Simple pleasures? – in praise of Dvořák's music

Sometimes dismissed for having little to offer intellectually, the Czech composer’s populism, heart and imagination will instead be celebrated by Mark Elder and the Hallé in this month’s Dvořák festival

“Music should always be joyful, even when it is tragic. He is a happy man who leaves such a legacy behind him.” So wrote Bohuslav Martinů of his Czech compatriot Antonín Dvořák.

Over the next few weeks, Manchester’s Hallé Orchestra is staging a festival of seven concerts devoted entirely to that legacy. But why, of all composers, does Dvořák need such exclusive attention? Do the hugely famous Slavonic Dances, the Cello Concerto or the New World Symphony – works featured in the festival – really need any more exposure? What is it about Dvořák’s music that merits such total immersion?

“Dvořák was a populist in the best possible way”, says the Hallé’s music director, Sir Mark Elder. “He was one of the great tunesmiths and his music has such colour. Being Czech, dance was central to his conception of being a musician, something audiences all around the world relate to. Some of my fellow conductors feel Dvořák’s music has nothing to offer intellectually – one even told me ‘it isn’t dirty enough’ – but I love it, and it’s enormously enjoyable to perform – and of course, to listen to.”

But the Hallé’s festival isn’t exclusively focused on the tried and tested bits of the Dvořák canon. There’s a chance to hear the charming Moravian Duets which may have established Dvořák’s international reputation, but today are only rarely performed in this country. The same is true of the Piano Concerto, a piece some regard as a curate’s egg. “It just needs a good advocate,” says Elder. “I know pianists who adore it, including Stephen Hough and Garrick Ohlsson. The piece just needs a bit of tender love and care. I have high hopes we can make some new friends for it.”

The title of the festival, Nature, Life and Love, is taken from the subtitles of a trilogy of overtures: In Nature’s Realm, Carnival and Otello. Dvořák composed them shortly before leaving Bohemia in 1892 to become director of New York’s National Conservatory of Music (he became a considerable celebrity in the city). Musically united by a recurring pastoral theme (which is heard gorgeously in Carnival as a memory of another, distant world), they are nevertheless seldom performed as the triptych Dvořák intended.

Some might lament a lost opportunity to hear Dvořák’s earlier symphonies, particularly the underrated Third, Fifth and Sixth; the festival instead features the composer’s last three symphonies, which are all hugely famous. In character these works are distinctive, representing different aspects of their composer’s personality: the Brahms-influenced Seventh is a turbulent affair (though, as Martinů noted, nevertheless ultimately joyful); the Eighth pastoral and high-spirited (it’s even been described as the pigeon-fancying Dvořák’s “birdsong symphony”); while the Ninth, the iconic New World, was a product of Dvořák’s American years. A special event, Beyond the Score, led by Gerard McBurney on 7 May, promises to place the work in enlightening contexts.

After returning to Bohemia from America, Dvořák became preoccupied with Karel Erben’s nationalistic collection of folk-ballads, Kytice. These stories rival the Brothers Grimm in their delight in the macabre and inspired four superbly graphic symphonic poems – described by Janáček as “the most Czech of Dvořák’s works”. The longest and perhaps the greatest of them is The Golden Spinning Wheel, a piece based on a story Elder describes as “particularly bloody, with its countless severed limbs”. This magnificently orchestrated work, however, does have a happy ending.

The festival culminates with another rarely performed work, the oratorio Saint Ludmila, an expression of Dvořák’s profound religious faith and patriotism performed in a newly commissioned English translation by David Pountney. This gargantuan piece was premiered at the 1886 Leeds festival and features some of Dvořák’s most rousing, full-throated choral writing, as well as exquisite arias and ensemble pieces. Though Dvořák had the English taste for Handel in mind as he wrote it, he consistently reveals his own character as a distinctively Czech melodist.

The son of a butcher and innkeeper, Dvořák’s success and fame were hard earned. Brahms, Janáček, Sibelius and even the young Schoenberg admired him, though under Czechoslovakia’s communist regime his music was officially regarded – not least by the influential culture and education minister Zdenék Nejedlý – as inferior to that of Smetana. “Dvořák presents a massive obstacle,” Nejedlý wrote in 1913, “which any young Czech musician must remove from his path if he is to make progress”.

As the festival will hopefully remind us, Dvořák’s music never tried to be progressive. It might not engage deeply with the intellect, but it does with the heart and the imagination in the most direct way possible (does music really have to engage the intellect anyway?). A consummate orchestrator, a supreme melodist, a passionate Czech nationalist with universal appeal, Dvořák continues to speak with immediacy, kindness and humanity. As Martinů put it: “If anyone expressed a healthy and happy relationship to life, it was he.”

Antony Bateman

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Hallé/Elder review – Paul Lewis weighs his phrases carefully
Mark Elder conducts pianist Paul Lewis and the Hallé Orchestra in a consummate performance of Brahms and Dvořák, writes Alfred Hickling

Alfred Hickling

17, Oct, 2014 @4:39 PM

Article image
Sibelius: Symphonies Nos 5 & 7; En Saga review – Elder brings care but occasional chill
Sibelius’s great Fifth Symphony fares less well than the Seventh in Elder’s readings

Andrew Clements

06, Apr, 2016 @2:00 PM

Article image
A Shropshire Lad: English Songs Orchestrated by Roderick Williams | classical album of the week
Baritone Williams has orchestrated this wide selection of songs by British and Irish composers and illuminates each one with moving personal touches

Andrew Clements

01, Dec, 2022 @3:49 PM

Article image
Gurrelieder review – Elder matches beauty with intensity in Schoenberg's immense drama
This outstanding collaboration between Manchester’s Hallé and the BBC Philharmonic was made all the more affecting by the recent UK terror attacks

Tim Ashley

05, Jun, 2017 @1:25 PM

Article image
The top 10 classical shows of 2017
A magisterial Monteverdi cycle, Oliver Knussen’s adventures in haiku – and a hero’s return for Simon Rattle. Our critic picks his highlights

Andrew Clements

18, Dec, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
Hallé/Elder review – Jonathan Dove explains evolution … with singing galaxies
The composer’s A Brief History of Creation runs riot through 14 billion years of history with Hallé Children’s Choir giving voice to big bangs, galumphing dinosaurs and the first tiny cell

Alfred Hickling

20, Jun, 2016 @11:56 AM

Article image
Pavel Kolesnikov/Hallé/Mark Elder review – superb Sibelius and no-frills Rachmaninov
Kolesnikov met the challenges of Rachmaninov’s demanding Third Piano Concerto with ease, and the orchestra soared during Sibelius’s glorious Third Symphony

Andrew Clements

09, Oct, 2022 @12:36 PM

Article image
Hallé/Elder review – Elder’s measured passion unleashes Mahler’s magic
Mahler’s huge Third Symphony marked a triumphant opening of the Hallé’s spring season

Hugh Morris

24, Jan, 2022 @12:35 PM

Article image
Sibelius: Symphonies Nos 4 & 6 review | Andrew Clements's classical album of the month
Mark Elder and the Hallé bring a sympathetic, powerful character to Sibelius’s enigmatic symphonies

Andrew Clements

13, Feb, 2020 @3:00 PM

Article image
Das Rheingold CD review – Hallé bring the drama where patchy protagonists don't
In a new CD of their series of concert versions of The Ring cycle, the Hallé’s Rheingold has more drama and intensity than the singers at times

Andrew Clements

31, May, 2018 @1:00 PM