Emily Maitlis: BBC 'looks out of touch' over Munchetty decision

Newsnight presenter says corporation set ‘semantic conundrum’ in Trump racism ruling

The Newsnight presenter Emily Maitlis says the BBC is in danger of looking “massively out of touch with the real world” as a result of its critical verdict on Naga Munchetty’s comments about Donald Trump.

Speaking on Saturday in support of Munchetty, who presents BBC Breakfast, Maitlis said the corporation’s executive complaints unit (ECU) was wrong to censure any member of staff who publicly called out racism.

In July, Munchetty suggested on air that Trump’s tweets attacking four US Congresswomen of colour and urging them to “go home” were likely to be “embedded in racism”, according to her own experience. When pressed by her co-presenter she added that the US president’s remarks made her “furious”.

Last week, Munchetty was judged to have broken the public broadcaster’s editorial guidelines on impartiality.

Maitlis told an audience at Cliveden literary festival in Taplow, Berkshire, that the BBC had set “a semantic and linguistic conundrum” for itself by ruling that, while Munchetty was within her rights to describe Trump’s tweets as typical examples of racism, she had been wrong to imply the person who wrote them was racist.

“She [Munchetty] was very careful in her language. She said she herself had been told to go home. From what I understand, the BBC ruling said it was fine to call out racism, but not to call Trump a racist,” said Maitlis.

“Now, I’ve tried to practise that in the comfort of my own home. I think it’s complicated. The point is that the BBC, the complaints body, is trying to work its way through a semantic and linguistic conundrum, that they end up looking as if they have their heads down in this Dickensian ledger of for and against, or good and bad.”

A BBC spokesperson said: “The statement from the executive team is clear, the BBC is not impartial on racism. Racism is not an opinion and it is not a matter for debate. Racism is racism.”

Maitlis’s criticism comes after high-profile writers and journalists wrote to the Guardian urging the BBC to reconsider. The ECU’s findings have also now been referred to Ofcom, the national media regulator.

This weekend the novelist Philip Pullman and the former children’s television presenter Floella Benjamin joined the angry response to the BBC’s decision on Munchetty.

Pullman, 72, tweeted: “The BBC is being timorous in the Naga Munchetty case. She’s right and they are wrong.”

Benjamin, 70, who was one of the first black women to appear regularly on British television in the 1970s and 1980s, said she was dismayed by the ECU’s decision.

Tony Hall, the BBC’s director general, attempted to clarify the situation on Friday in an email to staff. He said the corporation “was not impartial on racism” and that he and his fellow executives admired Munchetty for speaking out.

Maitlis said this highlighted the confusion. “My worry is that the complaints body looks as if it’s massively out of touch with the real world,” she said.

“You have a woman of colour in a prominent position in a main news outlet, who is a presence, but not allowed to be a voice. That’s a difficult place for a complaints body to be. It shouldn’t be my colleagues and people of colour who are having to come out and say this, it should be anyone and all of us.”

Earlier this month the ECU upheld a complaint about Maitlis “sneering and bullying” during a Newsnight discussion with the newspaper columnist Rod Liddle.


Vanessa Thorpe Arts and media correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Emily Maitlis: 'Her winning quality is she doesn't take herself too seriously'
Newsnight’s new lead presenter is described as super-smart with a determination to be distinctive

Jim Waterson Media editor

22, Mar, 2019 @1:30 PM

Article image
Emily Maitlis and Nick Robinson audition in Question Time pilots
Kirsty Wark and Samira Ahmed also tried out as hosts during secret show with panel of MPs

Dan Sabbagh

08, Oct, 2018 @9:03 AM

Article image
Emily Maitlis brushes with Donald Trump | Media Monkey
Media Monkey: BBC2 presenter asks property tycoon about his trademark combover hairstyle


25, Nov, 2010 @11:17 AM

Article image
Sky's Alex Crawford: 'sexist' to ask if motherhood compatible with frontline

Correspondent who reported live as rebel convoy entered Tripoli reveals how she copes with the risks and dangers of her job. By Dan Sabbagh

Dan Sabbagh

27, Aug, 2011 @1:43 PM

Emily Maitlis joins Newsnight

4.30pm: BBC London presenter Emily Maitlis is to join Jeremy Paxman and Kirsty Wark as one of the main presenters of Newsnight. By John Plunkett.

John Plunkett

22, Feb, 2006 @4:40 PM

Article image
BBC newsreader Richard Baker dies aged 93
Presenter long associated with Radio 3’s classical music shows was known for his smooth delivery

Vanessa Thorpe Arts and media correspondent

17, Nov, 2018 @2:32 PM

Article image
Why BBC news anchors are the television hosts with the most
From Paxman to Dimbleby, the BBC is using its trusted news anchors to give gravitas – and a dash of celebrity – to its shows. By John Dugdale

John Dugdale

08, Feb, 2010 @7:00 AM

Article image
Naga Munchetty reprimand blurs BBC’s own lines between reportage and opinion | Kenan Malik
The BBC Breakfast presenter had every right to express her anger at Donald Trump’s racist comment

Kenan Malik

29, Sep, 2019 @9:30 AM

Article image
Emily Maitlis: ‘Prince Andrew was unleashed. He wanted to tell me everything’
Newsnight was granted a rare audience with the royal ... and after a decade of silence, he was unstoppable. Its presenter shares the secrets of the interview of the century

Emily Maitlis

19, Dec, 2019 @6:00 AM

Article image
BBC chairman criticises Emily Maitlis’ Newsnight comments on Dominic Cummings
Richard Sharp made remarks on coverage of lockdown drive while setting out his blueprint for improving broadcaster

Nadeem Badshah

03, Dec, 2022 @11:14 PM