Just joking: John Humphrys defends remarks on BBC gender pay gap

Today broadcaster had come under fire for leaked comments to colleague Jon Sopel sparked by Carrie Gracie’s BBC campaign

Radio 4’s John Humphrys has defended his “jocular exchange” with Jon Sopel over colleague Carrie Gracie and the BBC’s equal pay controversy.

The presenter of the Today programme told ITV News on Friday that he was “totally totally in support of equal pay for equal work”.

But he was caught earlier in the week making disparaging remarks after Gracie decided to leave her post as China editor after she learned that male colleagues, including Sopel, a presenter and correspondent, were earning significantly more than her.

Humphrys’ controversial comments are believed to have been made on Monday and were leaked on Wednesday.

Humphrys told Olivia Kinsley of ITV News that Sopel was an old friend. They were in the habit of winding each other up, he said, and the jokey exchange “was a bit of mutual mickey-taking, and that is all it was”.

He said: “It was not meant for any other ears than Jon’s, although there happened to be a producer in the studio at the time – a woman as it happens, who thought it was very funny, because they know about the relationship that I have with Jon.

“It had absolutely nothing to do with my views on women’s pay, which I repeat and have said consistently should be equal – equal pay for equal work, absolutely no question of that. “It wasn’t meant to be broadcast to anybody. It was just a chat – I had no idea, neither did Jon, neither did anybody else – including the producer – that it was being recorded somewhere in the bowels of the BBC and somebody chose to leak it. And that er, yeah, was mildly annoying.”

On Friday, the BBC said the comments did not break its editorial guidelines as the pair were not explicitly campaigning about an issue, so Humphrys would not be barred from reporting on equal pay. Some female broadcasters who have commented on the issue have, however, been prevented from discussing equal pay on air.

Humphrys, when asked if this was a case of double standards, said: “I can understand only that if people have been misled as to what the exchange was all about, then maybe they could take the wrong message from it.”

When asked whether as an influential person at the BBC he would get behind the campaign to close the gender pay gap, he said: “ I am behind that campaign and so, if I may say so, is the BBC.”

On Thursday, a BBC spokesman said the leaked exchange was ill-advised and that the presenter regretted it. However, a source from the corporation told the Guardian that “management are deeply unimpressed” with the conversation.


Nicola Slawson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
BBC will not discipline John Humphrys over gender pay gap jokes
Corporation says Today presenter’s leaked off-air comments did not contravene its editorial code as newsroom anger grows

Tara Conlan and Jane Martinson

12, Jan, 2018 @3:56 PM

Article image
John Humphrys under fire over BBC equal pay comments
Co-founder of Women’s Equality party accuses former Today presenter of ‘going full troll’

Vanessa Thorpe Arts and media correspondent

25, Jan, 2020 @8:02 PM

Article image
John Humphrys meets his match
Peter Preston: Andrew Lansley has discovered the secret of how to fend off interviewers on the Today programme: bombard them with facts

Peter Preston

24, Sep, 2011 @11:07 PM

Article image
John Humphrys jokes about BBC gender pay gap in leaked recording
Radio 4 host claims off-air conversation with colleague Jon Sopel about Carrie Gracie was ‘silly banter between old mates’

Nicola Slawson

12, Jan, 2018 @12:31 AM

Article image
John Humphrys thinks outside the box | Media Monkey
Media Monkey: The BBC Radio 4 inquisitor-in-chief has made his thoughts clear on management speak


03, May, 2013 @8:20 AM

Article image
John Humphrys turns grime rapper on Today programme
After segment discussing the lack of Brit nominations for grime artists, the BBC presenter tries out some rhymes of his own

Jessica Elgot

12, Feb, 2016 @11:12 AM

Article image
Send us your questions for John Humphrys
The Today presenter has asked his final question. Now it’s your turn to quiz the BBC inquisitor…

The Observer

20, Sep, 2019 @10:49 AM

Article image
Caption competition: what is John Humphrys saying?
What might the Today presenter be saying while draped in a leopard-skin wizard's cloak, AKA The Slanket of Con, the smelly blanket used by Radio 4's continuity announcers

Tim Dowling

07, Dec, 2011 @1:39 PM

Article image
John Humphrys attacks BBC's 'liberal bias' days after retiring
Broadcaster presented Radio 4’s Today show for 32 years, earning a reported £600,000

Mark Townsend

21, Sep, 2019 @4:28 PM

Article image
John Humphrys says he is staying on Today programme
Veteran presenter also dismisses claims that Radio 4’s flagship breakfast show has dumbed down

John Plunkett

17, Mar, 2015 @7:00 AM