Row over plan to DNA test Chopin's heart

Scientists refused permission to analyse organ to prove composer died of cystic fibrosis, not TB

Scientists are locked in a battle with the Polish government over their request to test the heart of Frédéric Chopin for evidence he suffered from cystic fibrosis. They believe the Polish composer was not a victim of tuberculosis, as commonly supposed, but died because he suffered from one of Europe's most widespread hereditary disorders.

The researchers want to test his preserved heart to prove this point but have just been rebuffed by Polish authorities. However last week they pledged to continue to press for access to the composer's remains to prove their theory.

'This is a very important request,' said Dr Michael Witt, of Warsaw's Institute of Molecular and Cell Biology. 'If we can prove Chopin suffered from cystic fibrosis, then we will have shown that a serious medical disability is still no barrier to achieving fame and success.'

Chopin died in France in 1849 and was buried in Paris though his heart was removed and placed in a jar of cognac, since kept in Warsaw's Church of the Holy Cross. Now scientists want to use some of the tissue to test their theory.

The musician, born in 1810, is considered Poland's greatest composer. However, his life was plagued by bad health. According to a Journal of Applied Genetics paper by Witt and fellow researchers Lucyna Majka and Joanna Gozdzik, Chopin was frail, slim, with sunken cheeks, suffered continual infections of the lung, and displayed symptoms of delayed puberty.

'Chopin was a disabled person who depended on his friends' care during the last four years of his life,' they state. 'He had to be carried up stairs and teach the piano in a lying position.'

After his 10-year relationship with the writer George Sand came to end in 1847, Chopin's health deteriorated even further and he spent the last year of his life confined to bed, suffering from intense pains in his joints, depression and shortness of breath. He died in 1849, of 'tuberculosis of the lungs and larynx', according to his post mortem report.

But Witt's team believe his symptoms were really those of cystic fibrosis, a genetic disorder that affects the lungs, pancreas, liver and intestines. The disease is inherited from symptomless parents. Each can pass on an affected gene to their children. Those who inherit a double dose develop the disease which manifests from early childhood. About one in 2,500 new-born children in Europe has cystic fibrosis. Current treatments can keep sufferers alive until they are over 40.

Witt points out that two of Chopin's three sisters had similar complaints, including multiple organ failure, and died prematurely. These symptoms strongly suggest that the Chopin family was afflicted by cystic fibrosis, says the scientist. The theory would be impossible to prove if it were not for the fact that Chopin's heart is pickled in cognac, offering the prospect of providing a few cells that could determine, from DNA tests, if he suffered from the condition. 'Once we have that in our hands it is a small matter to do a DNA test,' Tadeusz Dobosz, a geneticist at Wroclaw Medical University, told the journal Science

However, the Polish government said last week it would not give permission for such tests. Witt and his team insist that they will continue to press for access to Chopin's heart.

They state in their paper: 'Is it not right to make an attempt to prove to many suffering people that many things count in life much more than a weak physical body, and they are not predestined to vanish without leaving something that will influence, inspire and enrich generations to come?'


Robin McKie, science editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Examination of Chopin’s pickled heart solves riddle of his early death
Scientists diagnose rare complication of tuberculosis following analysis of heart stored in jar of cognac for 170 years

Robin McKie Observer Science Editor

05, Nov, 2017 @12:05 AM

DNA explodes Greek myth about women

British researchers have unearthed evidence that women in Ancient Greece were major power brokers in their own right

Robin McKie, science editor

31, May, 2008 @11:01 PM

Article image
Scientists attacked over claim that 'junk DNA' is vital to life
Rivals accuse team of knowing nothing about evolutionary biology

Robin McKie

24, Feb, 2013 @12:06 AM

Article image
Chopin's interest in men airbrushed from history, programme claims
Journalist says he has found overt homoeroticism in Polish composer’s letters

Philip Oltermann and Shaun Walker

25, Nov, 2020 @5:00 AM

Article image
Swifts may hold secret of staying young

Researchers say the birds have a distinctive piece of genetic material whose length predicts their life expectancy

Robin McKie, science editor

15, Mar, 2009 @12:01 AM

Article image
Brown faces deepening revolt over embryo bill

Stephen Byers joins calls for free vote over controversial bill that includes legalisation of human-animal embryo research

Gaby Hinsliff, political editor

23, Mar, 2008 @12:51 AM

Lorenzo loses battle for life but legacy of hope lives on

Lorenzo Odone, whose condition inspired the film Lorenzo's Oil, has died a few days after his 30th birthday

Peter Beaumont

31, May, 2008 @11:01 PM

Article image
‘The wondrous map’: how unlocking human DNA changed the course of science
Thanks to the success of the Human Genome Project, 20 years ago this week, scientists can track biology and disease at a molecular level

Robin McKie

21, Jun, 2020 @7:19 AM

Article image
DNA from thin air: a new way to detect rare wildlife in hostile environments
Discovery that traces of genetic material are all around us opens a non-invasive way to boost biodiversity

Robin McKie

08, Aug, 2021 @9:30 AM

Article image
Scientists launch search for genetic test to spot killer prostate cancer
Gene-screening, as is used to detect some breast cancer risks, could save thousands of lives

Robin McKie

08, May, 2021 @1:18 PM