BBC braces for criticism over 2016 decision to rehire Martin Bashir

Analysis: report likely to focus on ex-BBC bosses, including Tony Hall who oversaw 1996 investigation into Diana interview

When Martin Bashir rejoined the BBC as religious affairs correspondent in 2016, the corporation’s head of newsgathering Jonathan Munro said he was attracted to the reporter’s “track record in enterprising journalism” and respect within the industry.

Some of those involved in that decision may be regretting their enthusiasm for Bashir, as current BBC bosses brace for public criticism over their decision to bring back a man whose journalistic reputation was destroyed by a subsequent report on his use of fake documents to secure a 1995 interview with Diana, Princess of Wales.

Next week, the corporation will reveal the findings of a rapid internal investigation into the decision to rehire Bashir by Ken MacQuarrie, a longstanding BBC executive described internally as the corporation’s Harvey Keitel due to his history of cleaning up messes created by other managers.

The former director general of the BBC, Tony Hall.
Tony Hall, the former director general of the BBC. Photograph: Ben Stansall/AFP/Getty

MacQuarrie has spent recent days interviewing senior executives and gathering information, with the expectation he will produce a brief summary of the circumstances surrounding Bashir’s return and whether anyone should take the blame for failing to adequately vet his history.

The corporation has strongly denied a suggestion from the Conservative MP Julian Knight that Bashir was handed the religious correspondent job in 2016 without an interview process. However, sources within the BBC told the Guardian the process was streamlined with the intention of ensuring Bashir got the job. They claimed this involved previously unsuccessful applicants being re-interviewed a second time in order to legitimise the hiring of Bashir.

A spokesperson for the BBC declined to comment on the specifics of this allegation and said they would publish the findings next week. The report is likely to focus on the top executives involved in the hiring process, including Munro, the former head of news James Harding, and the then-director general Tony Hall. Hall undertook the original bodged investigation into Bashir in 1996.

The former head of news, James Harding
The former head of BBC news, James Harding, has said previously he took responsibility for the decision to hire Bashir. Photograph: Carl Court/AFP/Getty Images

Harding has previously said he took responsibility for the decision to hire Bashir but did not directly answer questions on whether he had consulted with Hall before making the appointment.

In some ways the BBC should thank Dominic Cummings for ensuring the Bashir scandal has not been more damaging. It was Cummings’ bellicose briefings to the media about the government’s desire to cut the BBC down after the Conservatives’ 2019 election victory that helped push Tony Hall out of the corporation two years earlier than expected.

If Hall had still been in position as director general – rather than heading off to run the National Gallery – the corporation could have been facing the second successive resignation of a director general over an internal scandal. Instead, the new director general, Tim Davie, was free to criticise his predecessor’s reign and state clearly there is “no doubt” that rehiring Bashir was a “big mistake”.

The BBC’s director-general, Tim Davie, said rehiring Bashir was a ‘big mistake’.
The BBC’s director-general, Tim Davie, said rehiring Bashir was a ‘big mistake’. Photograph: Andrew Milligan/PA

Bashir was already considered an unusual appointment for what was perceived to be a relatively junior newsroom role, given his career-landing interviews with the likes of Michael Jackson and a subsequent stint in the US as a talkshow host. However, his career had taken a dip after a series of scandals that culminated in his departure from MSNBC in 2013.

Even after arriving, he gained a reputation for seeking celebrity through other channels – blindsiding BBC management when he announced he was appearing on ITV’s Celebrity X Factor. In the process he became the first BBC religion editor to forget the words to Lionel Richie’s Easy on a live singing competition.


Jim Waterson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Martin Bashir to face questions over Diana interview when he recovers from Covid
BBC says it will review Charles Spencer’s claims of journalistic malpractice at later date

Nazia Parveen and Jim Waterson

03, Nov, 2020 @5:27 PM

Article image
‘A cover-up’: what the Dyson report said about the BBC and Martin Bashir
Bashir’s lies to obtain Diana interview were discovered by the BBC but effectively covered up, finds report

Matthew Weaver and Ben Quinn

20, May, 2021 @8:04 PM

Article image
BBC report clears staff over rehiring of Martin Bashir
Inquiry says there were ‘shortcomings’ in process, but no one involved knew of methods Bashir used to secure Diana interview

Mark Sweney

14, Jun, 2021 @1:25 PM

Article image
Prasanna Puwanarajah to play Martin Bashir in The Crown
Exclusive: Netflix series will dramatise details of journalist’s interview with Diana, Princess of Wales

Tara Conlan

26, Nov, 2021 @11:24 AM

Article image
Martin Bashir won over BBC with his grasp of theology
Questions about the journalists’s record were not addressed by those who gave him his most recent job, says Panorama reporter

Vanessa Thorpe

30, May, 2021 @8:30 AM

Article image
BBC to hold investigation into how Martin Bashir obtained Diana interview
Diana’s brother Earl Spencer claims journalist produced fake documents to win trust of family

Jim Waterson Media editor

09, Nov, 2020 @2:29 PM

Article image
MPs give ex-BBC bosses a right royal bashing over Bashir’s Diana interview
There wasn’t much left of former directors general Tony Hall and John Birt after four-hour grilling

John Crace

15, Jun, 2021 @5:50 PM

Article image
BBC finds Princess Diana's lost note that it says clears Martin Bashir
Broadcaster claimed document proved royal was not coerced into doing 1995 interview

Jim Waterson

13, Nov, 2020 @5:50 PM

Article image
Former BBC chiefs told to expect criticism in Diana interview inquiry
Findings of investigation into tactics used by journalist Martin Bashir in 1995 are due to be published

Mark Sweney

20, May, 2021 @7:33 AM

Article image
Martin Bashir quits BBC before release of Diana interview inquiry’s report
Journalist steps down as religion editor on health grounds before publication of investigation

Jim Waterson Media editor

14, May, 2021 @6:21 PM