Failing energy firms will cost UK consumers £2.7bn, says watchdog

National Audit Office accuses Ofgem of creating a market ‘vulnerable to large-scale shocks’

Consumers will need to pay £2.7bn to cover the costs of 28 energy suppliers failing since June 2021, according to the government’s spending watchdog.

The National Audit Office (NAO) said bill payers had “borne the brunt” of the failures and accused energy regulator Ofgem of creating a market “vulnerable to large-scale shocks”.

A swathe of energy suppliers have collapsed over the past year as a sixfold spike in the cost of wholesale gas between February and December 2021 crippled companies who were unable to increase costs to customers because of the government’s energy price cap.

Ofgem had embarked on a drive to open up the market to smaller players before the price crunch. But big energy suppliers have argued that new entrants should have hedged greater proportions of their energy.

The failures are expected to cost about £94 per customer. The costs, which included missing payments by failed suppliers into government schemes to support renewable generation, are shared across all energy bills, not just for the customers of failed suppliers.

On top of the £2.7bn, the government is spending taxpayer funds to support green energy supplier Bulb, which collapsed last November. Bulb, which has 1.6 million customers and is the largest supplier to have failed, is in a special administration funded by the government.

Last financial year, the government spent £900,000 on an administrator to run Bulb and expects to spend a further £1bn this year. The final bill will not be clear until Bulb exits administration. A trio of bidders – British Gas, Abu Dhabi’s Masdar and Octopus Energy – are understood to be interested in Bulb.

Gareth Davies, the head of the NAO, said: “By allowing so many suppliers with weak finances to enter the market, and by failing to imagine that there could be a long period of volatility in energy prices, Ofgem allowed a market to develop that was vulnerable to large-scale shocks.”

Sign up to the daily Business Today email or follow Guardian Business on Twitter at @BusinessDesk

The NAO recommended that the government and Ofgem should establish a process for considering the impact of new interventions in the retail market, like the price cap. It also said Ofgem should define a set of objectives for its regulation of the retail market and report on its performance.

Ofgem is tightening rules around the financial resilience of suppliers, consulting on whether to set the price cap quarterly and on ringfencing consumer credit balances.

Dame Clare Moriarty, chief executive of Citizens Advice, said: “It’s totally unacceptable that suppliers entered the market without proper checks and that customers were landed with a multibillion-pound bill as a result.”

Nigel Pocklington, chief executive of green energy supplier Good Energy, said: “Ofgem is taking action now but at this point the suppliers still standing are generally well run – the stable doors are closing after the horses have bolted.”

Ofgem said it “accepts” the report’s findings and is “already working hard to address all of the issues raised”.


Alex Lawson Energy correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Energy firms warned by watchdog of 'radical' change ahead
Ofgem tells suppliers to prepare for range of reforms, including switching customers automatically to better deals

Adam Vaughan

19, Oct, 2017 @2:22 PM

Watchdog tells energy firms to speed up price cuts

Ofgem threatens to refer energy industry to Competition Commission over unfair premiums for consumers

Mark Milner and Tim Webb

17, Dec, 2008 @12:01 AM

Article image
Energy bills still leave consumers confused despite Ofgem reforms

Survey by Which? finds almost two-thirds of consumers unable to work out cheapest deal from big six power companies

Terry Macalister

14, Mar, 2014 @12:05 AM

Article image
Energy watchdog accused of stalling electric vehicle rollout
Scottish Power boss says UK regulator needs reform after refusing upgrades to cope with e-vehicle demand

Jillian Ambrose

18, Oct, 2019 @3:22 PM

Energy watchdog investigates npower bill errors

Energy regulator to investigate £60m in overcharges after changes made to bill calculation

Miles Brignall and Mark Milner

17, Jun, 2008 @11:01 PM

Article image
Energy companies boost profits despite gas price cuts, warns energy watchdog
Critics brand revelation the final straw for consumers with Ofgem calling on competition watchdog to take widening profit figures into account

Sean Farrell

29, Jan, 2015 @2:27 PM

Article image
Ofgem tells energy firms: 'one last chance'
Energy regulator's ultimatum gives 'big six' firms two months to reform or face a full-scale competition commission inquiry

Tim Webb

21, Mar, 2011 @8:40 PM

Article image
Regulator sorry for not capping UK consumers' energy bills sooner
Ofgem chief Dermot Nolan to not receive bonus as MPs liken him to ‘a bystander, rather than active participant in the market’

Adam Vaughan

10, Jan, 2018 @1:13 PM

Article image
Energy consumers face £172m bill for collapse of 11 suppliers
Warnings 32,000 households may be targeted by debt collectors

Jillian Ambrose

20, Jun, 2019 @11:01 PM

Article image
Energy firms' profit from customers has risen 77% in a year, says Ofgem
Big six energy companies made £53 profit per customer before latest price rises – up from £30 a year earlier

Jennifer Rankin

25, Nov, 2013 @7:13 PM