Associated Press journalists condemn decision to fire Emily Wilder

  • Company to review social media policies after Wilder’s firing
  • Republicans targeted her over Palestinian advocacy as a student

Journalists at the Associated Press published an open letter on Monday, decrying the decision to fire Emily Wilder, a young employee targeted by a Republican smear campaign regarding her pro-Palestinian advocacy while a student.

“It has left our colleagues – particularly emerging journalists – wondering how we treat our own, what culture we embrace and what values we truly espouse as a company,” the journalists wrote.

Just hours later, the AP said it plans to launch a review of its social media policies.

In a memo to staff members on Monday, the AP’s news leaders asked for volunteers to suggest changes to social media guidelines, with the idea of a committee bringing forth recommendations by September.

“One of the issues brought forward in recent days is the belief that restrictions on social media prevent you from being your true self, and that this disproportionately harms journalists of color, LGBTQ journalists and others who often feel attacked online,” the memo said. “We need to dive into this issue.”

Wilder, a 2020 Stanford graduate, was an intern at the Arizona Republic before the AP hired her for an entry-level role in Phoenix.

She announced her new position in April, tweeting photographs which showed her wearing an AP logo. She started as a news associate in early May but was fired weeks later – according to the company, for violating its social media policy. She and other AP staffers remain confused as to how.

Wilder was fired soon after Republicans at Stanford resurfaced her history of pro-Palestinian advocacy while a college student. Conservative outlets publicized the story and prominent figures including the Arkansas senator Tom Cotton shared it.

“I was told my editors were only hoping to support me as I received an onslaught of sexist, antisemitic, racist and violent comments and messages,” Wilder wrote in a statement.

“Less than 48 hours later, the AP fired me. What future does it promise to aspiring reporters that an institution like the Associated Press would sacrifice those with the least power to the cruel trolling of a group of anonymous bullies?”

Last week, an AP spokesperson said: “We can confirm Emily Wilder’s comments that she was dismissed for violations of AP’s social media policy during her time at AP.”

The dismissal came days after a building which housed an AP office in Gaza was destroyed by Israeli action.

The AP social media policy, the spokesperson said, was meant to ensure that “one person cannot create dangerous conditions for our journalists covering the story. Every AP journalist is responsible for safeguarding our ability to report on this conflict, or any other, with fairness and credibility, and cannot take sides in public forums.”

On Monday, the AP news leaders said sharing more information was difficult: the company does not publicly discuss personnel issues to protect the privacy of staff.

“We can assure you that much of the coverage and commentary does not accurately portray a difficult decision we did not make lightly,” the memo said. It did not make clear what information was reported inaccurately.

The AP’s memo was signed by 10 news leaders, not including its executive editor, Sally Buzbee, who begins next month as executive editor at the Washington Post. The AP said Buzbee was not involved in the Wilder case since she handed over day-to-day responsibilities to others when accepting the Post job.

Wilder’s dismissal has nonetheless sparked outcry among journalists, many of whom wonder why the AP chose to harm a young professional instead of appreciating a teachable moment.

“The fact that AP refused to defend her when the going got tough highlights exactly what folks have been saying all day: only the powerful survive. The rules only apply to the vulnerable,” tweeted Megan Taros, who reports for the Arizona Republic.

In the open letter, AP employees excoriated the company’s willingness to fire Wilder.

“We are often the target of people unhappy with scrutiny,” staff members wrote. “What happens when they orchestrate a smear campaign targeting another one of us?

“Once we decide to play this game on the terms of those acting in bad faith, we can’t win.”

Wilder’s termination also reinvigorated conversations about journalistic impartiality.

“There is a reckoning coming in American journalism,” tweeted Julián Castro, a former secretary of housing and urban development and candidate for the Democratic presidential nomination.

“Good. It’s well past time to rethink a notion of ‘objectivity’ and ‘neutrality’ that always privileged the status quo and all who benefit from it.”

The Associated Press contributed reporting

Contributor

Alexandra Villarreal

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Associated Press vows to defend staff against online attacks after Emily Wilder firing
The news agency has admitted to mishandling the situation and said they fired the reporter for breaching social media policies

Edward Helmore

26, May, 2021 @8:04 PM

Article image
Outcry after Associated Press journalist fired amid row over pro-Palestinian views
News agency decision to fire Emily Wilder criticised after rightwing media highlight her previous activism in college

Maanvi Singh

21, May, 2021 @12:34 PM

Associated Press names new national editor

Brian Toolan, editor and senior vice president of the Hartford Courant, has been appointed to the new post of national editor at Associated Press. Toolan will be responsible for developing coverage of spot news and enterprise for national and international audiences. As editor of the Courant, Toolan oversaw the paper's winning of a 1999 Pulitzer prize for the reporting of breaking news. (Via Boston.com / News)

Roy Greenslade

05, Jul, 2006 @8:11 PM

Article image
Associated Press offers simultaneous live video feeds to news websites
News agency says its video service took off before birth of Prince George

Roy Greenslade

10, Feb, 2015 @12:42 PM

Article image
Two Associated Press journalists shot in Afghanistan

Photographer Anja Niedringhaus is killed and another wounded after attack in Khost province on eve of presidential election

Emma Graham-Harrison in Kabul

04, Apr, 2014 @1:14 PM

Article image
Revealed: how Associated Press cooperated with the Nazis
German historian shows how news agency retained access in 1930s by promising not to undermine strength of Hitler regime

Philip Oltermann in Berlin

30, Mar, 2016 @11:18 AM

Article image
Associated Press opens news bureau in North Korea
Associated Press president says new office will operate under the same standards and practices as AP bureaux worldwide

Tania Branigan in Beijing

16, Jan, 2012 @12:27 PM

Associated Press threatens legal action against websites
Largest US news agency pledges to 'protect the content' of its 6,700 members. By Bobbie Johnson in San Francisco

Bobbie Johnson in San Francisco

07, Apr, 2009 @7:13 AM

Article image
Associated Press sues 'parasitic' news agency over licensing claim
AP continues fight against digital agencies using its content, claiming Meltwater News does not pay licence fees. By Josh Halliday

Josh Halliday

14, Feb, 2012 @5:46 PM

Article image
Interview: Tom Curley, Associated Press chief, on driving news faster
Stepping down after nine years, the AP boss talks battles with Google, getting paid for content, and the effects of phone hacking. By John Plunkett

John Plunkett

12, Feb, 2012 @7:00 PM