Billy Joel: Piano Man (Legacy Edition) – review


Billy Joel had already released four albums – three with groups, and one solo disaster that was mastered at the wrong speed – before Columbia picked him up in 1972 and released this, the album that gave him his first solo breakthrough. For those more familiar with Joel's 80s MOR staples, it's a rum old do, with banjos and dobros every bit as prominent as Joel's piano – as if, in the wake of Elton John's Tumbleweed Connection, every singer-pianist had to somehow pretend to be a cowboy (the west is addressed directly in The Ballad of Billy the Kid). The centrepieces are the two extended narratives that made his name. Piano Man itself presents a sentimentalised view of Joel's time as a lounge pianist, though if it was that great, one wonders why Joel chose to pursue international stardom instead. Captain Jack – the song that got him signed after a Philadelphia radio station playlisted a live version from a promo show – attempted to capture the ennui of a generation by means of a clunky lyric – "You're sister's gone out, she's on a date/ You just sit home and masturbate" – about a listless loser who buys drugs from the titular dealer. Both, though, show off Joel's undeniable knack for a melody that simply brushes objections away, and his skill at combining Broadway, singer-songwriter and soft rock techniques. The real fascination here, though, is the second disc, a brushed-up version of the promo show that brought Captain Jack to attention. It reveals Joel as nervy, but fully formed.


Michael Hann

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Billy Joel – review

An unusually intimate gig for the underrated 64-year-old songwriter reveals he is due for reappraisal, writes Caroline Sullivan

Caroline Sullivan

06, Nov, 2013 @1:19 PM

Billy Joel, NEC, Birmingham

NEC, Birmingham

Dave Simpson

07, Jul, 2006 @12:40 AM

Article image
Billy Joel review – evergreen, edgy and in sublime voice
Piano man plays all the hits, switching styles, from doo-wop of The Longest Time to experimental Zanzibar, with aplomb

Betty Clarke

11, Sep, 2016 @11:49 AM

Old music: Billy Joel – Souvenir

Russell Cunningham: The New Yorker's seasonal hymn reflects on how trinkets can transport us to times past

Russell Cunningham

05, Jan, 2012 @12:35 PM

Article image
Billy Joel: 10 of the best
Pop’s original young fogey has mastered many styles, but at his heart there has always been sentiment and tartness. Here are 10 of his classics

Stevie Chick

07, Jan, 2015 @4:13 PM

Article image
Elton John claims Billy Joel needs more rehab
Singer urges his friend to check into rehab to defeat his alleged alcoholism, saying he needs 'tough love'

Sean Michaels

03, Feb, 2011 @12:32 PM

Article image
Exclusive: Billy Joel performs Stiletto in Moscow in 1987 - video

Watch previously unreleased material from Billy Joel's historic 1987 tour of Russia, with the singer performing Stiletto

25, Apr, 2014 @8:47 AM

Article image
Billy Joel takes blame for Bruce Springsteen bike breakdown
Joel tells crowd at Madison Square Garden gig he built motorcycle that left the Boss stranded by side of the road in New Jersey

Guardian music

24, Nov, 2016 @8:23 AM

Article image
Chris Buck's best photograph: Billy Joel in the dark with an Applause sign
‘Billy said, “I’ll do this – but I’m not one who performs because of an urgent need for approval”’

Interview by Karin Andreasson

01, Jun, 2017 @5:00 AM

Article image
Daft Punk: Tron: Legacy – review

Daft Punk were put on Earth to write the soundtrack to Tron, so why is Alexis Petridis disappointed?

Alexis Petridis

02, Dec, 2010 @4:09 PM