Handel: Il Pastor Fido – review

Crowe/Dennis/Manley/La Nuova Musica/Bates
(Harmonia Mundi, two CDs)

Though it followed two of Handel's early operatic masterpieces, Agrippina and Rinaldo, Il Pastor Fido, first performed in London in 1712 and based on one of the most popular plays of the 17th century, is a problematic work. It is deliberately intimate and pastoral, almost a stylistic experiment in evoking an Arcadia that never existed, but it's rather thin on characterisation and dramatic coherence as a result. Handel drastically revised his score for a production in 1734, only retaining eight of the original 34 numbers, and that reworking is the version usually heard today. This is claimed as the world-premiere recording of the original 1712 score, though, in fact, this version was recorded (with a few cuts) as long ago as 1961 and has subsequently been released on CD. Handel completists will doubtless rush to add this performance to their burgeoning collections, but David Bates and his fine young lineup of singers (with Lucy Crowe and Anna Dennis as the lovers, Amarilli and Mirtillo) do little to bolster the work's slender dramatic means; rather than a living, breathing performance, the result is an elegant musical object, as bloodless as a porcelain figurine.

Contributor

Andrew Clements

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Handel: Il pastor fido – review
La Nuova Musica bring Handel's Il pastor fido to vibrant life, writes Nicholas Kenyon

Nicholas Kenyon

07, Apr, 2012 @11:04 PM

Il Pastor Fido – review
Handel's supposedly problematic opera came good under David Bates, immaculately sung and free of self-indulgence, writes Tim Ashley

Tim Ashley

17, Apr, 2012 @4:59 PM

Handel: Alceste – review
These vocal and orchestral numbers don't really hang together but the Early Opera Company do wonderful things with them anyway, says Tim Ashley

Tim Ashley

12, Jul, 2012 @8:52 PM

Handel Bad Guys – review
The album reminds us that Handel characterises evil with the same complexity with which he depicts good. It forms a superb showcase for an exceptional singer, says Tim Ashley

Tim Ashley

06, Feb, 2013 @3:30 PM

Handel: Arias for Bass – review
Handel associated bass voices with iniquity – but Christopher Purves shows there was psychological insight there, too, says Tim Ashley

Tim Ashley

10, Jan, 2013 @9:45 PM

Article image
Handel: Ottone CD review – neglected opera performed with relish
Max Emanuel Cencic and Ann Hallenberg are ably supported by an elegant orchestra in this mesmerising recital

Erica Jeal

29, Jun, 2017 @5:15 PM

Article image
Handel: Tamerlano review – Minasi's conducting is second to none
The work's severity and sensuousness arewonderfully captured by Il Pomod'Oro, writes Tim Ashley

Tim Ashley

08, May, 2014 @11:29 AM

Article image
Handel: Imeneo CD review – some rough edges but Ann Hallenberg shines
This later version of the opera benefits from some striking arias and a love duet, but the star is mezzo Ann Hallenberg, who is in another league

Erica Jeal

18, Feb, 2016 @6:15 PM

Article image
Barsanti; Handel: Edinburgh 1742 CD review – a rich insight into the Enlightenment city

Kate Molleson

03, Aug, 2017 @2:45 PM

Article image
Handel: Heroes from the Shadows CD review
Nathalie Stutzmann and her chamber ensemble Orfeo 55 give a splendid recital of some of Handel’s best arias, writes Tim Ashley

Tim Ashley

13, Nov, 2014 @8:10 PM