Direct Line ordered to review five years of car claims after underpayments

Insurer told to reassess vehicle write-offs to identify any unfair settlements

Britain’s second-biggest car insurer, Direct Line, has been ordered to go back through five years of claims after admitting it had underpaid some customers who had their cars and vans written off.

After an investigation into the car insurance market that began in December 2022, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), this week ordered Direct Line to conduct a review of claims where vehicles had been written off “to identify any policyholders who received unfair settlements and provide them with appropriate redress”.

Direct Line, which has recently been accused by customers of upping premiums by 50%-75%, said in a statement that it was reviewing all total loss claims settled between 1 September 2017 and 17 August 2022.

“We expect that this will affect a minority of customers and the vast majority of customers will not be impacted. Customers do not need to contact us, either directly or via third parties, as we will contact impacted individuals to apologise and provide appropriate redress, including interest,” it said.

The review is the latest blow to one of the UK’s biggest motor insurers and follows a string of profit warnings caused by runaway inflation in its claims costs, which prompted the departure of its chief executive in January.

Back in December, the FCA said it had seen evidence that motor insurance customers, whose cars had been written off after an accident, had received payouts lower than fair market value. However, it did not name insurers.

Offering a price lower than fair market value is not allowed under FCA rules and the watchdog said it would take action against companies it found doing this

“People shouldn’t need to question whether they are being offered the right amount for their written-off car or other goods that they need to replace,” Sheldon Mills, the FCA’s executive director for consumers and competition, said at the time, adding that such practices would hit people “precisely at the time they can ill afford it”.

This week’s FCA notice confirmed the suspicion that Direct Line has been offering below-value payouts after customer cars were written off.

Two weeks ago, Guardian Money reported on the case of Leslie Martin from Manchester who complained that Direct Line had offered him a derisory £19,0000 payout after it wrote off his very rare Rolls-Royce.

Forced to spend £32,000 on a replacement, he had valued his car at more than £25,000 but Direct Line has refused to up its offer. At the time, Direct Line claimed it had reached the £19,000 figure after it had approached multiple independent Rolls-Royce dealers.

“The way my claim has been treated has been appalling,” Martin says. “It’s no surprise to me that the company has been called out by the regulator.”

Customers who think their claim has been undervalued can complain to their insurer and then to the Financial Ombudsman if their complaint is not resolved.


Miles Brignall

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Car insurance firms use loopholes to keep costs high for loyal customers
It is banned from charging more for renewals than new deals, but the industry still has some tricks up its sleeve

Anna Tims

28, May, 2022 @8:00 AM

Article image
Direct Line to pay £30m to overcharged car and home insurance customers
Company breached rules that state existing policyholders should not be charged more than new ones

Mark Sweney

01, Sep, 2023 @8:49 AM

Article image
RAC accused of hiding 37% rise in cost of breakdown cover
Policy renewal letter did not mention annual premium increase, says one customer, despite it being mandatory

Miles Brignall

19, Jan, 2019 @10:16 AM

Article image
UK drivers shocked as car insurance costs soar by up to 90%
The price of petrol and diesel may have dropped but households are being hit by another rising cost

Zoe Wood

22, Jul, 2023 @6:00 AM

Article image
UK car insurance: insider tips on how to save money
From the best time to renew and using comparison sites to choosing a black box policy

Rupert Jones

22, Jul, 2023 @10:00 AM

Article image
Direct debit option increases insurance payments, FCA finds
Consumers are not told the higher cost of paying by instalments, the Financial Conduct Authority says, with some being charged interest of up to 75%

Patrick Collinson

11, May, 2015 @10:25 AM

Article image
Swiftcover won’t pay out what I’m due after a serious car accident
We claimed, but we can’t get the £1,000 or so the vehicle was worth

Miles Brignall

20, May, 2019 @6:00 AM

Article image
EU’s gender ruling on car insurance has made inequality worse
It said car insurance firms couldn’t discriminate between the sexes ... since then men have seen a four-fold rise in premiums

Patrick Collinson

14, Jan, 2017 @6:59 AM

Article image
Your car in the Covid lockdown: how to save on insurance and more
Some Britons are driving much less than before– here are ways to cut costs

Sue Hayward

06, Mar, 2021 @1:00 PM

Article image
Avoid paying a premium for car insurance
Latest figures reveal the soaring costs of cover, with warnings of further rises to come. But here’s what you can do to get a better deal

Rupert Jones

24, Sep, 2016 @6:00 AM