Appreciation: The brilliant but bewildering Hans Werner Henze

Robert Ponsonby writes: I first met Hans Werner Henze in 1970, when he directed his opera Elegy for Young Lovers at the Edinburgh festival

I first met Hans Werner Henze in 1970, when he directed his opera Elegy for Young Lovers at the Edinburgh festival. The conductor was Alexander Gibson, who had already programmed a number of Henze's works with the then Scottish National Orchestra.

Moving from the management of that orchestra to the BBC in 1972, I was grateful to Henze for inaugurating, with two programmes, the studio series The Composer Conducts – and he was certainly one of those who could. Between 1975 and 1986, I scheduled several of his works at the Proms. Problematic, however, was The Raft of the Medusa, whose aborted premiere in Hamburg in 1968 had become notorious.

I had heard a tape of the final rehearsal and was bothered by the Ho Chi Minh chants that end the piece, so I wrote to ask if he had considered an alternative ending. His reply was characteristic: "For me, this finale represents a violent switch from past to present. I'm aware of the fact that it is crude and rude and I almost hate it. Yet it does something, at least for me..." In the event, David Atherton's moving performance at the 1978 Proms went off without incident, the finale no longer subversively topical.

Henze could not really understand the ridicule he encountered in Germany for voicing strongly leftwing views from a position of considerable personal comfort. But his move to Italy in 1953 – described in an unforgettably evocative radio broadcast that demonstrated not only his mastery of English but also his beguiling charm – was some sort of a liberation.

Italian warmth of climate and character released both the sensuality inherent in his music and the manifest sensuality of his own character. At their most heartfelt, as that with the admirable Michael Vyner, his gay relationships could be creative: the works Henze wrote for Michael's London Sinfonietta now seem to be among his best.

The move to Italy brought another bonus – friendship with another asylum-seeker, William Walton, who often welcomed him to Ischia and was genuinely interested in his development, if also envious of his gifts as self-promoter: "Hans really does know how to manage things," Walton wrote in 1976. "At his Montepulciano festival he managed to get it televised by the Italians, the Germans and BBC TV." And, sure enough, a letter from Henze soliciting BBC collaboration soon landed on my desk.

In another letter, written not long after Henze had suffered a heart attack, Walton accidentally touched on the question which is surely central to any assessment of Henze's music: "Hans is not too well … I tried to persuade him that it was quite unnecessary for him to write more music – he has done already enough for two lifetimes." And indeed Henze's facility was prodigious – as was his industry and the range of his achievement.

He belonged to no school, but he tentatively explored systems, including serialism, which were fundamentally alien to him. Aspiring to an idiom both radical and communicative, he evolved, initially, a postromantic lyricism of his own.

Later – particularly in the smaller-scale political works – he found a harder edge, though not the "con malizia" of Walton, whose orchestration he much admired. Still later, the big symphonies once again demonstrated an absolute technical mastery, but a tendency towards soft-centred prolixity which seemed to me to weaken them, however alluring their externals. Without doubt Henze was brilliantly gifted, but also bewilderingly so.


Robert Ponsonby

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Hans Werner Henze obituary

Composer devoted to the exploration of political ideas in the opera house and concert hall

Guy Rickards

27, Oct, 2012 @9:38 PM

In praise of … Hans Werner Henze | Editorial
Editorial: It may take many years to fully measure the significance of this prolific and stylistically eclectic composer's output


29, Oct, 2012 @10:43 PM

Article image
Hans Werner Henze: A matter of life and death

Blighted by illness and personal loss, German composer Hans Werner Henze has bounced back to create a career-defining work with Phaedra, writes Tom Service

Tom Service

14, Dec, 2009 @9:30 PM

Article image
German composer Hans Werner Henze dies age 86

The death of German composer Hans Werner Henze has been announced today

Imogen Tilden, Tom Service

27, Oct, 2012 @1:58 PM

Article image
House music: Flora Willson's watching and listening highlights
Our critic enjoys a masterly, socially distanced first night of the Proms, a new series by Opera North made to listen as you walk and a striking Met performance by Lise Davidsen

Flora Willson

31, Aug, 2020 @4:00 PM

Article image
A guide to Hans Werner Henze's music

Henze's artistic credo was that music ought to have something to say about human emotion and to contribute to contemporary society, writes Tom Service

Tom Service

29, Oct, 2012 @4:23 PM

Article image
House music: Tim Ashley's watching and listening highlights
Daisy Evans’s delightful update of The Telephone crowns engaging online treats from Edinburgh and Salzburg festivals, while our critic looks ahead to live, audience-free Proms

Tim Ashley

24, Aug, 2020 @3:00 PM

Article image
CD: Henze: Voices, Walker/ Sperry/ London Sinfonietta/ Henze

(Explore, two CDs)

Andrew Clements

03, Nov, 2006 @12:18 AM

Article image
The top classical, world, folk and jazz of summer 2017
Comedy choirs, desert rock, a trip to the moon and a musical tour of Hull are the standout sounds of the season. Plus Django Bates jazzes up Sgt Pepper

Tim Ashley, Robin Denselow, John Fordham and Imogen Tilden

19, Jun, 2017 @5:00 AM

Article image
The best classical festivals in the UK for 2016
Exciting, innovative concerts abound this season – and not just at established giants such as Edinburgh and the Proms

Imogen Tilden

21, May, 2016 @10:00 AM