Childcare crisis risks pushing women out of workforce, says TUC

Families in Britain struggle with reduced access to nurseries and informal care during pandemic

Two in five working mothers with children under 10 in Britain are struggling to find the childcare they need, as breakfast and after-school clubs remain shut and care from friends and family remains limited, according to a survey for the TUC.

The lack of access to childcare has resulted in a crisis that risks turning the clock back on decades of labour market progress, warned Frances O’Grady, the general secretary of the Trades Union Congress.

“Women workers have borne the brunt of this crisis – both on the frontline and at home,” she said. “But this can’t go on. If we don’t take this childcare crisis seriously, women will be pushed out of the workforce.”

The ICM survey found that 41% of working mothers with children under 10 cannot get, or are unsure whether they will get, enough childcare to cover the hours they need from this month. Nearly half (45%) said they do not have their usual help from friends and family, while 35% said they cannot get places at after-school clubs and 28% have lost childcare provided by school breakfast clubs. The same proportion (28%) do not have their usual nursery or childminder available.

While previous surveys suggest all parents have taken on more childcare during the pandemic, the survey found that while 43% of women said they have had to combine working at home and childcare, the same was true for only 29% of their male partners.

Ness, a midwife in south-east England with two primary-age children, said the school now required breakfast and the after-school club to be booked weeks in advance – but she is told of her shift pattern at much shorter notice. “Although my husband has been able to work at home, he is under increasing pressure to be in the office more frequently,” she said. “Our childcare plans aren’t confirmed for September and the coming months, and it is extremely stressful.”

The TUC has called on the government to expand the furlough scheme beyond October for parents without the childcare they need, as well as asking for companies to provide more flexibility for working parents.

The poll found 1 in 6 working mothers – mostly in low-paid jobs – said they have had no choice but to reduce their working hours.

The survey also revealed how working mothers are being stretched to their limits: 3 in 10 said they regularly worked early in the morning (pre-8am) or late at night (post-8pm) to balance work and childcare.

The CEO of Working Families, Jane van Zyl, said parents were being expected to return to work in a similar way to early March, without vital childcare infrastructure. “Caring responsibilities have been absent from the government’s economic recovery plans, and they now need to be centre stage,” she said.

Experts have warned that the pandemic could set women back decades and increase the gender pay gap. The survey found that one in six women said that they were worried that balancing work and childcare had affected how they would be assessed by their manager, while one in six said they were worried that it had affected their chances of a promotion in the future.

The chair of the women and equalities select committee, Caroline Nokes, said the government had failed to heed months of warnings about the “real crisis looming”. “Throughout the pandemic, women have consistently raised concerns that they were more likely to be furloughed, more likely to be doing the home-schooling and more likely to feel marginalised at work,” she said. “This is further evidence that the pandemic may have seen real employment progress for women go into reverse.

“We want women to come out of this pandemic in as good an employment position as men, and without some proactive policy to bring that about, it will simply not happen.”

The childcare sector has recently intensified its lobbying of government, warning that thousands of providers may go bust without swift intervention.

O’Grady added: “Childcare providers desperately need new government cash to stay open. And we need an extension to the job retention scheme for mums and dads who can’t return to work because of childcare responsibilities.”

Contributor

Alexandra Topping

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
UK working mothers are 'sacrificial lambs' in coronavirus childcare crisis
Exclusive: Survey reveals lack of childcare played role in almost half of female layoffs

Alexandra Topping

24, Jul, 2020 @3:00 PM

Article image
Sunak's jobs plan must be backed by childcare funding, say MPs
Chancellor failed to offer financial help to nurseries in summer statement

Heather Stewart Political editor

09, Jul, 2020 @3:56 PM

Article image
Childcare constraints forcing more women to work closer to home
Gender commuting gap shows women across UK more likely to live 15 minutes from work

Jasper Jolly

07, Nov, 2018 @6:28 PM

Article image
Working families' childcare costs outstrip wage rises, says TUC
Fees have soared by 52% over past decade, compared with 17% rise in earnings

Ben Quinn

02, Sep, 2018 @11:01 PM

Article image
UK society regressing back to 1950s for many women, warn experts
Study suggest worsening inequality during lockdown, with women saddled with more not less childcare

Hannah Summers

18, Jun, 2020 @2:04 PM

Article image
UK risks ‘turning clock back’ on gender equality in pandemic
Select committee issues 20 recommendations including maintaining universal credit increase

Ian Johnston

09, Feb, 2021 @12:01 AM

Article image
Women took on bulk of childcare during British lockdown, study finds
ONS polls show impact of home-schooling on parents’ mental health, with women hardest hit

Richard Adams Education editor

22, Jul, 2020 @1:37 PM

Article image
Unions chief: lack of planning risks chaotic reopening of schools
Call for taskforce to be set up to coordinate classroom return for some in England on 1 June

Heather Stewart and Richard Adams

21, May, 2020 @7:26 PM

Article image
UK childcare costs soar by more than £2,000 in a decade, TUC says
Analysis shows average nursery fees for children under two have risen by £185 month since Tories took office

Alexandra Topping

13, Jun, 2022 @5:00 AM

Article image
Boris Johnson urged to set out credible back-to-office plan
Unions and industry bodies call for focus on test and trace, transport and childcare issues

Heather Stewart and Rob Davies

28, Aug, 2020 @2:38 PM