Lady Gaga's David Bowie tribute didn't do either artist justice

Gaga has Bowie’s shapeshifting abilities and a strong voice, but the late star’s legacy was ill served by the hectic megamix she performed

Lady Gaga has trafficked in Bowie-isms since she first crash-landed into pop music with The Fame, her 2008 breakthrough collection of dance-pop hits and slickly offered sexuality. Over the past 18 months or so, though, she’s been seemingly paying her music-industry debts for the messy, indulgent 2013 album Artpop, which will go down in history as one of those “interesting failures”. She’s gone to great lengths to prove she’s a pop artiste worthy of the pantheon, singing the Star-Spangled Banner and selections from The Sound Of Music on pop culture’s biggest stages, dueting with Tony Bennett and teaming up with Diane Warren.

So it makes sense that her apology tour would wind its way to the Grammy stage in the form of a tribute to the late David Bowie, whose shape-shifting Gaga has emulated perhaps more fully than any other pop star. (Happy fifth anniversary of Gaga arriving at the Grammys in an egg.) The tribute, produced by former Bowie collaborator Nile Rodgers and underwritten by Intel, smooshed together a slew of tracks from the Thin White Duke’s 70s and 80s offerings. (No Blackstar tracks here, alas.) Sporting a flame-red ’do, Gaga began the show becoming one with Bowie through the magic of digital projection; she then went through a few outfit changes a la her 2013 Video Music Awards performance of the Artpop lead single Applause, going from caped to feathered to jumpsuited as the music (and the piano she took to) shifted around her.

While she kept up ably – say what you will about her flights of fancy, the woman has keen pop instincts and a strong voice – and it was gratifying to see Rodgers up there smiling and strutting after his own dealings with cancer, there was something slightly dissatisfying about the whole thing. Cutting down the sprawling catalog of Bowie is no mean feat, of course, but having so many selections only represent the classic-rock-canon-approved slice of the man’s work seemed reductive; there was more to Bowie’s appeal than face paint and flashy jumpsuits, as any of the eulogies that have poured forth since his death on 10 January could have shown.

Bowie’s constant pushing toward the edge – toward the ridiculous, the sublime, the otherworldly – deserved more of an homage than hasty costume switcheroos and zips through choruses. A Gaga performance of, say, Five Years or even the Blackstar closing statement I Can’t Give Everything Away might have stopped the show, honoring Bowie’s artistry and the way he kept going, working on his art even under shifting critical winds, until the very end.


Maura Johnston

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Lady Gaga to perform David Bowie tribute at Grammys
The star will play a medley of Bowie songs in homage to the prolific artist who inspired her at the ceremony in Los Angeles

Mahita Gajanan in New York

02, Feb, 2016 @4:39 PM

Article image
Is a Lady Gaga tribute to David Bowie the best way to remember him? | The Observer debate
Not everyone is convinced that a Lady Gaga tribute to David Bowie is the best way for the Grammys to mark his death

Barbara Ellen and Peter Robinson

06, Feb, 2016 @4:00 PM

Article image
‘Gaga’ for David Bowie? How easily we smear the ill and disenfranchised | Catherine Shoard
Dementia patients suffer doubly, victims of a vocabulary that mocks their vulnerabilities

Catherine Shoard

18, Feb, 2016 @8:00 AM

Article image
Viral video: One Direction, Justin Bieber and Star Wars VIII
Ed Sheeran, Drake and Kelly Clarkson read mean tweets, Game of Thrones teaser, Lady Gaga channels David Bowie and Beyoncé turns black

Janette Owen

19, Feb, 2016 @7:21 AM

Article image
Lady Gaga's vomit artist: 'I have experienced migraines'

Shock, laughter, outrage … Millie Brown's vomit art has provoked an outpouring of reaction. She tells Leo Benedictus why puking on Lady Gaga does not glamorise bulimia

Leo Benedictus

24, Mar, 2014 @5:30 PM

Article image
Lady Gaga "essential" viewing at the Grammys
The Grammys will never be hip, but between Gaga's egg and Cee Lo's muppets they were in danger of becoming essential viewing

Dorian Lynskey

14, Feb, 2011 @9:00 PM

Article image
Nan Goldin and Lady Gaga's vomit artist – the week in art

Jonathan Jones: The queen of hardcore photography bares all about her druggy past, as the queen of vomit art defends her craft – all in your fave weekly dispatch

Jonathan Jones

28, Mar, 2014 @5:41 PM

Article image
Lady Gaga's new gay anthem

Has Lady Gaga's Born This Way got what it takes to be a classic gay anthem? Jon Savage on the debt she owes to a brave 1970s singer

Jon Savage

14, Feb, 2011 @6:01 AM

Article image
Lady Gaga's new album 'finished'
The 'odd couture' pop star has completed her third album, but won't release it until March or April 2011

Sean Michaels

23, Jun, 2010 @8:49 AM

Article image
Lady Gaga's 30 greatest songs – ranked!
Following her triumphant One World: Together at Home charity concert – and before her album Chromatica – we rate the best of Stefani Germanotta’s gloriously OTT pop

Michael Cragg

23, Apr, 2020 @11:30 AM