Amazon Marketplace purchases not covered by Consumer Credit Act

If you pay Amazon and it passes the money on to the retailer, a loophole could leave you without redress

Shoppers using Amazon Marketplace to buy high-value items have been warned that their credit card company won't come to their aid if there's a major problem with their purchase and the retailer refuses to help.

For years consumers paying for any item costing more than £100 with a credit card have been able to hold the card provider jointly liable in the event of a significant problem with the item. This right, enshrined in section 75 of the Consumer Credit act, covers items bought in the £100 to £30,000 range.

However, it has emerged that shoppers buying through Amazon's Marketplace service do not get this protection because of the complicated way the internet giant processes payments. The fact that Amazon takes the money then passes it on to the retailer – minus its commission – renders the protection invalid, Guardian Money has learned.

Robert Pert, of Skegness, Lincolnshire, is among those hit by this loophole. In September he bought a £150 exercise treadmill from an Amazon Marketplace online retailer called Health & Fitness Direct. After six weeks the item failed, and he discovered he was not the only buyer having problems with the product.

Repeated attempts to contact the retailer and then Amazon drew requests to send the item back for repair. However, given the host of negative posts from other buyers, some of whom had accepted returns and had still further problems, he decided the item was not of merchantable quality and demanded his money back.

Amazon refused, so he approached his credit card supplier, Lloyds Bank, for a section 75 claim. He was shocked when the bank wrote back saying that because he had paid Amazon for the item, the claim would not be met.

The Financial Ombudsman Service has confirmed that similar cases brought by other consumers have been turned down for the same reason.

It means that buyers wanting to gain credit card protection should avoid buying through Marketplace and instead go direct to the seller's independent website and pay with their card there. Had Pert done this, Lloyds would have had to consider his claim.

A spokesman for Amazon said: "The Amazon A-to-Z Guarantee provides additional protection for customers who buy from the third party Marketplace when payment is made via the website. This covers an item received being defective, damaged, not as described, or received late. We have contacted the customer in question to advise him to raise an A-to-Z Guarantee claim and will review on receipt."

But Amazon's small print shows that claims can only be made up until 90 days after the order is placed, meaning Pert is out of time. Other potential Amazon Marketplace users should note there is no protection if the expensive item fails after 90 days and the retailer will not help. Sometimes the manufacturer will honour a warranty. However, the Sale of Goods Act makes the retailer responsible, and they should always be you first port of call.

The good news is that Health & Fitness Direct has told us that at the start of Pert's problem it offered him a full refund if he returned the item, and the offer still stands – although he has to organise and pay for a courier.


Miles Brignall

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Alternatives to Amazon: MPs spread seasonal boycott message
Margaret Hodge, chair of the parliament public accounts committee, is one of several MPs urging an Amazon boycott. We look at alternative places to shop

Rupert Jones

30, Nov, 2013 @7:00 AM

Article image
How to kick that Amazon habit
My lowest point came when I ordered a pair of bootlaces for a couple of quid. Now I avoid the site at all costs

Patrick Collinson

09, Nov, 2012 @11:02 PM

Article image
How to have an Amazon-free Christmas … and save money

We price checked this year's top toys and found that people concerned about the online giant's tax issues can easily shun it

Patrick Collinson and Jill Papworth

03, Dec, 2012 @10:49 AM

Article image
The most-asked money questions on Google

What are the most searched for personal finance questions on Google? And, most importantly, what are the answers to your money queries?

Patrick Collinson, Tony Levene, Mark King, Jill Papworth, Rupert Jones

07, Sep, 2012 @10:00 PM

Article image
Internet cookie crunch on the way for online shoppers
Websites must soon ask visitors to consent to cookies under new rules, producing the potential for a rash of pop-ups

Rupert Jones

30, Mar, 2012 @10:01 PM

Article image
Banned by Amazon for returning faulty goods
Greg Nelson has bought 343 items from the online giant since 2014. But after sending 37 back he is now blocked from using it and can’t reclaim his credit balance

Miles Brignall

18, Mar, 2016 @9:08 AM

Article image
Amazon wipes customer's Kindle and deletes account with no explanation

Kindle user had her account deleted because it had ties to 'previous abuses of company policy', but the online retailer blanked all follow-up enquiries

Mark King

22, Oct, 2012 @2:25 PM

Article image
Amazon is making me share my payment details
New rules for Amazon Prime are forcing me to reveal details against all banking terms

Anna Tims

25, Aug, 2016 @6:00 AM

Article image
Amazon's Luxembourg base means improved consumer rights

Amazon is covered by Luxembourg consumer laws – which means its goods are protected for two years, not one. But will it pay up? Miles Brignall investigates

Miles Brignall

30, Apr, 2010 @11:21 PM

Article image
Consumer rights bill receives warm welcome

The new 'bill of rights' should rescue consumers from the cycle of failed repairs and replacements and clarify their rights online

Patrick Collinson

11, May, 2013 @6:00 AM