Why indie bands and country don't mix

Why do metropolitan indie types such as Christopher Owens, Mystery Jets and and Iceage insist on ‘going country’?

You’d think, with its historical tendencies towards Republicanism, mawkishness and garish inanity, country and western would be given a wide berth by the modernist, metropolitan sophisticates of the indie scene. And yet there’s an obvious attraction: an earthy, rooted realness, and the rugged allure embodied by darker characters such as Johnny Cash and Hank Williams. As such, country has pulled in some improbable aficionados from leftfield: the Charlatans, Nick Cave, Hefner and Prefab Sprout have all tried the 10-gallon hat on for size with varying degrees of success.

The difficulty, of course, is that you can’t just pull on a pair of cowboy boots and call yourself country. Take Twickenham’s Mystery Jets, who went to Texas to record their last album Radlands and immediately started twanging out things called The Ballad Of Emmerson Lonestar, as if a bit of Waylon Jennings might rub off on them by osmosis. It didn’t. This is a band with an actual geographical legacy – Eel Pie Island – so why try to adopt someone else’s?

Copenhagen’s Iceage, meanwhile, started off as teenage hardcore punks and as recently as 2013 were imitating the glacial motions of classic Joy Division. But on their latest album, Plowing Into The Field Of Love, they clatter along like a truckful of pitchfork-wielding rednecks chasing the local hippies out of town. The concept of Danish country-punk could have been interesting, but perhaps out of a misguided desire for earthiness and substance, Iceage have merely trundled down a well-trodden road to nowhere.

Worst of all is Christopher Owens, former frontman of yearning indie pop combo Girls. On his latest single, Nothing More Than Everything To Me, he’s gone full-on country gospel – pedal steels and all the trimmings – though any rhinestone twinkle is dulled by a plodding, white-folks-can’t-dance rhythm that recalls Phil Collins doing Motown. Which is apt, for while the 80s vogue for whiteys such as Collins, Michael, Hucknall etc to ape soul mannerisms felt like the musical version of “blackface”, the appropriation of country feels like an act of “whiteface” – buying into a mythical notion of the “authenticity” of country, uncomfortably close to Sarah Palin’s notion of “real America”, a reactionary, kitschy abandonment of the exploratory urge in favour of cautionary conservatism.

Country is about the spirit, not the trappings, something understood by Londoners Morton Valence on the harrowing, cinematic “urban country” of their current album Left, or by genuine Texan Scott H Biram, whose recent Nothin’ But Blood set fuses country and metal with whiskey-soaked, railroad intensity. They know that country’s not a genre you merely imitate; it’s to be absorbed, spat out, evolved from, and messed up real good.


David Stubbs

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Just don't call it 'indie classical'

Nico Muhly, Olafur Arnalds and a new generation of composers are successfully transposing classical tropes to a rock setting

Selim Bulut

01, Nov, 2013 @1:00 PM

Article image
This week's new live music

Phosphorescent | Mi Ami | Toumani Diabate | Garsington Opera | Bobby McFerrin | Martial Solal

Andrew Clements, John Fordham & John Robinson

28, May, 2010 @11:06 PM

Article image
This week's new live music

Avi Buffalo | Caitlin Rose | Reading/Leeds Festival 2010 | Presteigne Festival | Daar Kom Die Alibama | Scottish National Jazz Orchestra

Andrew Clements, John Fordham & John Robinson

20, Aug, 2010 @11:06 PM

Article image
Indie bands get into the island life

Ibiza has influenced dance music for years. But what's the sound of Orkney or Eigg?

Ailbhe Malone

06, Apr, 2012 @11:05 PM

Article image
Why brass bands are back in vogue

The brass band sound is embedded deep within the British psyche. Now, a new generation are blowing their own trumpets

Joe Muggs

06, Sep, 2013 @12:00 PM

Article image
This week's new live music

Dum Dum Girls | Holly Miranda | Erykah Badu | Francesca da Rimini | Die Walküre | Phil Bancroft's Home

Andrew Clements, John Fordham & John Robinson

23, Jul, 2010 @11:06 PM

Article image
Ian Svenonius: 'A band is about an ideology, a way of life, an aesthetic'

The former Nation Of Ulysses and Make-Up man is back with Chain And The Gang, and a new manifesto for survival in the internet age

James Medd

23, May, 2014 @12:00 PM

Article image
From Ghetts to Genesis, Nick Cave to Arlo Parks: autumn 2021’s essential music
From Fontaines DC to the Valkyrie, a techno Halloween to Little Simz, this is the unmissable music of the next few months

Alexis Petridis, Ammar Kalia and Andrew Clements

25, Aug, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
Readers recommend: songs about smuggling and stealing – results

Pickpockets to highwaymen, bank heists to drug smuggling, the readers' collective Robin Hood act has made a treasure chest, says Peter Kimpton

Peter Kimpton

19, Dec, 2013 @1:40 PM

Article image
Sarabeth Tucek and Josh T Pearson are the Charlie Sheens it's OK to follow

Two of this year's most striking albums are immensely candid rock confessionals. Should we feel dirty for listening in?

Laura Snapes

15, Apr, 2011 @11:03 PM