Messiah review – the Dunedin Consort delivers Handel’s epic with zest

St John’s Kirk, Perth
John Butt led a choir of just 12 in a vivid performance that was at turns sensual, unflinching and menacing

Messiah is all things to all performers: vast choral-union epic to lithe period-band trot, Handel’s sturdy masterpiece accommodates them all. Of the latter, the annual account from John Butt and the Dunedin Consort tends to be something special. Butt strikes a fine balance: his instincts are exploratory, but he respects the sense of ritual that comes from familiarity; he takes the work’s religiousness seriously, but avoids sanctimony. There is no trace of sickly elation but there is a proper dose of mystery. The big tunes are kept relatively plain, while moments of musical intrigue are given real drama. Tempos aren’t extreme; if anything, arias are on the spacious side allowing the soloists room to delve. Still, the three hours usually fly by. This year was no exception.

The vocal sound was typically lean, with a choir of just 12 singers including the four excellent soloists. The priority wasn’t so much about ensemble blend or smoothness as vivid colour and counterpoint, and the character of each voice shone through in the mix. The odd moment of oily choral synthesis was all the more striking for being rare: the sudden, whispered sternness of the line, “and the Lord hath laid on him the iniquity of us all” forced us to sit up and self-reflect.

Thomas Walker was bold in the tenor arias, delivering a sensual Comfort Ye, an unflinching Thy Rebuke Hath Broken His Heart and a menacing Thou Shalt Break Them. David Shipley was a clear and agile bass, soprano Mhairi Lawson added unshowy, effortless glamour and mezzo Rowan Hellier had gentle, subtle grace.

The depth of the orchestral sound was a bit lost in the high crypt of St John’s but the shapely, zestful spirit of this playing would be hard to miss from a mile away.


Kate Molleson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Dunedin Consort: Messiah review – drive and drama, clarity and beauty
Soloists James Laing and Nicholas Mulroy shone particularly among an exemplary ensemble in a small-scale interpretation of Handel’s oratorio led by John Butt

Tim Ashley

21, Dec, 2016 @2:19 PM

Dunedin Consort, Queen's Hall, Edinburgh

Queen's Hall, EdinburghBased on translated Gaelic poems, it is atmospheric, sensitively written and worth hearing again

Rowena Smith

10, Nov, 2008 @12:01 AM

Article image
Messiah review – an impressive wall of sound
If you want to hear Handel’s oratorio done in the grand manner, Huddersfield Choral Society and the Royal Northern Sinfonia are the ones to do it

Alfred Hickling

16, Dec, 2015 @12:05 PM

Article image
Hercules review – Handel’s neglected opera is an extraordinary study in marital jealousy
It was never staged in Handel’s lifetime, and rarely is in ours, yet this concert performance makes an outstanding case for the work’s dramatic qualities

George Hall

05, Mar, 2015 @3:43 PM

Article image
CD: Handel, Messiah


Tim Ashley

08, Dec, 2006 @9:57 AM

Article image
AAM/Egarr review – breathtaking vocals elevate a festive Messiah
Superlative work from Ailish Tynan and Tim Mead set this devotional interpretation of Handel’s oratorio soaring, writes Tim Ashley

Tim Ashley

11, Dec, 2014 @6:12 PM

Article image
Messiah by Jonathan Keates review – the story of Handel’s masterpiece
First performed in 1742, the oratorio was afterwards adapted for huge choirs, and continues to be a firm favourite

Philip Hensher

24, Dec, 2016 @7:30 AM

Article image
Dunedin Consort / Butt / Sophie Bevan review – baroque fireworks lit by natural spark
Sophie Bevan’s refreshing virtuosity pairs splendidly with the Dunedins in this enjoyable romp through Bach and Handel

Kate Molleson

24, Feb, 2016 @12:23 PM

Article image
Dunedin Consort – review

The Scottish baroque ensemble eschews star turns and tackles a tricky Mozart's Requiem at the Lammermuir Festival, writes Kate Molleson

Kate Molleson

24, Sep, 2013 @12:02 PM

Rodelinda – review

Talented Royal College of Music students acquit themselves finely in David Fielding's modern-day setting of Handel's opera, writes George Hall

George Hall

15, Mar, 2011 @6:23 PM