Spice Girl among stars to begin phone-hacking claims against Murdoch empire

Melanie Chisholm, Boyzone’s Shane Lynch and S Club 7’s Hannah Spearritt latest to allege voicemail interception

A group of 1990s pop stars are among the latest individuals to launch phone-hacking cases against Rupert Murdoch’s media empire, as the scandal that has dogged the company for more than 15 years continues to rumble on at the high court.

Melanie Chisholm from the Spice Girls, Shane Lynch from Boyzone, Hannah Spearritt from S Club 7, and Steps’s Ian Watkins and Lee Latchford-Evans have recently filed claims against the company.

The cases are a reminder that, even as Murdoch attempts to revive his reputation in the UK with the launch of his national television channel talkTV, his business is continuing to pay out millions of pounds a year to settle historical cases of illegal voicemail interception.

The company is also embroiled in a phone-hacking case brought by Prince Harry, who has alleged that his voicemails were targeted by the Sun and News of the World. Murdoch’s lawyers have accepted that Harry’s phone was hacked by reporters at the News of the World, but say he was made aware of this in 2006, meaning he has missed the six-year statute of limitations on bringing such cases. They deny allegations that his phone was targeted by reporters working for the Sun.

Murdoch’s decision to hire Piers Morgan as the lead presenter of talkTV will also refocus attention on the use of phone hacking when Morgan was editor of the Mirror. Phone hacking was widely practised by Mirror reporters during this era, and Morgan has previously discussed listening to voicemails left by Sir Paul McCartney. However, he has always strongly denied any personal involvement or knowledge of illegal information-gathering.

The new cases by the 1990s pop stars have been filed against Murdoch’s News Group Newspapers subsidiary, the legal owner of the Sun and the now defunct News of the World. Murdoch has burnt through hundreds of millions of pounds in legal fees over the last decade settling similar cases. This has ensured that claims are not tested in potentially embarrassing public trials.

News UK declined to comment on the latest cases.

Despite repeated claims in court hearings that phone hacking was widely used at the Sun, the company has repeatedly insisted that the practice did not take place at the daily tabloid. Even settlements that are made specifically in relation to allegations of wrongdoing at the Sun are usually accompanied by a statement from News UK insisting that such hacking was limited to the News of the World.

However, the Lib Dem MP Simon Hughes recently settled and received a substantial payout over a case explicitly related to articles published by the Sun during the editorship of Rebekah Brooks, who is now in charge of all Murdoch’s British media outlets. Asked about Brooks’ involvement in the story, Hughes said outside court that he would not name names, but “it is clear from all I have seen that it went to the top of the Sun”.

• This article was amended on 27 September 2021. An earlier version said Simon Hughes had “won” a case related to articles published by the Sun; in fact, the case was settled out of court.


Jim Waterson Media editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Paul Burrell and James Hewitt among latest phone-hacking cases
Dozens of celebrities join Prince Harry in new cases against Sun and Mirror publishers

Jim Waterson Media editor

21, Oct, 2019 @5:37 PM

Article image
Murdoch papers hid evidence of illegality, say phone-hacking victims
Lawyer representing victims at high court says involvement of senior executives in unlawful activities was covered up

Graham Ruddick Media editor

11, Oct, 2017 @8:39 PM

Article image
Phone hacking: lawyers seek access to Murdoch and Brooks email accounts
Alleged victims in court bid to prove there was an attempt to cover up hacking at the News of the World and the Sun

Jasper Jackson

09, Mar, 2017 @6:03 PM

Article image
News of the World phone hacking: Noel Fielding latest to win damages
Presenter of Great British Bake Off among celebrities compensated by News Group Newspapers, which shut paper in 2011

Sarah Marsh

04, Mar, 2021 @5:48 PM

Article image
Phone-hacking cases against Murdoch papers settled at last minute
Confidential settlement of cases against Sun and News of the World raises difficult issues for future hacking cases, judge says

Dan Sabbagh

18, Jan, 2018 @4:51 PM

Article image
After Meghan’s victory, Harry has phone hackers in his sights
Analysis: the prince may be prepared to risk a costly lawsuit against the Sun and Mirror, rather than settling

Haroon Siddique and Jim Waterson

03, Dec, 2021 @4:45 PM

Article image
Simon Hughes to sue over News of the World phone hacking
News International faces civil action by Lib Dem MP whose voicemail messages Glenn Mulcaire admitted intercepting in earlier criminal case. By James Robinson

James Robinson

11, Aug, 2011 @5:14 PM

Article image
Murdoch’s News Group admits benefiting from hacking of army officer's emails
Publisher to pay damages to Ian Hurst after admitting ‘vicarious liability’ as Labour calls for case to be taken into account in assessing Murdoch bid to buy Sky

Graham Ruddick Media editor

06, Oct, 2017 @5:33 PM

Article image
Phone hacking: show of unity can't hide cracks in News Corp
Tensions simmer as 'frustrated' Rupert Murdoch flies in to face phone-hacking affair, Andy Gray row and troubled Sky bid

Dan Sabbagh

28, Jan, 2011 @8:26 PM

Article image
Sun publisher pays Sir Simon Hughes phone-hacking damages
Former Lib Dem MP claimed he had been ‘victim of unlawful information gathering’ after tabloid outed him

Jim Waterson Media editor

10, Jun, 2021 @4:09 PM