Jude Rogers on Sir Paul McCartney's admiration of the Wombats

There's a cynical explanation for Sir Paul McCartney's admiration of the Wombats - but even if it's true, I don't really begrudge him

Hold the front page, Liverpool-lovers: Sir Paul McCartney has said he fancies a pop at producing his fellow Scousers, the Wombats. Just imagine: a purple-haired pusher of blackbirds and frog choruses taking a fancy to three frizzy-haired, short-legged, nocturnal creatures. It's like something out of the Magical Mystery Tour on even more drugs.

In our more sober reality, this collaboration still looks mighty peculiar. After all, our Paul is a perky-thumbed songwriting colossus who knocked out Yesterday before his 23rd birthday. The Wombats are deeply average indie-rock unit-shifters who sing about school uniforms and backfiring at discos. Still, give Macca his due - there's nothing like an elderly local statesman rolling up his sleeves to help out a few youngsters.

It's obvious what's in this for the Wombats: a big spike in record sales, a new audience, and a bigger, better profile. But what's in it for McCartney? Now in his 65th year, he could be kicking back and enjoying his copious royalties. On recent form, he's doing quite the contrary: releasing an album every other year, and playing gigs like a mop-top possessed. (Which is to say that his recent divorce seems to have fuelled his activity, rather than quelled it.) To link up with a young band can only add to the impression of an artist still glimmering with spark, health and virility. It also helps that the group he covets, of course, are Liverpudlian.

The Wombats' youth, in some ways, is even more important than their Merseyside connections. Much of McCartney's music, after all, has been driven by the experiences of his early years. His last two albums, in particular, have bubbled over with such references. 2005's Chaos and Creation in the Backyard bubbled with nostalgic songs about English Tea and Too Much Rain, and even featured a picture of himself on the cover - a teenager, in his family's back garden, strumming on a guitar. And many of the lyrics on last year's Memory Almost Full hinted at his fear of forgetting - a fear made more poignant by what was happening in his personal life. Its second track almost said too much: "I hope it isn't too late/ Searching for the time that has gone so fast/ The time that I thought would last/ My ever-present past."

In that ever-present past, we also remember the altruism of the younger McCartney. With John Lennon beside him, some of their great early songs were given to other artists - I Wanna Be Your Man to the Rolling Stones, or I'll Keep You Satisfied to Billy J Kramer and the Dakotas. Not only did this reflect the practices of the time, but it also underlined the prolific talents of the twosome, and their happiness to perform for other people. So, by offering his services to a new generation, McCartney is both continuing his legacy, and remembering the machinations of his youth.

Saying that, there's also a cynical explanation for McCartney's admiration of the Wombats. The band met at the Liverpool Institute for Performing Arts (Lipa), the school founded in 1996 by Mark Featherstone-Witty and - oh hello, Paul McCartney. Is our boy simply patting himself on the back? Call me a soft touch, but I don't think it's that simple. And even if it were, I don't really begrudge him. After all, the meat-machine whiff of the Brit School may surround Lipa's alumni, but at least Sir Paul has done what a thousand megastars haven't - put his money where his mouth is and practically encouraged the next generation.

McCartney shouldn't stop here. If he's so keen on his Liverpudlian legacy, he should think about what he could do for the city's more interesting musicians: the Zutons, Ladytron or Candie Payne. But for now, by all means, embrace the Wombats, Sir Paul. Perhaps bend their ears towards the episodic madness of Band On the Run, though, or the mad electronic pop of Temporary Secretary off McCartney II. You've given us your legacy; time to help Liverpool's new breed give us their own.

Contributor

Jude Rogers

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
CD: The Wombats, A Guide to Love, Loss and Desperation

(14th Floor)

Leonie Cooper

02, Nov, 2007 @11:49 PM

The Wombats: This Modern Glitch – review
Catchy tunes and exuberant riffs mask the serious melancholia at the heart of the Wombats' second album, writes Maddy Costa

Maddy Costa

21, Apr, 2011 @9:45 PM

Paul McCartney offers to produce the next Wombats album

News: The Beatles legend offers to lend his knob-twiddling skills for the next release from the Wombats

Sean Michaels

11, Jun, 2008 @12:06 PM

Article image
CD: Paul McCartney, Memory Almost Full

(Hear Music)

Jude Rogers

15, Jun, 2007 @10:57 PM

On music: Jude Rogers on Lily Allen's topless Q cover

Jude Rogers laments the decisions of Lily Allen and Natasha Khan to go topless

Jude Rogers

27, Feb, 2009 @12:01 AM

Jude Rogers on the downfall of boy bands

You'd think a Girls Aloud support slot would be the making of a hot new boy band - but is there even an audience for them any more, says Jude Rogers

Jude Rogers

26, Jun, 2008 @11:15 PM

Article image
Lady Gaga v Pixie Lott: the battle of the Christmas video promo

Lady Gaga's new video proves how wrong I was about her initially. I wish I could say the same about Pixie Lott's offering, writes Jude Rogers

Jude Rogers

03, Dec, 2009 @11:05 PM

On music: Glasvegas' knockout blow to Oasis

Jude Rogers: The Gallaghers still think they walk on water. But Glasvegas are just as bolshy - and their brand of lonely nostalgia packs a bigger punch

Jude Rogers

21, Aug, 2008 @11:01 PM

On music: Jude Rogers on the return of the Horrors

The Horrors' brilliant new single is proof that prominence in the gossip pages doesn't guarantee lifelong musical awfulness, says Jude Rogers

Jude Rogers

27, Mar, 2009 @12:01 AM

Jude Rogers: Rock is all about daft theatre

Jude Rogers: Rock is all about daft theatre. It's not like mainstream pop, which sparkles cheaply and perfectly like a good local panto

Jude Rogers

29, May, 2008 @11:10 PM