New EU copyright rules could boost media groups

Publishers, musicians and TV makers could find it easier to make money from use of their work on YouTube, Google News and Facebook

The EU is proposing strict new copyright rules aimed at making it easier for musicians, TV makers and publishers to make money out of their work online.

Google could be especially hard hit by the rules, which could force both YouTube and Google News to pay out more for hosting content or showing parts of it.

Many working in newspapers and the music and film and TV industries hold Google partly to blame for lost revenues from issues such as piracy.

In particular, artists and record labels have argued that YouTube has created a “value gap” but does not fairly compensate them for the huge amount of music streamed over its platform, arguing that it hides behind “safe harbour” rules governing content uploaded by users.

The new rules, which are contained in proposals from the European commission for an updated copyright directive, would require video sites such as YouTube to quickly remove or get authorisation for copyrighted videos, and strengthen the negotiating position of rights holders.

YouTube and other sites such as Dailymotion would have an “obligation to deploy effective means such as technology to automatically detect songs or audiovisual works”, though it praises YouTube’s efforts in the area.

The directive also offers hope for news publishers, some of which have been vociferous in their criticism of firms such as Google for making money from their content without paying.

New rules will recognise “the key role press publishers play in terms of investments in and overall contribution to the creation of quality journalistic content”, providing them with a stronger foundation to make aggregators such as Google News pay for republishing all or part of their article.

The new proposals still have to be approved by the European parliament and council of ministers and are likely to take months to come into force.

The European commission also said it was looking at ways to improve enforcement of rules including involving digital advertising companies that put ads on sites that host content that violates copyright, and companies that process payments for sites that charge for access.

Google’s vice president for global policy, Caroline Atkinson, said the company disagreed with the commission’s approach.

“Innovation and partnership – not subsidies and onerous restrictions – are the key to a successful, diverse and sustainable news sector in the EU,” she wrote in a blog post.

“And for both European creators and consumers, it’s vital to preserve the principles of linking, sharing and creativity on which so much of the web’s success is built. The appropriate balance has not yet been struck, and Google is committed to playing its part in the discussions.”


Jasper Jackson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Battle over EU copyright law heads for showdown
Brussels to vote on directive, supported by artists and news agencies, that opponents say could destroy the internet

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

09, Sep, 2018 @2:09 PM

Article image
Copyright directive will protect creatives | Letter
Letter: Carole Tongue says our story about MEPs approving sweeping changes to copyright law should have focused more on creative workers


01, Apr, 2019 @4:07 PM

Article image
What do major copyright changes mean for internet freedom?
Will we still be able to upload online content and news – and what about memes?

Alex Hern

26, Mar, 2019 @5:35 PM

YouTube faces $1bn lawsuit for alleged breach of copyright

MTV owner Viacom has launched a $1bn lawsuit against Google and its video-sharing website YouTube. By Bobbie Johnson.

Bobbie Johnson, technology correspondent

14, Mar, 2007 @10:46 AM

Article image
'We're righting a wrong,' say the artists taking on YouTube
This week sees the final episode in the battle for the musicians fighting for a fairer deal

Mark Sweney

01, Jul, 2018 @3:36 PM

Article image
Vinyl sales bigger than YouTube for British artists
Sales of vinyl records grow for eighth year in row, but labels attack ‘meagre’ payouts from advert-funded streaming websites

John Plunkett

19, May, 2016 @11:01 PM

Article image
Tech Weekly podcast: action on illegal filesharing and Britain's broadband future
Aleks Krotoski and the team dissect moves to force ISPs to prevent filesharing, the government's lack of vision for super-fast broadband, and news on Facebook, eBay and YouTube

Aleks Krotoski

26, Feb, 2008 @7:18 PM

Article image
EU copyright law may force tech giants to pay billions to publishers
Legislation opposed by firms like Facebook and Google and groups warning of detrimental consequences for the internet

Mark Sweney

12, Sep, 2018 @1:57 PM

Article image
UK copyright laws to be freed up and parody laws relaxed
Downloading purchased CDs onto laptop to be legalised, but music industry call for levy on copying devices is rejected. By Mark Sweney

Mark Sweney

20, Dec, 2012 @5:48 PM

Article image
Google seeks to turn YouTube rights clash into profit

Internet group is working to persuade music and video companies to cash in rather than clamp down when their content is uploaded

Katie Allen

01, Nov, 2009 @2:31 PM