Britpop: a cultural abomination that set music back

During the heyday of Blur and Oasis, ruthless ambition became the order of the day, as scores of unrelentingly pedestrian bands ditched everything that once made British pop music interesting

Britpop casualties: Dodgy, Marion, Menswe@r, Salad and the Bluetones on the dark side of the scene

It's all down to Bobby Robson. Well, partly at least. The true starting point of Britpop was not Select magazine's infamous April 1993 cover – which pictured Suede's Brett Anderson in front of a union jack, with mentions for the Auteurs, Pulp, Saint Etienne and Denim, and the headline "Yanks Go Home!" – but the 1990 World Cup.

New Order released a song for it; hooliganism, though present, wasn't the main story in town as England reached the semi-finals; the myth developed of fans dropping ecstasy and getting loved up instead of violent. Suddenly – almost overnight, it seemed at the time – patriotism ceased to be the last refuge of the scoundrel, but a worthwhile expression of national self-confidence. Beer, music, football and fashion came together, united by Paul Gascoigne's tears and John Barnes' rap. And the lad, formerly demonised in the popular imagination as the Sergio Tacchini-wearing, broken-bottle-wielding thug of the terraces, began his journey to the heart of British popular culture. As Loaded magazine, first published in 1994, would have said: Good work, fella!

And all because Bobby Robson switched to a sweeper system. If England had crashed out in the group stages, would Britpop even have happened?

Select, April 1993
Select from April 1993 Photograph: Select

That's a grotesque simplification, of course. But it's also fitting, because a grotesque simplification is what Britpop became, a collection of lowest common denominators that ended up setting music back: a slavish devotion to a set of signifiers that included 60s music, mod fashion, football, and intoxication. None of those are bad things in isolation. But put together they resulted in a generation of bands and fans who resembled nothing so much as a parody of the football hooligans of a generation before. The racism of the hooligans was verboten, but the sense of Little England loomed large. While literal flagwaving – Noel Gallagher's union jack guitar aside – was a rarity, the concentration on Britishness in lyrics, dress, attitudes was at odds with British pop's historic magpie internationalism. Everything that made inspirations such as the Kinks or the Beatles interesting – their borrowings from black culture, filtered through suburban English eyes, or their wide-eyed sense of exploration – was left undigested.

If you look at those groups on Select's Britpop cover, what united them was not a slavish devotion to anything, but their peculiarly quirky representations of Britishness. Suede's was the easiest to caricature, all council flats, bad drugs and transgressive sex. The Auteurs seemed cruel, cynical and haughty, almost like a Kingsley Amis vision of pop. Pulp, arguably the best of the bands who became associated with Britpop, were arch and wry, yet devastatingly empathetic and humane. Saint Etienne looked to the continent for an internationalist conception of nationality, even as they sang about north London greasy spoons. And Denim used the 70s as a metaphor for a decayed Britain of tattered surfaces losing their shine. What none of them were about was arms-around-shoulders beery bonhomie. They were all outsiders.

Damon Albarn at the Brits in 1995. Photograph: Richard Young/Rex Photograph: Richard Young/REX

But Britpop's imperial period, which began 20 years ago – with the release of Blur's Parklife on 25 April 1994 – and lasted until the release of Oasis's Be Here Now in August 1997, saw the quashing of the sense that outsiderdom was the defining feature of what was known as "indie" music. It wasn't enough to plough your own furrow: instead ruthless ambition became the order of the day, as scores of unrelentingly pedestrian bands followed Oasis's lead and pronounced themselves determined to conquer the world. "I crave extremes. I want to be THAT famous, or THAT known," Louise Wener of Sleeper told Melody Maker in 1995. "The only reason I'm in this is to make great rock'n'roll records, for the hell of it, and I'm concerned that everybody thinks I'm this politically correct, right-on woman," Echobelly's Sonya Aurora Madan told Q the year before (one of the ironies of Britpop is that women did take a prominent role, even in the music of the lad). Previously unusual and experimental groups such as Merseyside's psychedelic Boo Radleys ruthlessly targeted the charts.

And with every hit by one band came a record deal for another, snapped up more and more quickly as the music industry – awash with cash at this point – threw contracts at bands who were patently not prepared for anything resembling a career, the likes of Menswe@r, leading yet more second- and third-rate bands to form in the hope of getting their own shower of cash. What's worse, it became the expected path: if you weren't interested in stardom, why were you in music in the first place? If C86 had defined indie as music made by white guitar bands, then Britpop finally robbed it of any connection to its original derivation: music produced and distributed independently. Indie had ceased to be an alternative. And if it was no longer an alternative, but a hegemonic force of its own, then what was the point of it? Britpop became such a part of the establishment that the Labour party even had its own unofficial Britpop liaison officer, a man named Darren Kalynuk. When I tried to question him about this for the New Statesman in 1996, he was evasive, but by 2003 he was boasting about it in this newspaper.

Gallaghers At Maine Road
Liam and Noel Gallagher of Oasis, at Manchester City's Maine Road stadium in 1995. Photograph: Kevin Cummins/Getty Images Photograph: Richard Davis/Getty Images

If Be Here Now was the death knell, then proof that Britpop was a cultural abomination had come the year before. In 1996, Tim Lovejoy took over as the presenter of Sky Sports' Saturday morning magazine show, Soccer AM, in which the music of British guitar bands was a key element. And here, in one package, was everything the 1990 World Cup had sown the seeds for: pop music, laddishness, football, all interchangeable. As in Animal Farm, one looked from the animals to the humans and could see no difference. Banter on!

Britpop casualties: Dodgy, Marion, Menswe@r, Salad and the Bluetones on the dark side of the scene


Michael Hann

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Devendra Banhart: 'I love almost every Britpop band'

The Venezuelan singer and artist on Britpop, life under Chávez and childhood memories of bugs' guts

Chris Salmon

21, Mar, 2013 @10:37 PM

Article image
Britpop is back! What's behind the 90s music revival?
This summer’s Cool Britannia festival showed there is a huge appetite for re-formed 90s bands, including the Bluetones, Echobelly and Sleeper. Was the music really that good – or do people just want nostalgia during uncertain times?

Alexis Petridis

06, Sep, 2018 @12:27 PM

Article image
Britpop casualties: 'It felt like we crashed someone else's party'

Being at the heart of the indie scene in the 90s wasn't as much fun as it seemed on the pages of the NME. Members of Dodgy, the Bluetones, Menswe@r, Salad and Marion remember the dark days of Britpop – and what has happened since

Interviews by Paul Lester

24, Apr, 2014 @6:00 PM

Article image
Don't look back in anger: did Britpop cause Brexit?
It’s a thesis doing the rounds – and is full of holes. But there’s no denying that Britpop’s nostalgia did make flag-waving nationalism more acceptable

Michael Hann

22, Nov, 2018 @2:30 PM

Dodgy: Stand Upright in a Cool Place – review
Britpop survivors Dodgy return with an impressive new album that plays up their melancholy streak, writes Dave Simpson

Dave Simpson

16, Feb, 2012 @10:00 PM

Article image
Could Alex James's Britpop drink turn out to be made of cheese?
The cheese-obsessed former Blur bass player wants to create a drink named after the 90s musical fad. He'll be going up against Oasis again, then

14, Jan, 2014 @3:09 PM

Article image
Britpop songs – 10 of the best
For some it meant the arrogant swagger of Oasis and cheek of Blur, to others it stood for the perceptive wit of Pulp, but mostly the Britpop moment produced catchy tracks about youth on the move

Caroline Sullivan

15, Feb, 2017 @12:10 PM

Article image
Britpop wasn't perfect, but it was ours | Elinor Davies
Eli Davies: I’m puzzled why this wave of nostalgia for the likes of Blur and Oasis has annoyed people quite so much. They brought a bit of joy to a grey era

Eli Davies

14, Apr, 2014 @11:51 AM

Article image
Quiz: How much do you know about Britpop?

To celebrate the 20th anniversary of Blur's Parklife, here are 30 questions to test your knowledge of mid-to-late 90s British guitar music

Jack Dutton

25, Apr, 2014 @11:38 AM

Article image
Shed Seven review – a nostalgia rush from the Britpop songbook
Rick Witter’s 90s band offer very little in the way of progression, but they recapture the spirit of a bygone era

Daniel Dylan Wray

02, Jul, 2018 @12:05 PM