Milk formula firms target women looking for pregnancy advice

Companies advertise products to women searching online for folic acid to get around marketing restrictions

Women trying for a baby are being targeted by formula milk companies on social media even before they have become pregnant, a World Health Organization scientist has said.

Formula milk brands use online shopping and search data to detect when someone is planning a baby, said Dr Nigel Rollins, of the department of maternal, newborn, child and adolescent health at the WHO.

“Digital platforms have made [the] industry massively more powerful,” he told the Unicef Baby Friendly annual conference last week. “Companies use sophisticated algorithms to target ads to women whose online behaviour suggests they might be pregnant.”

Researchers have previously reported how formula milk marketing executives described first-time pregnant women as “the holy grail”.

Rollins explained how women who ordered folic acid – an essential nutrient in early pregnancy – or browsed fertility or pregnancy information websites were likely to be profiled as thinking about starting a family.

Formula milk brands could then target these women by promoting branded social media posts, including those for their own apps, online “baby clubs” or helplines offering advice on getting pregnant, staying healthy during pregnancy or parenting.

Direct advertising of formula milk to parents of babies under six months old is prohibited in the UK but loopholes mean companies can provide advice to pregnant women and new parents under their own logos.

Rollins claimed the ultimate intention was to establish a “relationship” between the parent and a brand before a baby was born. “It is a way of providing ‘support’ but essentially it is marketing in disguise,” he said.

Rollins emphasised there should be no criticism of mothers who chose or needed to use formula milk. “Women and families should make, and have the right to make, decisions that best serve their circumstances.”

A WHO report published earlier this year warned it was “difficult” to avoid digital marketing of formula milk, especially when people were looking online for information about, or support for, breastfeeding.

It also suggested companies were deliberately targeting pregnant women and new mothers in their “most vulnerable moments”.

“Content that appears to offer information personally tailored to meet mothers’ concerns can be delivered at the very moment a woman seeks information on infant feeding,” it added.

“The content of these promotions typically presents a [breastmilk substitute] as the solution for challenging but normal infant behaviours like hunger, crying or digestive discomfort,” the report said.

Shereen Fisher, programme director of the UK committee for Unicef Baby Friendly Initiative, said: “Powerful multinational infant formula companies push the boundaries of existing legislation to promote their products. We need to make sure all babies and parents are protected from misleading marketing practices.”

A spokesperson for the British Specialist Nutrition Association, which represents the UK formula milk industry, said: “When parents are unable to, or choose not to, breastfeed, a scientifically developed infant formula is the only food recognised by the WHO as a suitable and safe alternative to breastmilk.

“It is important that parents can make informed choices about the options that are right for their baby and situation. We need to support parents with factual nutritional information, including on packaging and online, so that they can make the right decision for them. It’s a responsibility we take seriously.

“BSNA members comply with the WHO code as implemented in UK law and wish to contribute to a balanced, sensible debate about responsible marketing of formula, and protecting and promoting breastfeeding.”


Rosie Taylor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Express yourself! Celebrity mums lead breast pump boom
Stars’ selfies highlight the growing popularity of breast pumps for mothers balancing pressures of work and childcare

Tess Reidy

25, Aug, 2018 @2:00 PM

Article image
Parents frustrated with NCT launch ‘guilt-free’ antenatal classes
Anger over natural birth and breastfeeding bias spurs alternative baby clubs

Donna Ferguson

17, Jun, 2018 @5:00 AM

Article image
National Childbirth Trust president quits in breastfeeding row
Charity must remain a campaigning voice for women, says ex-head Seána Talbot

Donna Ferguson

20, Apr, 2019 @8:37 PM

Article image
Test all pregnant women for smoking, say NHS chiefs
The plan, which is supported by the Royal College of Midwives, is part of a wider drive to discourage cigarettes at hospitals

Denis Campbell

26, Feb, 2017 @12:03 AM

Article image
Breasts are so ostentatious. If only women could spurt milk from their fingers | Barbara Ellen
Barbara Ellen: It’s not mothers feeding their babies naturally, but those who insist on taking offence at the act who should be ashamed of themselves

Barbara Ellen

07, Dec, 2014 @3:05 AM

Article image
UK health trusts suspend home birth services as midwives shortage deepens
‘Crisis’ in maternity care leaves expectant mothers facing difficult births in hospital or without support at home

Hannah Summers

28, Nov, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Therapy ‘has long-term benefits for mothers with depression’
CBT has positive effects on mental health, financial empowerment and parenting skills, long-term study shows

Jamie Doward

29, Apr, 2017 @11:04 PM

Article image
Mums-to-be reject baby showers for ‘mother blessings’
Increasingly popular spiritual gatherings controversially borrow from Navajo traditions

Tess Reidy

18, Aug, 2019 @6:59 AM

Article image
Fear on the ward: UK mothers threatened with social services for refusing maternity care
Women who refuse advice from health service staff say they are being coerced with threats of referrals to agencies and police

Hannah Summers

02, Oct, 2021 @1:05 PM

Article image
Adventure playgrounds 'too risky' to insure
England children’s commissioner and London mayor raise concerns after leading firm refuses to cover some playgrounds

Michael Savage

03, Feb, 2019 @6:00 AM