Channel 4 privatisation ‘could shut up to 60 production companies’

As public consultation closes, analysts say a sale would undermine UK’s ‘levelling up’ agenda

As many as 60 British TV production companies could face going out of business if Channel 4 is privatised, according to a report published as the government closes its public consultation into the potential sale of the broadcaster.

Channel 4’s unique status, established in 1982 as an editorially independent broadcaster to provide a culturally challenging alternative to BBC One, BBC Two and ITV, makes it vitally important to hundreds of independent television producers across the country.

It is publicly owned but commercially funded, mostly through TV ad revenue, and is not required to turn a profit or focus on dividends for shareholders.

However, in June the culture secretary, Oliver Dowden, announced plans to privatise the broadcaster and will today insist it stands to benefit from a change of ownership. A 10-week public consultation on the proposals closes at 11.45pm on Tuesday.

Dowden has guaranteed that a new owner of Channel 4 would have to continue to make unprofitable public service programming and support the independent TV production industry, but said that a deep-pocketed investor would enable it to secure more broadcasting coups such as airing Emma Raducanu’s victory at the US Open.

“If we choose to proceed with a sale, I will make sure Channel 4 remains subject to proper public service obligations,” Dowden will say at a speech at the Cambridge Media Convention on Wednesday.

“If Channel 4 wants to grow at some point it will need cash. It won’t be able to compete with the streaming giants. It did a fantastic job at broadcasting the Paralympics. Channel 4 was able to bring the entire country together to cheer on Emma Raducanu. We’ve needed these national moments this last year, and we need more of them on free-to-view television.”

For the government to generate a significant return on the sale it would have to relax Channel 4’s remit, such as allowing it to make its own shows, according to a report by Ampere Analysis that says the broadcaster’s £660m annual budget for commissioning TV productions is likely to be a key cost-saving target for any new owner.

“If the government looks to relax Channel 4’s remit to derive more money from privatisation, then that would have a substantial negative impact on the UK production sector,” said Richard Broughton, an analyst at Ampere. “Channel 4 works with more small production companies than any other broadcaster, we estimate 200 over the last two years, and a privatised Channel 4 would likely leave many financially challenged.”

An analysis of those 200 production companies found that almost 140 relied on Channel 4 for half or more of their TV production work.

“Regional production companies are more likely to be reliant on Channel 4 projects,” said Broughton. “A sale of Channel 4 alongside a relaxation of its remit would therefore undermine the UK government’s ‘levelling up’ agenda.”

Channel 4’s own research estimates that up to 1,300 jobs would be lost from businesses that the broadcaster deals with, such as production companies, if it moved out of public ownership.

Pre-Covid, Channel 4’s total programming budget stood at £660m, with almost £500m of that on original shows such as It’s a Sin and Gogglebox.

However, the report argues that a new owner would aim to cut 40% to 50% of Channel 4’s programming budget to boost its roughly 8% margin closer to the level of commercial peers across Europe, which operate at about 15% or higher.

“A reduction in spend on original productions could jeopardise 50 to 60 small production companies,” said Broughton. “And potentially more if a buyer is particularly risk averse and looks to commission more from larger producers.”

Broughton said Channel 4’s cost-cutting actions during the pandemic provide evidence to any potential buyer that slashing the content budget can provide immediate financial returns.

Last year, Channel 4 made £150m in cuts, almost all of it from the programming budget, as the pandemic stopped productions and TV advertising revenue declined steeply. The broadcaster went on to report a pretax “surplus” of £74m, the largest in its 38-year history, as the TV ad market bounced back.

Channel 4 paid Amazon, the exclusive UK rights holder to the US Open on its subscription streaming service, a seven-figure sum for the rights to air the US Open final free-to-air. The deal, which Channel 4 made no return on as it airs Amazon’s feed ad-free, drew a peak audience of 9.2 million viewers and 40% of the total UK viewers watching TV at the time.

Critics of Dowden’s comments say that a new owner could still meet its PSB obligations while still dramatically cutting the total programming budget, commitment to spend outside London and reduce Channel 4’s newly-established presence around the country.

Last month, former Channel 4 chairman Lord Burns and former chief executive David Abraham said key public service content at the broadcaster, such as the Paralympics and news and current affairs, would probably be slashed by a new owner as they do not make a profit.

Sign up to the daily Business Today email or follow Guardian Business on Twitter at @BusinessDesk

“Under private ownership, Channel 4’s fiduciary duty would be to maximise returns to shareholders,” the broadcaster said in its full response to the government’s consultation which it published on Monday. “This dynamic can be seen in other commercially funded, but privately owned public service broadcasters like ITV. A private owner would have a natural and legitimate incentive to seek both to dilute the more commercially onerous parts of the channel’s remit.”

Ampere estimates that without any change to Channel 4’s current obligations the government can expect to raise only £400m to £500m from privatisation. The last government attempt to sell Channel 4 in 2016 saw a £1bn price tag attached to the business.

Potential suitors this time around reportedly include the US pay-TV giant Discovery – which was considered a favourite last time before the government scrapped its privatisation plans – and ITV.


Mark Sweney Media business correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Channel 4 privatisation could put us out of business, say TV production firms
Forty-four small TV and film production companies take out full-page ad in Daily Telegraph

Mark Sweney Media business correspondent

05, Oct, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
Channel 4 privatisation – how would it work and who would buy it?
Selling off the publicly owned UK broadcaster could depend on changing its business model

Mark Sweney

22, Jun, 2021 @1:03 PM

Article image
Channel 4 privatisation proposal: ‘This could prove irreversible’
Broadcaster’s place in ‘fair system’ public-broadcasting overhaul is queried by its CEO

Mark Sweney

23, Jun, 2021 @12:12 AM

Article image
Channel 4 chair criticises government’s ‘harmful’ privatisation plan
Charles Gurassa writes to Oliver Dowden to air concern over lack of transparency behind decision

Lucy Campbell

20, Jul, 2021 @7:56 PM

Article image
Waitrose boss Mark Price quits to 'head Channel 4'
John Lewis said Price will leave in April after 33 years at the employee-owned retailer

Sean Farrell and Mark Sweney

20, Oct, 2015 @10:14 AM

Article image
Channel 4 left in limbo as Tories set for privatisation U-turn
Chairman Charles Gurassa complains about uncertainty as Channel 4 reveals record revenues and pays £595,000 in bonuses to top executives

Mark Sweney and Jane Martinson

10, May, 2016 @6:29 PM

Article image
Channel 4 pays millions in bonuses amid coronavirus TV ad slump
Broadcaster pays out £5m among staff just as it seeks to tap credit facility to weather fall in revenue

Mark Sweney

05, Apr, 2020 @12:51 PM

Article image
Ministers’ rationale for privatising Channel 4 looks extremely flimsy
The government’s stale plans for the broadcaster should be rejected in favour of cherishing it as a risk-taker

Nils Pratley

22, Jun, 2021 @6:22 PM

Article image
The great British broadcasting shake-up – all you need to know
Government TV changes include possible sale of Channel 4 and new rules governing streaming

Mark Sweney Media business correspondent

22, Jun, 2021 @11:01 PM

Article image
BBC in talks with Channel 4 to launch £500m bid for UKTV
Broadcaster, 50% controlled by BBC Worldwide, is major source of profit for the BBC

Mark Sweney

02, Jul, 2018 @5:00 AM