Feist: Metals – review

(Polydor)

There must be something in the ether. Björk's website has twinkled with pictures of sparkly minerals in the run-up to her imminent album, Biophilia, riffing hard on the natural world as a musical resource.

Nature also plays a starring role in Feist's fourth album, the first in four long years from the Canadian singer, erstwhile member of Broken Social Scene and Peaches sidekick. There's a stark landscape on the cover of Metals, an album named for the malleable, ductile ores that lie deep down, ripe for transformation.

All this organic material is in marked contrast to Feist's hi-tech thumbnail portrait. "1234" was the iPod Nano tune that introduced her to a bigger audience. Her winsome third album, The Reminder, won the Shortlist prize and was nominated for a Grammy.

On Metals, by contrast, you can just about hear the dust motes swirling through the air. Recorded in California's Big Sur with minimal overdubs, it is an album full of rattles and thumps, breaths and handclaps; "Get It Wrong, Get It Right", the album's consolatory closer, seems to have a herd of grazing goats on it.

As a consequence, it feels wrong to listen to Metals as a computer download. Its quieter moments, such as the campfire tune "Cicadas and Gulls" and the self-explanatory "Bittersweet Melodies", require somewhere soft to curl up.

Its louder moments – and there are plenty – are even better and feature stomping incantations that demand air and company. The chorus of "The Undiscovered First" is about as close as Feist gets to a hoedown. "Is this the way to live?" demands the chorus, which features the rattle'n'holler of San Francisco's Real Vocal String Quartet (they sing as well as fiddle). The tune that most resembled a "1234" pop moment – "Woe Be", previewed on the website of Spin magazine – did not make the final album cut.

Rhythm is key to this subtle record. For all their elegance, Feist's gossamer hiccups can be as difficult to grab hold of as fistfuls of steam. All the percussion here – the galumphing beats and clacking typewriter on "The Bad in Each Other", a song about how nice people can't always be nice to one another – serves as counterpoint to Feist's feathery vocalising. Songs such as "How Come You Never Go There" and the subtle "Anti-Pioneer", meanwhile, have the gentlest swing of jazz to them. Overall, these songs vibrate on the ultraviolet spectrum: blue, but not blues.

Has Feist been unlucky in love? The press release that accompanies Metals alludes to a lyric of Feist's coming true over the course of her touring ("I'll be the one to break my heart," from The Reminder's "I Feel It All"). Even though Metals features one happy conjoining – "The Circle Married the Line" – on balance, Metals is full of iron filings that don't line up magnetically. People are out of synch, love is not "the light it was", and, in the album's killer blow, succour is hard to find: "When you comfort me/ It doesn't bring me comfort/ Actually."

Contributor

Kitty Empire

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Feist: joy mixed with steel
Exhausted by touring, Feist cast off music for nearly two years. But now she's back, and her album Metals reveals a steelier side to the happy-go-lucky songster. Interview by Miranda Sawyer

Miranda Sawyer

01, Oct, 2011 @11:04 PM

Article image
Feist review – indie shapeshifter gets conceptual
Audacious, occasionally baffling stagecraft and much emotion act in tandem in a daring set in which the Canadian singer-songwriter goes rogue

Kitty Empire

16, Sep, 2023 @1:00 PM

Article image
Broken Social Scene: Hug of Thunder review – strength in numbers
(City Slang)

Kitty Empire

09, Jul, 2017 @6:59 AM

Article image
Feist: Pleasure review – an atmosphere that really breathes
(Polydor)

Kitty Empire

30, Apr, 2017 @7:00 AM

Article image
Feist: Multitudes review – a soul-stirring career highlight
The Canadian singer-songwriter processes birth and bereavement on a raw sixth album of gossamer vocals and screaming outbursts

Ammar Kalia

15, Apr, 2023 @1:00 PM

Article image
Feist: Metals - review

While Metals may not be a career-ending avant-garde noisefest, there's plenty here to separate Feist from the rest of the kooky advert-soundtrack sirens, says Alexis Petridis

Alexis Petridis

29, Sep, 2011 @2:32 PM

Broken Social Scene: Forgiveness Rock Record | CD review
Serious time spent listening to this Canadian collective's biggest record yet will bring rewards, writes Hermione Hoby

Hermione Hoby

08, May, 2010 @11:07 PM

Article image
Feist review – one of the best live shows of the year
The magnetic Canadian singer performs her perceptive songs of love and loss during a gig that is precisely choreographed but still feels intimate and vividly in the moment

Shaad D'Souza

10, Sep, 2023 @11:59 AM

Article image
Braids: 'We could never write a song about pizza' - interview

The intensely emotional songs of Braids are mirrored by the band's complicated personal relationships. Hermione Hoby catches up with Canada's hottest new musical export

Hermione Hoby

23, Apr, 2011 @11:02 PM

Article image
Feist review – music to blitz the ears and engulf the senses
The Canadian indie-folk star transforms the sparse songs of recent album Pleasure into luminous ballads and splenetic blues-rock shredding

Caroline Sullivan

28, Jul, 2017 @11:16 AM