Hope not hate: most social media posts on Lionesses positive, study shows

Research finds female Euro players got 125 positive posts for each hate one – in contrast to abuse directed at England men

The vast majority of social media posts directed at England women’s triumphant Euro 2022 football players across a three-month period were positive, research has found.

The study of 78,141 posts on Twitter, Reddit and the imageboard website 4chan identified more than 50,000 positive posts – roughly one “hate” post for every 125 “hope” ones.

About 380 were classed as sexist or homophobic, while the rest were either negative or neutral.

Prof Matthew Williams, director of Cardiff University’s HateLab, which carried out the analysis, said: “Last year we saw horrendous racist abuse directed at individual players after England’s men’s team lost on penalties to Italy in the Euro 2020 final.

“In the women’s Euros, we found far fewer posts directed at individual England players, which is perhaps unexpected but may be reflective of the different audience for the game and positive sentiment around the team’s success.

“The nature of the 380 posts we identified was concerning, including attempts to scorn the success of women’s football, players being told in some of the less offensive posts to ‘get back to kitchen’ or to ‘make a sandwich’, and suggestions women should not be playing football. There were also grossly offensive posts that made sexual references. It is surprising that most of these posts remain live on the platforms.”

The study developed new algorithms to analyse thousands of English-language posts sent from 2 May-1 August.

Researchers found England players received 50,422 positive posts during the 13-week period. The largest number was during last month’s final against Germany, where England won 2-1 after extra time to lift their first major women’s tournament – and only the second in England’s history.

In total, 380 posts were identified as sexist hate speech, following a similar trend over time to the positive content, and peaking with 93 posts during the final.

In comparison, after England’s penalty misses in last year’s final defeat to Italy at Euro 2020 at Wembley, there were 920 racist posts identified each hour at the peak of communications on Twitter.

The analysis of the hate speech posts against the women found that most were misogynistic (96%) and 4% homophobic.

Williams said: “Governments and social media companies need to go further, but ultimately, until the majority of users of these platforms become upstanders against hate instead of bystanders, we are unlikely to see the eradication of hateful abuse from our online spaces.”

In June, a report by Fifa, the game’s world governing body, and FifPro, the global players’ union, used artificial intelligence to track more than 400,000 posts on social media platforms during the semi-finals and final of Euro 2020 and this year’s Africa Cup of Nations.

The study revealed more than half of the players involved were subjected to some form of discrimination.

Much of the abuse came from their home nation, with 40% of it homophobic and 38% racist in nature – and most remained visible.

Fifa and FifPro announced a dedicated in-tournament moderation service across men’s and women’s football that will scan recognised hate-speech terms and prevent offending messages from being seen by the intended recipient and their followers.


Nadeem Badshah

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
UK's first football hate crime officer turns focus on social media
Stuart Ward of West Midlands police aims to stamp out racist abuse in grounds and online to bring back community spirit

Jessica Murray

15, Feb, 2021 @12:34 PM

Article image
Social media companies ‘make money from hate’, says Thierry Henry
Ex-Arsenal star says he will continue boycott of online platforms because they are ‘not really trying’ to tackle online abuse

Dan Milmo in Lisbon

02, Nov, 2021 @4:19 PM

Article image
Young LGBTQ+ people more than twice as likely to experience hate speech online
Digital Youth Index study finds minority groups also more likely to feel being online has had negative impact

Alex Hern

17, Oct, 2022 @5:00 AM

Article image
MPs criticise social media firms for failure to report criminal posts
Facebook, Google and Twitter condemned for not telling police about crimes on their platforms

Alex Hern

24, Apr, 2019 @2:40 PM

Article image
Government criticised over renewed delay to online safety bill
Internet safety groups say withdrawal of proposed legislation from next week’s Commons schedule leaves children at continued risk

Alex Hern UK technology editor

27, Oct, 2022 @5:25 PM

Article image
Online hate crime against disabled people rises by a third
Social media firms urged to protect users as offences increase in England and Wales

Amy Walker

10, May, 2019 @2:30 PM

Article image
Social media pressures 'driving up exam stress in girls'
Ahead of GCSE results, Girlguiding warns of expectation to post online and schools seeking acclaim

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

20, Aug, 2019 @11:01 PM

Article image
Social media firms to be penalised for not removing child abuse
UK police and charities praise plan to hold firms liable for not taking down harmful content

Sandra Laville and Alex Hern

08, Apr, 2019 @8:58 AM

Article image
Jermaine Jenas calls for laws to make social media firms tackle racism
Former England footballer says there is a disconnect between what police and social media firms deem abusive

Nadia Khomami

04, Oct, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
Social media firms must face heavy fines over extremist content – MPs
An inquiry by the Commons home affairs committee condemns technology companies for failing to tackle hate speech

Owen Bowcott Legal affairs correspondent

01, May, 2017 @5:01 AM