatory top end as her lover, Luigi; and Ivan Inverardi’s Michele prowls around in Brando-esque fashion, ominously muttering that he could have been a contender.

Barker-Caven is the artistic director of the Civic Theatre in Dublin and has spent most of his career in Ireland, so it is perhaps not surprising that his reading of Suor Angelica could be taken as a reflection on the miseries of the Magdalen laundries. The convent, in Hannah Clark’s design, is an iron-grey place full of the sound of suppressed desire and unanswered prayer. Jac van Steen’s conducting implies the sour undertow beneath the shimmer of pious flutes and seraphic strings; even the depiction of golden light playing in the cloister fountain has no sooner been established than it appears to curdle. The sense of loss is palpable.

Soraya Mafi sings Sister Genoveva’s sad recollection of her favourite lamb in terms that suggest that all of these women may have had their babies taken away from them. Patricia Bardon’s throatily sung, power-dressed Princess takes sadistic pleasure in informing her cloistered niece that she will never see her illegitimate son again – although the psychedelic video design that accompanies Angelica’s dying vision suggests otherwise. Anne Sophie Duprels is outstanding in the title role, despite delivering her big moment, Senza Mamma, face down on the floor. Among an impressive ensemble cast, there is simply nun finer.

• In rep at the Grand theatre, Leeds, until 26 October. Box office: 0844-848 2720. Then touring the UK until 2 December.

Contributor

Alfred Hickling

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Opera North: Billy Budd review – these seas are too calm
Orpha Phelan’s staging for Opera North needs more energy to fully cohere, but there are strong performances from Alan Oke as Vere and Roderick Williams as a sensitively sung Billy

Andrew Clements

19, Oct, 2016 @10:40 AM

Article image
Turandot review – Opera North show how you solve a problem like Puccini
This semi-staged version of Puccini’s experimental, grandiose final opera makes it more like an oratorio, and puts a bloodthirsty chorus at the centre of the action

Alfred Hickling

30, Apr, 2017 @1:10 PM

Article image
The Commission/Café Kafka, Royal Opera/Opera North/Aldeburgh Music – review

Two new works by Elspeth Brooke and Francisco Coll don't quite hold focus, but the performers are consistently strong, writes Erica Jeal

Erica Jeal

18, Mar, 2014 @2:52 PM

Article image
Das Rheingold review – Opera North's back-to-basics Wagner feels like a liberation
This was a concentrated and riveting realisation of the first part of Wagner’s Ring Cycle, with Jo Pohleim’s Alberich and Wolfgang Ablinger-Sperrhacke’s Loge particularly strong

Martin Kettle

29, Jun, 2016 @1:17 PM

Article image
Into the Woods review – Opera North casts spell on Sondheim fairytale
The puppetry alone is enough to recommend this magical take on Stephen Sondheim’s musical, but Opera North choristers are the real ace up the sleeve

Alfred Hickling

12, Jun, 2016 @11:24 AM

Article image
Opera North: Andrea Chénier review – great singing and impeccably judged conducting
Rafael Rojas, Annemarie Kremer and Robert Hayward give riveting performances in Annabel Arden’s thoughtful new production of Giordano’s French revolution-set tragedy

Alfred Hickling

20, Jan, 2016 @5:11 PM

Article image
Pagliacci, L'Enfant et les Sortilèges review – Opera North's 'Little Greats' series looks to be well named
The company’s season of short operas is less adventurous than its previous iteration, but there is little to fault in the execution

Tim Ashley

18, Sep, 2017 @2:29 PM

Article image
Il tabarro/Suor Angelica; Don Giovanni review – high piety and low pleasures
Opera North delivers a devastating Puccini double bill, as a brutal new Don Giovanni turns heads at ENO

Fiona Maddocks

09, Oct, 2016 @6:40 AM

Article image
A Little Night Music review – Opera North brings musical gains but dramatic loss
The new staging of Sondheim’s musical is a delicious and sweet treat, but with the songs rendered so beautifully, something of the work’s psychological edge is lost

Mark Lawson

05, Jul, 2021 @8:58 AM

Article image
Siegfried/ Götterdämmerung review – not just praiseworthy but wonderful
The power and greed of Wagner’s Ring have never rung more true than in this imaginatively staged and beautifully played production

Martin Kettle

04, Jul, 2016 @12:48 PM