Beware Murdoch, then change your mind

Rupert's critics issue dire warnings over his ownership of BSkyB - but reports of the Wall Street Journal's demise seem to have been exaggerated

The writing, of course, has been on the wall since January, when the European commission concluded that full Murdoch ownership of BSkyB "would not significantly impede effective competition in the European Economic Area or any substantial part of it". There was the Europe Rupert hates giving him a definitive nod on most of the arguments critics of the deal advance most passionately, leaving nothing but minor manoeuvrings over Sky News control for Jeremy Hunt and perhaps, now, judicial reviewers as midsummer turns to autumn.

Doom, gloom, the end of civilisation and "a loss of integrity and independence" that must be opposed because there is "already too much concentration of global media ownership" which Murdoch and his company "misuses for personal, political and business interests".

But those quotes from Jim Ottaway, the newspaperman whose family owned a chunk of Dow Jones and feared the worst if the Wall Street Journal fell into Murdoch hands, are four years old now. And what does Ottaway declare today? "I have to say that many of the things I said and feared Rupert Murdoch would do he has not," he told a Bloomberg TV special last week. His WSJ "is nowhere near as awful as I thought it might be".

So cross fingers, hope, and (perforce) beware awful warnings.

Think Didier Drogba and Fernando Torres. Then think Richard Littlejohn and Kelvin Mackenzie, the columnist who replaced him at the Sun in 2005. Now Kelvin is off to the Mail, where Littlejohn presides – and it's the former who gets the TV time that adds circulation clout. Two saloon bar strikers in the same forward line? Don't bank on it. One moment, as Drogba might say to Littlejohn, you're scoring goals: the next, you're on the bench of history.

Contributor

Peter Preston

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
As Rupert Murdoch leaves the stage, trouble waits in the wings
Murdoch's appearance before Leveson was merely a sideshow – the real problem is now what the lord justice is going to do about Jeremy Hunt, writes Peter Preston

Peter Preston

28, Apr, 2012 @8:00 PM

Article image
Beware Wall Street Journal bosses bearing messages of rhetorical excess
An unctuous letter from WSJ managing editor Robert Thomson has got staff worried, and rightly so, writes Peter Preston

Peter Preston

13, Oct, 2012 @11:30 PM

Article image
Here’s the Donald Trump bandwagon, and Rupert Murdoch nimbly leaping aboard
Only a few months ago, Murdoch was lauding Ben Carson in a ‘land of hope’. But long memories are no good to global power brokers

Peter Preston

31, Jan, 2016 @9:00 AM

Article image
Hold the front page - it's time US papers had a redesign
The Wall Street Journal looks fresh and modern, and circulation is rising. For many other American newspapers, neither of those things is true

Peter Preston

07, May, 2011 @11:05 PM

Article image
Times gloom in the shadow of the paywall
With the paywall a few weeks away, now is not the time for News International to be making cuts at the Times

Peter Preston

15, May, 2010 @11:10 PM

Article image
The Wall Street Journal is coming to Greater New York. What if the Times turned its attention to Greater London?

Rupert Murdoch is going head to head with the New York Times. But there are plenty of other big-city markets with room for some media competition

Peter Preston

01, May, 2010 @8:28 PM

Article image
Murdoch's purchase of Skiff offers newspapers platform for collaboration
Reports of News Corp's plan to acquire BSkyB have masked its acquisition of an e-reader that could work for all newspapers

Peter Preston

19, Jun, 2010 @11:04 PM

Article image
Running to Cable over Murdoch's BSkyB plans won't solve anything
Yes, Rupert Murdoch could use Sky customers as paywall fodder to bolster News Corp websites - but how likely is it?

Peter Preston

25, Sep, 2010 @11:06 PM

Article image
Has The Daily got off its launch pad?
Peter Preston: Murdoch's non-newsprint newspaper is looking at five to seven years to break even. Does it have that long?

Peter Preston

05, Feb, 2012 @12:03 AM

Article image
Rupert Murdoch: don't fear an old man in his twilight years
Peter Preston: The BSkyB deal makes News Corp more powerful than ever. But it was Murdoch senior's beloved stable of newspapers that made it a competition issue; once he departs the board, News Corp's passion for print will fade

Peter Preston

06, Mar, 2011 @12:12 AM