BBC boss offers to meet black executive after claims he was blocked from job

Marcus Ryder said to have lost out on senior role after making public interventions on race

The BBC director general, Tim Davie, has offered to meet a prominent black media executive who, it is claimed, was blocked from a senior job at the broadcaster after making public interventions on race.

Marcus Ryder said he was approached earlier this year by the BBC to apply for a new role, based in Birmingham, overseeing Radio 1’s Newsbeat bulletins and the news service of the Asian Network.

However, despite making the final round of interviews for the job, Ryder found the BBC ultimately scrapped the entire recruitment process. Instead, the corporation gave the job of overseeing Newsbeat’s move out of London to an internal candidate on a 12-month contract.

“I had no intention of applying,” said Ryder, who is a visiting professor at the Sir Lenny Henry Centre for Media Diversity. “I don’t have that much interest in working for the BBC but they approached me and it’s appealing because I’m very interested in regional diversity and the role of Birmingham.

“I had two rounds of interviews and there was a third round where they asked my views on impartiality and social media. They seemed to be impressed – and I impressed on them the importance of impartiality. Then I didn’t hear anything and weeks went by.”

People with knowledge of the BBC’s recruitment process have told the Guardian that executives were concerned that the government would perceive Ryder’s potential appointment as controversial, especially in the middle of licence fee negotiations. The Daily Mail has previously reported similar claims, but the corporation denies any candidate was “vetoed”.

Ryder, who previously worked for eight years as head of current affairs programming at BBC Scotland, has written at length about increasing diversity in the media. He said he believed strongly in impartiality in a professional setting and had even written internal BBC training manuals on the topic. “In terms of party politics I’ve never said anything that aligns me to a political party.”

He said he had only twice publicly disagreed with the BBC’s editorial lines since leaving the corporation: when Naga Munchetty was reprimanded for reflecting on her views on Donald Trump, and when the corporation broadcast the N-word uncensored on a news report. Both decisions were ultimately overturned by the then director general, Tony Hall.

There is concern among BBC staff about politicisation of hiring processes for key roles, and whether candidates who have taken public stances on topics such as the Black Lives Matter movement or trans rights are be considered impartial in the eyes of the BBC’s managers. The corporation is in the process of hiring a new head of news to oversee all of its output, with a growing perception among staff that Davie would prefer an external candidate.

Other candidates approached for the Newsbeat and Asian Network job included Aaqil Ahmed, who spent two decades at the BBC and rose to become the first Muslim to be head of religion and ethics at the broadcaster. He also failed to make the cut, with the role instead going to the Birmingham-based Danielle Dwyer.

A BBC spokesperson said Davie had not vetoed any particular candidate over their views. “We’d never comment on who did or didn’t apply for a job. After an external search, BBC News decided that as this role was bringing together departments from across the country, we were looking for an internal candidate with an existing understanding of the BBC, so did not take forward any external candidates for this particular post.

“After a separate recruitment process, we appointed an internal candidate on a year’s secondment. This was a BBC News decision. It is wrong to suggest any veto was exercised on any candidate.”


Jim Waterson Media editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
BBC says words to Rule, Britannia! will now be sung at Proms
Decision comes three days into tenure of new director general Tim Davie, who said original choice was due to Covid-19

Mark Brown Arts correspondent

02, Sep, 2020 @3:23 PM

Article image
BBC must serve all audiences, says new boss Tim Davie
Director-general faces claims that broadcaster is too London-centric and anti-Brexit

Jim Waterson Media editor

01, Sep, 2020 @10:00 AM

Article image
BBC boss hits back at China over ban on World News service
Director general Tim Davie warns of ‘growing global threat to free media’

Molly Blackall

13, Feb, 2021 @1:49 PM

Article image
BBC boss says it may have to pay out to whistleblower over Bashir interview
Tim Davie offers ‘full, unconditional apology’ to Matt Wiessler, designer who raised concerns with BBC bosses

Jim Waterson Media editor

25, May, 2021 @8:46 AM

Article image
BBC boss Tim Davie to crack down on staff airing views on social media
New director general says he wants to focus on impartiality after accusations of bias

Mark Sweney

03, Sep, 2020 @5:42 PM

Article image
Martin Bashir to face questions over Diana interview when he recovers from Covid
BBC says it will review Charles Spencer’s claims of journalistic malpractice at later date

Nazia Parveen and Jim Waterson

03, Nov, 2020 @5:27 PM

Article image
Sue Barker to leave BBC's Question of Sport after 24 years
Team captains Matt Dawson and Phil Tufnell also axed in quiz show shake-up

Jamie Grierson

13, Sep, 2020 @2:19 PM

Article image
Acting BBC boss to set out plans to rebuild trust after Newsnight fiasco
Tim Davie in talks with BBC Trust as row erupts over £450,000 payoff to George Entwistle

Dan Sabbagh and agencies

12, Nov, 2012 @7:56 AM

Article image
Bake Off poacher tipped as frontrunner for BBC top job
Jay Hunt seen as in contention while ITV and Channel 4 bosses thought unlikely to join race

Mark Sweney and Tara Conlan

21, Jan, 2020 @6:45 PM

Article image
Why is Princess Diana's Panorama interview back in the news?
Charles Spencer’s call for an inquiry into fake documents has reawakened interest in the 1995 BBC programme

Caroline Davies

03, Nov, 2020 @4:27 PM