ABC article defamed commando by naming him and running ‘huge colour photo’, court told

Heston Russell’s lawyer tells federal court readers were given ‘impression’ he was responsible for shooting an unarmed prisoner in Afghanistan

Lawyers for a former special forces officer have argued an ABC article portrayed him as a war criminal, despite not directly alleging he had committed crimes.

Heston Russell is suing the ABC and two of its investigative journalists over stories published in 2020 and 2021 which he argues gave readers the “impression” he was responsible for shooting an unarmed prisoner and was being investigated.

One article, published in 2021, asserted an Australian commando platoon was being investigated over its actions in Afghanistan in 2012 as well as allegations made by a US marine helicopter pilot that – on a 2012 mission – he heard the “pop” of an unarmed and handcuffed prisoner being executed by Australian soldiers because there was no room for them on the extraction flight.

Russell was the commanding officer of November platoon, 2nd Commando Regiment, in 2012, and present on the platoon’s missions. He was quoted in the article as denying the allegations and saying his platoon had never harmed a prisoner. He called on the ABC to apologise.

Russell’s lawyer, Sue Chrysanthou SC, argued in the federal court on Wednesday that the article’s assertion his platoon was under investigation, along with the publication of his name and picture, left the reader with the impression he was involved in the shooting.

“The only commando identified in any of the publications is my client – a huge colour photo of him and his full name,” Chrysanthou told Justice Michael Lee.

“It is a shocking allegation of murder … and the only person the reader is left with being responsible for it is my client.

“It is frankly divorced from reality to suggest the reader would not immediately, seeing the lovely, shiny photograph of my client in this article, and reading how despicably the commandos behaved, such that the marines refused to work with them ever again, would not think that this guy is the commander of a unit that killed people.”

The ABC is arguing a defence of contextual truth, in that Russell was the commander of the platoon which was under investigation, and that the allegations raised in the stories were in the public interest.

Court documents filed by the ABC claim it is true that members of November platoon were the subject of a criminal investigation by the Office of the Special Investigator into their conduct in Afghanistan.

Chrysanthou argued Russell was implicated as either being guilty of shooting the prisoner or of being involved in criminal wrongdoing – despite the article not directly naming him as responsible.

She said an “ordinary” person reading the article would be left with that impression.

“This isn’t an analysis of a haiku, it’s something where a person is flicking through their phone on a bus or reading these things first thing in the morning,” she told the court.

The barrister said Russell’s denial, included in the article, rather than effectively countering the allegations would probably be interpreted as him lying.

“Publishing a mere denial isn’t sufficient. The reader needs to leave … understanding that the allegation is false,” Chrysanthou said. “The reader would think, ‘Well he would deny it wouldn’t he’.”

Acting for the ABC, Lyndelle Barnett, said there were “multiple layers the reader had to jump through” to arrive at the conclusion Russell was guilty of murder and the “ordinary, reasonable reader” would not arrive at that conclusion.

She argued that allegations of wrongdoing against one or more members of the platoon did not implicate the group as a whole and would not be interpreted as such by readers.

“The ordinary person wouldn’t take it to mean it was every member of a platoon that was shooting a prisoner,” Barnett told the court on Wednesday.

Russell wants the ABC to remove the article and pay aggravated damages on top of court costs. The case continues.

Additional reporting Australian Associated Press

Contributor

Ben Doherty

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Christian Porter v ABC: can the minister sue for defamation over article that didn't name him?
What will be determined by the case? Will it preclude an independent inquiry?

Paul Karp

16, Mar, 2021 @5:27 AM

Article image
Christian Porter acting for Mick Gatto in his high court appeal over ABC defamation case
Former attorney general, who discontinued his own defamation action against the ABC last year, among underworld figure’s legal representation

Paul Karp

05, Jul, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial: witness expected to deny wrongdoing in killing of Afghan villager
Person 11 to give evidence on allegation by newspapers that Roberts-Smith kicked handcuffed man off cliff before ordering him shot

Ben Doherty

08, May, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
Captive Afghan teenage boy allegedly shot in the head, Ben Roberts-Smith’s defamation trial hears
Former comrade called as witness by Roberts-Smith denies seeing teen alive or recognising photo of dead body

Ben Doherty

12, May, 2022 @5:34 AM

Article image
Ben Roberts-Smith: SAS soldier tells defamation trial he refused to be interviewed by AFP about Afghanistan
Witness denies assertions from newspapers that he was motivated to lie to derail an investigation into possible war crimes

Ben Doherty

11, May, 2022 @10:29 PM

Article image
Missing witness and a change of government: the latest delays in Ben Roberts-Smith’s defamation case
Trial held up due to Covid and fall of Kabul now waits for evidence release by new attorney general and reappearance of Person 27

Ben Doherty

27, May, 2022 @2:57 AM

Article image
Man pleads guilty to harassing ABC’s Mark Willacy over reporting on alleged Afghanistan war crimes
Thomas Mark Rickard, who served in ADF, avoids conviction but is ordered to pay $1,000 good behaviour bond for leaving reporter abusive and threatening voicemail

Nino Bucci

29, Aug, 2022 @3:49 AM

Article image
Ben Roberts-Smith’s defamation trial laid bare the brutal reality of Australia’s decades-long war in Afghanistan – now the ex-soldier awaits judgment
While costs of about $25m and possibly millions in damages are at stake, the trial also has existential implications for Australian journalism

Ben Doherty

27, Jul, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
SAS soldier tells Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial he felt hurt by best man who made murder allegation against him
Former comrade denies in court that he and Roberts-Smith killed handcuffed Afghan man Ali Jan as alleged by newspapers in their defence

Ben Doherty

11, May, 2022 @5:31 AM

Article image
Woman who says Ben Roberts-Smith punched her sustained an injury in a fall earlier on same night, defamation trial hears
Person 17 does not contest she fell down stairs, but in evidence given to defamation trial in March says Roberts-Smith punched her later that night, a claim Roberts-Smith denies

Ben Doherty

13, May, 2022 @4:57 AM