BBC journalist settles case after claiming she was bullied into Syria trip

Former news producer Natalie Morton claimed she was bullied into ‘unnecessary’ trip to Homs

A war journalist who sued the BBC after claiming she was bullied into a dangerous assignment during which she was almost killed in an explosion has settled her case for £40,000.

Natalie Morton, 44, a former news producer, said the ordeal left her with severe post-traumatic stress disorder and anxiety, which ended her broadcasting career, drove her to drink and left her so traumatised she could not watch the news.

Morton, who had covered conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan, alleged that she was bullied by the BBC’s chief war correspondent, Lyse Doucet, into the “unnecessary” trip into war-stricken Homs, Syria, in April 2014.

There, a shell landed close to her car, inflicting 35 shrapnel injuries on a cameraman and, though Morton escaped with minor injuries, she said the incident destroyed her mental health.

While the BBC and Doucet have denied the accusations, the corporation agreed to settle the case, paying out £40,000. The settlement was revealed in a court order in which the BBC continues to deny liability for Morton’s injuries.

Her barrister, Simon Anderson, said she had been “intimidated and pressured” by Doucet, who was part of the BBC’s Emmy-award winning Syria reporting team, into risking her life by going along on the trip into Homs. He claimed Doucet had been “angry” at her previous refusal to go on another dangerous assignment in the town of Maaloula.

Morton also alleged senior BBC managers failed in their duty to keep staff as safe as possible and to care for journalists who had experienced trauma in conflict zones.

The BBC’s barrister, David Platt QC, maintained that Morton was not put under any pressure to travel with Doucet to Homs, that it was her decision to go and that all precautions were taken to prevent injury to its staff.

According to papers filed at Central London county court, Morton travelled into Syria with Doucet, camera operator Phil Goodwin, and documentary-maker Robin Barnwell. Her job was to provide news coverage of the conflict as Doucet’s producer, while Doucet and Barnwell also filmed the Bafta-nominated current affairs documentary Children of Syria.

While filming was taking place for the documentary at a centre for internally displaced people in Homs, a stray mortar landed near the vehicle where Morton was waiting outside. Goodwin sustained 35 wounds and Morton’s mental health was seriously impacted.

“She has not watched or listened to the news since May 2015,” said her barrister in court filings ahead of the trial of her damages claim.

Morton claimed there was no need for her to have been on the trip to Homs as she was not involved in the documentary and that she was “persuaded/required” to go, having previously refused another hazardous assignment with Doucet.

Platt said Morton did not need to if “she viewed it journalistically unnecessary”. He said a risk assessment of the trip had been properly completed and Morton had been “expressly advised” by her driver not to stay in the vehicle. As an experienced war journalist, he said, she knew what she was signing up for.

Morton’s claim was due to go before a judge last week but was settled after the BBC agreed the payout and to cover her legal bills, likely to run into the tens of thousands.


Lucy Campbell

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Syria: French journalist Edith Bouvier pleads for evacuation from Homs

France calls for humanitarian corridor to Homs after video plea from journalist injured in shelling that killed Marie Colvin

Peter Beaumont

23, Feb, 2012 @5:32 PM

Article image
Marie Colvin stressed that the victims were the story, not the reporter | Michael White
Michael White: The veteran war reporter belonged to the heroic end of the newspaper trade but I'm uneasy with the coverage of her death

Michael White

23, Feb, 2012 @12:11 PM

Article image
US journalist held hostage in Syria taken to Tel Aviv after release

Peter Theo Curtis undergoing medical checks after being held by Jabhat al-Nusra, an affiliate of al-Qaida, since autumn 2012

Harriet Sherwood in Jerusalem

25, Aug, 2014 @12:06 PM

Article image
Turkey helps free Guardian journalist in Libya

Ghaith Abdul-Ahad released from Libyan prison after Turkish government and foreign ministry joined negotiations

Staff reporter

17, Mar, 2011 @3:05 PM

Article image
Sky journalist and crew deliberately shot at by Syrian government
Footage shows Alex Crawford and her team under intense bombardment in Idlib

Luke Harding

23, May, 2019 @5:43 PM

Article image
Syria and the risks of covering conflicts

'We're enemies of the state, these deaths show that'

Ghaith Abdul-Ahad and Martin Chulov

24, Feb, 2012 @10:21 PM

Article image
Guardian journalist Ghaith Abdul-Ahad in custody, Libya officials confirm

Correspondent went missing with Brazilian journalist Andrei Netto while reporting from country

Ian Black, Middle East editor and Peter Beaumont in Tripoli

10, Mar, 2011 @6:53 PM

Article image
Anthony Shadid, peerless chronicler of human stories
Martin Chulov pays tribute to a colleague whose reporting from troubled regions won admiration for its insight and humanity

Martin Chulov

17, Feb, 2012 @8:51 PM

Article image
Nicolas Sarkozy retracts claim about Edith Bouvier rescue
French president withdraws statement that suggested injured journalist had been evacuated from city of Homs in Syria

Martin Chulov in Beirut and Peter Beaumont

28, Feb, 2012 @4:46 PM

Article image
Homs: the story behind Mani's extraordinary images from the frontline
French photographer has taken extraordinary steps to avoid being caught by Assad's security forces

Ian Black, Middle East editor

25, Nov, 2011 @12:44 AM