Kelley takes reality check

3.15pm: Last year he labelled reality television 'trash', but now the American producer behind LA Law and Ally McBeal has been lured into making his own reality show. By Jason Deans.

In the spirit of "if you can't beat 'em, join 'em", LA Law and Ally McBeal producer David E Kelley, previously an outspoken critic of the US reality TV boom, is to make a reality show with a cast made up of real lawyers.

Mr Kelley and the show's other producers will be setting up their own law firm for the NBC show and hiring lawyers to try real civil cases, under an American practice known as alternative dispute resolution, which allows for binding legal arbitration outside of court.

The move is something of a u-turn for Mr Kelley, who last summer launched an outspoken attack on network executives for commissioning more and more reality shows, which he described as "junk" and "trash".

Mr Kelley said his change of heart was down to the strength of the idea for the legal reality show, which came from independent producer Renegade 83, the company behind the US version of Blind Date.

"I'm not a big fan of reality television and I'm still not a big fan of those productions that pander to the lowest common denominator. [But] the folks at Renegade wanted to meet and discuss the series and I loved the idea," Mr Kelley told American entertainment magazine Variety.

"It's a documentary meets a drama. We'll be creating our own law firm. We'll have our own [team] of lawyers and they'll become our main characters," he added.

Mr Kelley said he was not planning a full time switch to producing reality shows, adding that "this one's unique to my interest in law".

He will take a consulting producer role for the show, which has been commissioned for an eight-part series by NBC.

Mr Kelley said he would be giving Renegade access to his team of script editors and composers so that the reality show could be storylined in the same way as shows such as LA Law, Ally McBeal and The Practice, with serial elements that continue over several episodes.

The move by Mr Kelley, one of America's most prominent and successful drama and comedy producers over the past decade, highlights the growing trend for reality hits such as American Idol, The Apprentice and Joe Millionaire to replace scripted shows in the primetime schedules of the US networks.

American comedy and drama producers and writers are under increasing pressure because the runaway success of reality TV in the past four years means there are fewer and fewer slots for scripted shows, which have dominated network schedules for the past two or three decades.

This autumn NBC, once the home of sitcom hits including Seinfeld, Frasier and Friends, will launch just four new comedies - the lowest number on the network since 1980.

Mr Kelley felt the heat from the reality TV boom last year, when his successful ABC legal drama The Practice took a hammering in the ratings after being scheduled directly against Fox hit Joe Millionaire.

He was forced to take drastic action and sack half the cast to save The Practice, prompting his anti-reality rant at a Television Critics Association event last summer.

"Today [network bosses] celebrate the junk. Where once they were ashamed, now they throw a parade for it," Mr Kelley said at the time.

However, he also admitted ruefully that his wife, Hollywood star Michelle Pfeiffer, was a fan of Joe Millionaire.

· To contact the MediaGuardian newsdesk email editor@mediatheguardian.com or phone 020 7239 9857

· If you are writing a comment for publication, please mark clearly "for publication".

Contributor

Jason Deans, broadcasting editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Kathryn Flett on being a judge on a reality TV show

Kathryn Flett: Being a judge on a reality TV show can certainly be an eye opener - but not for the reasons you'd think

Kathryn Flett

13, Sep, 2008 @11:01 PM

Reality check: what's on when

(This is a link)

12, May, 2006 @6:45 AM

Article image
Guardian Weekend TV special

Reality shows have invigorated British TV, according to tomorrow's special television edition of the Guardian's Weekend magazine. By Owen Gibson.

Owen Gibson

07, Feb, 2003 @4:54 PM

Reality check

Since TV is so slavishly dependent on soaps, you'd expect TV executives to have worked out a sophisticated rationale for having them by now, beyond arguing merely that they're cheap and popular.

Adam Sweeting

14, Oct, 1999 @1:45 AM

Marina Hyde: Reality obsession

Are there any public cruelties that can't be justified with the words, 'Sorry, this is a tough business'? Marina Hyde on Make Me a Supermodel.

Marina Hyde

18, Mar, 2005 @8:03 AM

Altered reality

Reality programming has moved a long way from its fly-on-the-wall roots, and will continue evolving until people no longer want to watch it, writes Neil Blackley.

Neil Blackley

20, Oct, 2004 @6:22 AM

Marketing reality TV

Comment: Daniel Rogers compares the marketing of Channel 4's Big Brother and ITV's Survivor.

Special report: Big Brother

Special report: Reality TV

Daniel Rogers

29, May, 2001 @8:59 AM

Back to reality

Does Channel 4's latest foray into reality TV mark a return to a golden era of real-life documentaries or is the television industry still stuck in the Big Brother groove? Stephen Armstrong investigates

Stephen Armstrong

31, Aug, 2008 @11:01 PM

Divorced from reality

Did you know that not everything that happens on reality TV is the God's honest truth? No less an authority than Big Brother hostess Davina McCall believes this to be the case. "I've definitely thought that some Big Brother relationships were formed just for the publicity," McCall tells the Sun. That's funny, she seemed so keen on them at the time.

Monkey

26, Aug, 2008 @8:24 AM

Flight from reality shows

ITV's populist, reality-show approach to its scheduling has not proved as successful as bosses might have hoped. By Sam Jones.

Sam Jones

03, Aug, 2006 @6:13 AM