Cyclist run over by partially sighted motorist still battling with insurers

Joanna Davies was dragged along the road for 20 metres but has been offered less than half the £11,000 she has claimed

A Hampshire cyclist who was driven over by a partially sighted motorist has described her struggle to get the driver’s insurer, Aviva, to pay out.

It is more than a year since Joanna Davies was dragged along the road for 20 metres by the elderly driver, who was found to have such poor eyesight that his car was impounded by the police on the spot.

But despite him admitting liability at the time, being successfully prosecuted for driving without due care and attention and later banned, Davies says Aviva’s appointed lawyers have so far refused to accept that she needs a new bike or to even replace the clothes the paramedics had to cut off her at the scene.

Had Davies been in her car instead of her new Dutch bike, she suspects her claim would have been paid months ago.

She says her solicitor told her this week that Aviva has offered just over £5,000, less than half of the £11,000 she has claimed. If it goes to court she faces another year of waiting.

Aviva has denied it is stalling or refusing to pay her claim, and has pledged to conclude the matter.

“I was cycling home on my new electric bike of three weeks when a driver ran me over from behind,” she says. “My bike and I were pulled under his car. A witness later described how he had carried on driving because he thought he had hit a traffic cone.”

Davies blacked out for a few seconds with the initial impact. “When I came to, I was being dragged along with my head inches from the rear wheel arch before I was able to free myself and roll away,” she says. “The driver carried on another 30m with my bike under his car and only stopped when other motorists forced him to pull over. Had I not been wearing a helmet the worst could have happened, and it was the most unbelievably terrifying event.”

After the crash she hired the law firm Bott and Co to pursue a claim against Aviva to cover the cost of her bike, cyclewear and income while she was unable to work.

The businesswoman, who runs the Gilded Teapot, a tea shop in Lymington, says she followed all the advice and kept a recovery diary, tracked everything she had to spend on taxis and trains while she was on crutches and took photos of her injuries. Her accountant calculated her loss of earnings.

Joanna Davies outside the Gilded Teapot
Joanna Davies runs the Gilded Teapot in Lymington. Photograph: Joanna Davies

However, she says there have been delays all the way through the process.

“Basically, I’m exhausted. It’s really distressing to have to keep advocating for how much this crash has affected me. Apart from the police and the amazing paramedics, no one in this process seems to give a toss,” she says.

“The driver’s insurance seem to think I’m fraudulent but I’ve sent absolutely everything which proves I’m not. I just don’t understand why this is happening.”

Aviva says: “We were very sorry to hear of the accident and the injuries Ms Davies sustained in her road traffic accident. We have reviewed the details of the claim and confirmed liability but are still awaiting basic information. We’re going to be in touch with Ms Davies’ solicitors to try to conclude this matter as quickly as possible.”

Russell Stephens of the charity Cycling UK recommends using legal support when pursuing a claim related to road traffic incidents. Members of the charity get free legal support.

“Professional support can make a real difference, not just in a successful claim but also reducing the trauma of having to relive the incident each time you engage with the other party.

“It’s one of the main reasons why Cycling UK works closely with the law firm Slater and Gordon to offer free legal advice to our members in relation to cycling incidents, and also provides clear free guidance for anyone who is involved in a cycling collision on our website.”


Miles Brignall

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
‘My parked car was hit twice, but the insurers won’t pay’
Jacqueline Green’s vehicle is a write-off after two crashes that weren’t her fault. So why is she unable to claim?

Miles Brignall

26, Aug, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
EU’s gender ruling on car insurance has made inequality worse
It said car insurance firms couldn’t discriminate between the sexes ... since then men have seen a four-fold rise in premiums

Patrick Collinson

14, Jan, 2017 @6:59 AM

Article image
AA staff accuse association over ‘shameful’ price hikes
New members can face an automatic 124% increase in fees in year two. Now embarrassed members of the salesforce talk about the tactics

Miles Brignall

07, Apr, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
Why am I now liable for my ‘no fault’ accident claim?
Credit hire company EasiDrive says I will face legal and other costs if I don’t go to court

Anna Tims

14, Sep, 2018 @6:00 AM

Article image
Your car in the Covid lockdown: how to save on insurance and more
Some Britons are driving much less than before– here are ways to cut costs

Sue Hayward

06, Mar, 2021 @1:00 PM

Article image
Swiftcover won’t pay out what I’m due after a serious car accident
We claimed, but we can’t get the £1,000 or so the vehicle was worth

Miles Brignall

20, May, 2019 @6:00 AM

Article image
UK travel insurers stopping policy sales over coronavirus
Which? calls for urgent action by government, insurance firms and travel sector

Rupert Jones

13, Mar, 2020 @5:18 PM

Article image
Avoid paying a premium for car insurance
Latest figures reveal the soaring costs of cover, with warnings of further rises to come. But here’s what you can do to get a better deal

Rupert Jones

24, Sep, 2016 @6:00 AM

Article image
Car insurance firms use loopholes to keep costs high for loyal customers
It is banned from charging more for renewals than new deals, but the industry still has some tricks up its sleeve

Anna Tims

28, May, 2022 @8:00 AM

Article image
Aviva puts brakes on party bus whiplash claim
Insurer lashes out at ‘outrageous scale’ of fraud as it revealed sucessful fight against 46 claimants whose party bus collided with a Ford Fiesta

Hilary Osborne

07, Jan, 2016 @8:10 PM