Can Schofield and Willoughby recover from Queen’s queue fallout?

ITV presenters could highlight the good causes they have helped, PR experts suggest

Queen Elizabeth II’s funeral was an emotional event for many Britons. It allowed the nation to reflect on the passage of time, to deal with the loss of a historic figure, and to unite in criticism of the ITV presenters Phillip Schofield and Holly Willoughby for supposed queue-jumping offences.

The presenters of This Morning went from national sweethearts to national villains after they were accused of avoiding the eight-hour queue to see the Queen lying in state by entering Westminster Hall via a side entrance.

A petition to have them axed from the ITV’s show has now reached more than 55,000 signatures, while their meme-ification continues across social media and tabloid headlines. Domino’s Pizza tweeted: “Apologies to anyone waiting on their pizza, we’ve just received an order from Holly and Phil,” and the London Dungeon said it would let any guest who asked for a “Holly & Phil” at the door to gain queue-jumping rights for the same price as a standard ticket.

Schofield and Willougby’s defence was simple: their visit to Westminster Hall was “strictly for reporting” and they respected the rules set for the media. But for many of their viewers the damage was already done.

“I think the problem stemmed from them not making it clear before they visited the Queen lying in state that they were there ‘working’ and so it made it very difficult after the event to justify what was perceived as a ‘queue jump’,” said Simon Wadsworth, managing partner of the reputation management firm Igniyte.

“Given that it was well known that some people had queued for lots of hours, and even overnight, it was somewhat insensitive but probably a genuine oversight.”

What the public may not have known is that hundreds of journalists took up the chance to spend half an hour observing the public filing past the monarch’s coffin. They arrived in small groups before being led to a platform in Westminster Hall where they could reflect on proceedings in order to inform their reporting. Mobile phones were not allowed but they were allowed to take pen and paper into the hall.

Schofield and Willoughby were accompanied on their visit by a team that included Martin Frizell, the editor of This Morning, although an ITV spokesperson said he did not enter Westminster Hall.

Three issues appear to have combined towards creating this mini-scandal around a queue. First, it appears that Schofield and Willoughby were led to a different area of the hall from other journalists – which had the effect of allowing them to be caught on camera.

Second, footage spread across Instagram and TikTok before the intended broadcast on This Morning – priming viewers to believe that they had jumped the public queue. Third, This Morning’s audience seem to be particularly ill-disposed towards the pair and with regard to any potential breaches of royal etiquette – especially when fellow ITV presenter Susanna Reid chose to queue with the public.

So what can crisis and reputation management gurus like Wadsworth, whose firm’s list of clients include a Knight of the Realm, a film producer and a former Bond girl, advise? “Their statement seemed to lack empathy,” Wadsworth said. “I would have recommended a quick response along the lines of, ‘Whilst they were following guidelines they appreciated how it could be perceived and apologise for the impact it had’ – show a bit of contrition to make the public warm to their situation.”

For John Harrington, the editor of PR Week, who’s seen his fair share of crises, this one is particularly absurd. “Given the number of crises in the world at the moment, it’s logically ridiculous that allegations of queue jumping by two broadcasters have caused so many bad headlines, and apparently so much anger,” he said.

Harrington said the reason for the backlash was the same as for Boris Johnson’s lockdown parties: the sense of unfairness, of “one rule for them, another rule for the rest of us”. “Everyone has waited in a queue, just as everyone had to isolate during lockdown,” he said, adding that it was unfortunate the scandal came so soon after the “wheel of fortune” contest that offered to pay people’s energy bills.

The statement
A message from This Morning about Phillip Schofield and Holly Willoughby Photograph: This morning

Both Harrington and Wadsworth agreed that in the long term, the presenters could help rebuild their reputations by talking about good cause work they’ve done. “Usually we would help the client create positive new stories to counter the negative, perhaps focusing on the work they do for charity or the community to earn some good will back from those who feel they have let them down.”


Nadia Khomami and Jim Waterson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
ITV chief defends Holly Willoughby and Phillip Schofield over alleged queue-jumping
Carolyn McCall said pair’s jobs were safe and blamed misinformation from a ‘shrill minority’

Mark Sweney

27, Sep, 2022 @7:02 PM

Article image
Disabled woman was not moved for Holly Willoughby and Phillip Schofield to see Queen lying in state – ITV
Thousands sign petition for This Morning hosts to be fired after claims they jumped queue at Westminster Hall

Sophie Zeldin-O'Neill

25, Sep, 2022 @3:09 PM

Article image
Willoughby and Schofield ‘would never jump queue’ to see Queen lying in state
After criticism for skipping queue, ITV’s This Morning presenters said visit was ‘strictly for reporting’

Alexandra Topping

21, Sep, 2022 @7:37 AM

Article image
Holly Willoughby to replace Ant McPartlin on I'm a Celebrity
‘Hols and Dec’ will head for the Australian jungle this autumn, while regular co-host takes time off to treat addiction

Lanre Bakare

29, Aug, 2018 @10:45 AM

Article image
How do Holly Willoughby and Phillip Schofield rescue their reputations? | Zoe Williams
The queue row has left the This Morning presenters fighting to survive as the nation’s favourites. Here’s how everyone can move on, writes Zoe Williams

Zoe Williams

27, Sep, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Phillip Schofield, ITV presenter, announces he is gay
This Morning host appeals for kindness, particularly to wife and daughters who support him

Haroon Siddique

07, Feb, 2020 @1:11 PM

Article image
More than 29m people in UK watched Queen’s funeral, TV data shows
Figure is fewer than 31m who watched Euro 2020 final, and peaked at 19.5m viewers on BBC One

Jim Waterson and Tobi Thomas

20, Sep, 2022 @6:26 PM

Article image
BBC urged to reform complaints policy amid Naga Munchetty row
Handling of viewer feedback revives concerns over treatment of BAME staff

Jim Waterson Media editor

01, Oct, 2019 @6:04 PM

Article image
Susanna Reid: I've had enough of men telling me about feminism
Presenter says men accuse her of enabling Piers Morgan’s anti-feminist views

Staff and agency

18, Jun, 2018 @11:01 PM

Article image
This Morning's Alison Hammond: 'I had to educate myself on black history'
Her magnetic personality has endeared her to millions of viewers of the magazine show. Now, Hammond is delving into something more serious, exploring untold stories of black Britons

Alim Kheraj

28, Sep, 2020 @11:16 AM