Bid to stop Paul Dacre taking over at TV regulator

Industry and government figures stage 11th-hour effort to prevent former Mail editor being appointed chair of Ofcom

A last-ditch campaign to stop former Daily Mail editor Paul Dacre becoming chair of Britain’s national broadcasting regulator is being waged in Whitehall, the Observer understands.

After a final shortlist of candidates was interviewed last week, industry and government figures have been touting former culture minister and Tory peer Ed Vaizey as better placed to oversee Ofcom, amid concern about Dacre’s criticisms of the BBC. A final decision is expected this month.

Unease at Dacre’s candidacy has emerged inside and outside government. As chair of Ofcom, Dacre, who once called the BBC “too bloody big, too bloody pervasive and too bloody powerful”, will have a major role in regulating the corporation. It is understood that figures in the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) and Downing Street have concerns and regard Vaizey, who would still represent a political appointment, as a compromise.

Broadcasting figures have been privately warning that Dacre does not have the technical and economic expertise for the Ofcom job. Greg Dyke, the former BBC director general, said Dacre would be “totally unsuitable”.

Ed Vaizey.
Ed Vaizey. Photograph: Jeff Spicer/Getty Images

“He was a brilliant editor of the Daily Mail but showed no evidence that he began to understand what impartiality meant,” Dyke said. “His long-term antagonism towards the BBC would make him absolutely the wrong person to chair their regulator. On top of that, what does he know about the telecoms industry? In fact when I first learned that Mr Dacre was a candidate to be the next chair of Ofcom, I thought someone was joking with me. Let’s hope that turns out to be the case.”

While concerns persist that he would engage in a “culture war” with the BBC, Dacre is said to be most interested in taking on the big digital companies such as Facebook and Google, using new and forthcoming powers to regulate video-sharing platforms and tackle so-called “online harms”.

Vaizey, meanwhile, has made it clear he has “trouble with the sort of culture war that the government wants to undertake”. Neither Dacre nor Vaizey wished to comment.

There have already been concerns about the make-up of the panel asked to put forward suitable candidates to ministers. It includes Ian Livingston, the Tory peer and former chief executive of BT, and Paul Potts, a director of Times Newspapers. There have been suggestions Potts was appointed after an earlier member resigned. DCMS did not comment, but it is understood Potts has been on the panel since the official launch of the process.

A string of recent appointments has led to accusations that the government is trying to politicise control of broadcast media. It was announced last week that Robbie Gibb, the former Downing Street communications director, is to join the BBC’s board. Gibb, previously head of BBC Westminster, played a key role in the early stages of the formation of the GB News channel, which is due to launch soon. The chair of GB News, Andrew Neil, has said: “The direction of news debate in Britain is increasingly woke and out of touch with the majority of its people.” Meanwhile, the government has already appointed Richard Sharp, an adviser to chancellor Rishi Sunak and a Tory party donor, as chair of the BBC.

There are concerns about a wider attempt to politicise appointments to cultural and media positions. The government has already vetoed the reappointment of two women to Channel 4’s board of directors, while Charles Dunstone, the billionaire founder of Carphone Warehouse, has quit as chair of the Royal Museums Greenwich after ministers opposed the reappointment of a trustee who backed “decolonising” the curriculum.

As well as concerns over Dacre’s impartiality, other senior figures have suggested the Ofcom job involves a myriad of technical, economic and legal discussions that may simply frustrate him.

While saying he could not advise on who his successor should be, Lord Burns, who left as Ofcom’s chair late last year, told a conference last week: “I was not troubled by having to get involved from time to time in some quite detailed issues where the executive team do not see eye to eye with the companies Ofcom regulates. Finally, I was not dismayed at having to spend significant time with lawyers – I saw more of my legal colleagues than in any other job. The communications industry can be quite litigious.”


Michael Savage

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Johnson poised to appoint Paul Dacre chair of Ofcom
PM’s choice of controversial former Mail editor is part of his election promise to radically overhaul the BBC

Vanessa Thorpe Arts and media correspondent

31, Jan, 2021 @10:45 AM

Article image
Paul Dacre will get second chance to apply for Ofcom chair, ministers confirm
Interviews for TV regulator to be rerun despite panel saying former Daily Mail editor was ‘not appointable’

Jim Waterson Media editor

27, Oct, 2021 @1:24 PM

Article image
Hardline BBC critics reportedly offered top media roles
Former Daily Mail editor could head Ofcom, while ex-Daily Telegraph editor considers BBC chairman job

Vanessa Thorpe

26, Sep, 2020 @7:58 PM

Article image
Paul Dacre pulls out of running to be next Ofcom chair
Former Daily Mail editor announces decision not to proceed with second bid and takes swipe at civil service

Aubrey Allegretti and Jim Waterson

20, Nov, 2021 @12:00 AM

Article image
Ministers struggle to find people to interview Paul Dacre for Ofcom job
Exclusive: Second attempt to make former Daily Mail editor chair of media regulator hits stumbling block

Jim Waterson Media editor

31, Aug, 2021 @11:51 AM

Article image
Are Paul Dacre and Charles Moore set to rule over British media?
Socially conservative critics of UK media could redefine BBC and Ofcom but is there enough momentum to make the appointments a reality?

Jim Waterson

27, Sep, 2020 @6:58 PM

Article image
Johnson really cares about creating new jobs – especially if your name is Paul Dacre | Marina Hyde
For months the Tories have been trying and failing to shoehorn the former Mail editor into Ofcom. You could almost feel sorry for him, says Guardian columnist Marina Hyde

Marina Hyde

16, Nov, 2021 @3:04 PM

Article image
Dacre and the Mail count the heavy cost of victory in Europe
Brexit was the choice of DMGT’s indomitable editor-in-chief. But at what price to his prospects, his proprietor, or his company?

Peter Preston

09, Jul, 2016 @9:26 AM

Article image
Murdoch journalist given key voice over new chair of Ofcom
Paul Potts, a director of Times newspapers, appointed to panel to choose new head of broadcasting regulator

Vanessa Thorpe

14, Feb, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Paul Dacre and pay: how best to spend the Mail millions? | Peter Preston
Does the editor’s £2.5m pay signal the importance of editorial to the board? Or could a million or two of that be spent on investigations?

Peter Preston

17, Dec, 2017 @7:00 AM