BrightHouse loan customers unlikely to get refunds, say administrators

Creditor Greensill has received big sum but Grant Thornton decides cost of assessing other claims is too high

Administrators for the collapsed rent-to-own firm BrightHouse, which specialised in loans for big-ticket items such as fridges and sofas, have warned they will not have enough money to compensate thousands of customers who were left with unaffordable debts.

The latest report from the accountants Grant Thornton, which is managing the administration, shows a plan to set aside £600,000 for payouts to customers who may have been mis-sold expensive loans by BrightHouse has been scrapped.

Meanwhile, a number of creditors have received large sums. They include the supply chain finance firm Greensill, which is itself in administration after collapsing last year. Greensill – or its creditors – have received nearly £31m.

The process will raise fresh questions about how UK insolvency rules prioritise payouts for investors and lenders over customers.

Before it went bust in 2020, BrightHouse offered high-interest rent-to-own contracts to customers who would otherwise struggle to afford the upfront costs of household goods such as fridges, ovens, TVs and sofas. It charged interest of up to 69.9%, which, on top of service and insurance fees, could mean customers were paying two to three times the cost of the item on the high street. Some customers were never able to own the goods if they fell behind on payments.

BrightHouse customers were typically from low-income households receiving state benefits. The decision means some of the UK’s most vulnerable consumers could be missing out on crucial funds, just as the cost of living crisis squeezes finances.

Grant Thornton originally set aside up to £600,000 to deal with more than 11,000 affordability claims from customers who fear they may have been mis-sold loans. But its latest report, published in late April, reveals that the administrators plan to seek court permission to scrap the compensation pot after deciding that the cost would be too high.

“Given the likely significant volume and complexity of customers’ affordability claims … it is the administrators’ expectation that the cost associated with assessing these claims would far exceed the funds available for distribution,” the report said.

“As a result of the above, the administrators are seeking to make an application to the court in the coming period to seek to disapply the prescribed part,” it added.

Under the original plans, customers would have been due refunds for fees and interest, as well as an additional 8% interest on that sum dating back to the start of their loan.

Meanwhile, administrators confirmed they had hired a debt collection agency to “improve” repayments from customers and “maximise” payouts for creditors. Those creditors have included Greensill Capital, whose collapse last year sparked a wave of political scandals.

Greensill, which specialised in offering advances on company invoices for a fee, issued loans to BrightHouse in 2018. As a lender, Greensill was counted as a secured creditor, putting it at the front of the queue for repayment when its customer, BrightHouse, went bust. The administrators’ report confirmed that Greensill was repaid in full, receiving a total of £30.86m in 2020 – a year before it collapsed into administration.

Sara Williams, a debt adviser and author of the Debt Camel blog, said: “The hundreds of thousands of customers who should have had a refund for unaffordable lending will receive nothing. The money that customers have been pushed into paying during the administration is all going to the secured creditors.”

She added: “The government and the Insolvency Service need to change this. The customers are the innocent victims here and they should be given priority. Administrators should not seek to collect debts without considering first if the loan was mis-sold.”

The issue is particularly acute for customers of rent-to-own firms, who are typically young, female, or single parents, living in rented accommodation.

Customers have faced similar problems when dealing with the collapsed payday lenders such as Wonga. Hundreds of thousands of its former borrowers who were mis-sold loans by the company were told they would only receive 4.3p for every £1 owed in compensation.

Sign up to the daily Business Today email or follow Guardian Business on Twitter at @BusinessDesk

A spokesperson for administrators at Grant Thornton, which is also handling Greensill’s wind-down in the UK, said they were carrying out their obligations in line with UK insolvency rules and have distributed assets from BrightHouse “as required by legislation”.

The spokesperson said.“Whilst Greensill Capital (UK) Ltd was previously a secured creditor to BrightHouse, any obligations it was owed as part of BrightHouse’s administration were paid to it in accordance with the law and prior to it entering into administration itself. We have no further comments beyond the contents of the administrators’ filings in respect of both matters.”

A spokesperson for the Insolvency Service said: “The insolvency framework is designed to ensure that the creditors of an insolvent business receive as much of their money back as possible, and it is the duty of insolvency practitioners to consider the interests of all of the creditors in carrying out their work.”


Kalyeena Makortoff Banking correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Consumer groups welcome move to ensure finance firms put customers first
Mortgages, pensions, investments and loans must have duty to customer, says UK’s financial watchdog

Shane Hickey

14, May, 2021 @4:39 PM

Article image
High street banks warn of rise in UK customers defaulting on loans
Lenders expect wave of defaults this spring as cost of living soars, Bank of England survey finds

Richard Partington Economics correspondent

14, Apr, 2022 @12:07 PM

Article image
Rent-to-own retailer BrightHouse ordered to repay £14.8m to customers
Financial Conduct Authority says company supplying household goods on high-cost credit has not been ‘a responsible lender’

Julia Kollewe

24, Oct, 2017 @1:51 PM

Article image
PPI complaints to ombudsman soar as banks fail to deal with claims
Financial Ombudsman Service received a record 2m inquiries and complaints last year, including almost 380,000 about PPI

Miles Brignall

29, May, 2013 @5:30 AM

Article image
Rent-to-own BrightHouse accused of sidestepping Covid payment guidance
Administrators of the collapsed firm continue to ‘maximise’ loan collections from struggling customers

Kalyeena Makortoff Banking correspondent

30, Aug, 2020 @12:40 PM

Article image
Surge in UK consumer borrowing fuels likely interest rate rise
The 9.9% annual growth figure further adds to concerns of unmanageable debt among UK households

Phillip Inman

30, Oct, 2017 @12:13 PM

Article image
Borrowers on payment holidays to receive 'thuggish' debt letters
Campaign bids to change 1970s law forcing UK lenders to issue payments warning

Patrick Collinson

03, Jun, 2020 @5:01 AM

Article image
UK insolvencies at highest level since financial crisis
Personal debt balloons to £1.6tn as record number of households turn to ‘bankruptcy deals’

Patrick Collinson

26, Jan, 2018 @1:23 PM

Article image
Eurostar urged to tell customers they are entitled to refunds for cancelled trips
Rail regulator intervenes after several buyers claim they were offered e-vouchers instead

Miles Brignall

23, Dec, 2020 @2:58 PM

Article image
Consumer credit races ahead as UK households struggle to cope
People borrowed an extra £1.8bn in June, up from £900m in May, Bank of England figures show

Phillip Inman

29, Jul, 2022 @1:01 PM