Sarah Ferguson hits back at media watchdog’s findings on ABC’s Fox News documentary

Four Corners host says report has huge implications for the ability of the broadcaster to ‘fearlessly’ pursue public interest journalism

The high-profile ABC journalist whose Four Corners documentary about Fox News was found to have breached the public broadcasters editorial code, has hit back at adverse findings by Australia’s media watchdog.

The Australian Communications and Media Authority (Acma) found on Wednesday that reporter Sarah Ferguson’s two-part documentary Fox and the Big Lie breached the accuracy and fair dealing requirements of the ABC’s editorial code, but did not violate impartiality standards.

The program focused on the Murdoch empire’s Fox News and the 2020 US election.

Ferguson responded to Acma’s report in a 1,200-word piece published by the ABC on Thursday, saying that she “expected the Fox Corporation to complain loudly about our coverage. I did not expect ACMA to respond in the terms it did”.

Ferguson, who was based in the US bureau at the time of the documentary but is now the host of ABC current affairs program 7.30, said that understanding how one of the world’s most powerful media companies supported a damaging conspiracy that the election was stolen was “a compelling story in the best traditions of public interest journalism”.

“The overwhelming majority of issues raised by Fox were rejected by the regulator.

“However, ACMA’s final report and its inflammatory press release raise questions about the regulator’s understanding of journalism.”

Ferguson said that among the “simplest and silliest” assertions made by the regulator were that using the word “mob” to describe the 6 January rioters was emotive and strident language, that it was wrong to stop a Fox presenter who was a “cheerleader” for the “Big Lie” on a public street and ask her questions, and that the ABC should have included a Fox press release that was almost three years old in its story.

“In its report, responding to extensive complaints by Fox, ACMA says 19 times the ABC did not breach impartiality or mislead the audience. It identified three minor subjective breaches within our coverage,” Ferguson wrote.

“Yet the press release issued by ACMA chairperson Nerida O’Loughlin and the language of the report create an overall impression that our programs were misleading and not honest.

“I take their words extremely seriously.”

Under the sub-heading “huge implications for journalism”, Ferguson said a finding by Acma that the ABC misled the audience by failing to cover the role of social media in relation to the 6 January insurrection “most challenges the ABC’s freedom to pursue public interest journalism fearlessly”.

“It appears simple on the face of it, but its ramifications are not … ACMA found in an oddly subjective decision that we misled the audience by omitting to also cover the role of social media in relation to January 6.

“This is despite the fact that Four Corners had already produced a comprehensive episode about the insurrection months earlier.

“Consider the implications of this for journalism. According to ACMA’s interpretation of the code, the ABC is not free to choose the editorial focus it determines the most relevant.”

In August last year, Ferguson spoke to former Fox News insiders who claimed the rightwing channel became a propaganda outlet for the former president under the watch of Rupert Murdoch himself.

The program sparked an unprecedented backlash against the ABC by the Murdoch empire, both in Australia and the US, and a complaint was pursued first with the ABC, which rejected any breaches, and then with the Australian Communications and Media Authority (Acma).

In a 60-page report, Acma rejected six of Fox’s allegations of editorial breaches and upheld two. The authority found the documentary Fox and the Big Lie “came close to, but did not breach, the high bar set by the impartiality standards in the ABC’s code”.

In a statement after the publication of Acma’s findings, Fox News said it was pleased with the ruling over breaches of the editorial code.


Nino Bucci

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
How Sky News Australia turned watchdog’s rebuke over climate denial into an ‘exclusive’ story | Weekly Beast
Regulator finds commentator Rowan Dean broke accuracy and fairness rules, but Sky puts its own spin on things. Plus: is SBS moving to western Sydney?

Amanda Meade

28, Apr, 2023 @3:43 AM

Article image
Murdoch empire strikes back at ABC Four Corners documentary on Fox News’ championing of Trump
Fox sent letter threatening possible legal action to Australian broadcaster before two-part program on the relationship with former US president aired

Amanda Meade

25, Aug, 2021 @11:05 PM

Article image
‘We’re not in fear’: Sarah Ferguson unfazed by Murdoch backlash after Fox News special and says more to come
ABC’s Four Corners episode ruffled plenty of feathers at News Corp Australia. Plus: Paul Barry’s fill in impressed by Media Watch’s fairness

Amanda Meade

27, Aug, 2021 @5:20 AM

Article image
Sarah Ferguson to replace Leigh Sales as host of ABC’s 7.30 program
Former Four Corners presenter has won five Walkley awards in a career with the ABC stretching back to 2008

Amanda Meade

28, Apr, 2022 @10:07 PM

Article image
Executive decision: Lachlan Murdoch turns back on media inquiry to reopen Fox News | The Weekly Beast
News Corp co-chairman declines Senate communications committee invitation. Plus: Daily Telegraph names and shames ‘index case’

Amanda Meade

03, Sep, 2021 @3:21 AM

Article image
ABC thumbs its nose at News Corp and Acma with rerun of Fox and the Big Lie | Weekly Beast
Revamped Sarah Ferguson documentary to air on Four Corners after initial version sparked complaints. Plus: the Australian’s own goal

Amanda Meade

21, Apr, 2023 @4:27 AM

Article image
The voice, try and understand it: kid gloves for reporter who asks Dutton ‘is it a man or a woman?’ | Weekly Beast
Opposition leader gently explains referendum proposal to 4BC’s Peter Fegan. Plus, Crikey’s bumpy ride rolls on

Amanda Meade

14, Apr, 2023 @4:51 AM

Article image
Kim Williams must marry ABC’s need for diversity with objective journalism, former Media Watch host says
Jonathan Holmes believes incoming ABC chair knows it is a ‘very live debate’ amid upheaval over impartiality at the broadcaster

Tory Shepherd

25, Jan, 2024 @6:22 AM

Article image
ABC’s first Middle East correspondent urges management to back staff during Israel-Gaza conflict
Peter George says journalists aren’t as protected now by management as he was in the 1980s, and are at increasing risk of self-censoring

Josh Taylor

25, Jan, 2024 @2:00 PM

Article image
ABC's Media Watch in the hot seat over baffling tweet congratulating Alan Jones | Weekly Beast
Media Watch appears to ignore years of its own reporting in fond farewell to shock jock. Plus: the Australian’s sort-of apology

Amanda Meade

15, May, 2020 @3:00 AM