I am the biological father of my ex’s 21-year-old daughter. She insists I take this information to my grave

You’re faced with a very hard decision, writes Guardian Australia’s advice columnist, you will need to test the kind of person you feel OK about being

Several years ago I was contacted by an ex girlfriend who informed me I am the biological father of her 21 year old daughter, the middle of her three children. She was my first serious girlfriend but we split up whilst still young. Our paths crossed several years later and we had a brief affair. Unbeknownst to me she became pregnant through this liaison but kept the matter a secret and remained with her husband who unwittingly raised the child as his own.

My ex immediately regretted telling me and insisted I take this information to my grave. Whilst I have respected her wishes, I feel extremely frustrated with the situation and would like to meet and get to know this woman who doesn’t know I exist. I am married (16 years) and have a young daughter of my own. My wife is aware of this situation and fully supportive.

Eleanor says: As I see it, your dilemma here is about whether to tell the truth. It doesn’t sound like you’d be able to get to know this young woman any other way.

That’s a very hard decision to make. Usually when we make choices we think about which outcome we prefer – but here, it’s almost the opposite. You can’t make a decision out of an attachment to a particular outcome.

It can’t be about whether you’d like a happy relationship with this young woman – because you can’t rule out that she’d want nothing to do with you. It can’t be about whether your ex should have told you – because exposing deceit now won’t mean she was honest then. It can’t be about getting closure – because you might find it just makes people angrier. There are so many open futures here that the only thing this decision is “about” is whether you’re willing to risk all of them.

That makes the focal length of the choice very short. It’s poker rules: you make the best choice you can with the information you have, not claiming to know how things will turn out.

Sometimes when I’m stuck in a situation like that it helps to hear what someone else would do, set out almost like a closing argument. Being the listener seems to take the pressure off being the decider. I’ll try to do that for you now – I’ll tell you what I’d do, with the hope that it’ll help you run a resonance check. I stress I don’t offer this as an answer. I offer it so you can test whether you’d be proud to inhabit this kind of reasoning.

I wouldn’t tell. Here’s why: yes, her mother made a hurtful decision, and two or three more after that. But that’s done now, set in the resin of time. Reaching out might just be one more hurtful decision. It would mean she had to decide how to feel about a stranger while processing that her mother had an affair and deceived her. It would be a gamble on whether her parents’ marriage would survive, meaning this 21 year old – who didn’t choose any of this – might face a crisis while her support system was in a crisis of its own. Since I wouldn’t be able to guarantee that the world I’d force her into is better than the one she’s currently in, I’d be making that decision unilaterally. That wouldn’t feel fair.

So I’d try not to be pulled by the outcome I desperately wanted, or by how wildly unfair it is that I even have to make this choice. I’d try to do the least risky thing.

It would feel unspeakably tragic to do that. It would cost me one of life’s most beautiful things. I might even vent the steam of my fury at my ex so my pain had somewhere to go, or even upload my data to a DNA tracing website so that if my child ever went looking she’d be able to find me.

But I’d try not to confuse my protest at the situation for an answer about how to resolve it. Sometimes other people’s bad choices leave us with nothing but bad options.

I hope it helps to test whether that’s the kind of person you’d feel OK about being.

Whatever your answer, I think that’s the way to make this choice: when we can’t make decisions on outcomes, we can ask what kind of reasoning we’d like to shine out from our actions.


Ask us a question

Do you have a conflict, crossroads or dilemma you need help with? Eleanor Gordon-Smith will help you think through life’s questions and puzzles, big and small. Questions can be anonymous.

If you’re having trouble using the form, click here. Read terms of service here


Eleanor Gordon-Smith

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
My boyfriend isn’t sure if he wants children and I definitely do. Please can you help? | Leading questions
Your boyfriend’s uncertainty is legitimate, writes advice columnist Eleanor Gordon-Smith, but you must be proactive about something this important

Eleanor Gordon-Smith

14, Apr, 2021 @5:30 PM

Article image
I do not want children, but my boyfriend (and his mother) feel differently
This isn’t just your wishes against his, writes advice columnist Eleanor Gordon-Smith, it’s the wishes of the person they’re asking you to make

Eleanor Gordon-Smith

21, Oct, 2021 @4:30 PM

Article image
Leading questions: 'Should I make contact with my father, whom I have never met?'
Ask yourself whether this is a person you want in your life, writes advice columnist Eleanor Gordon-Smith, and be prepared for the possibility of disappointment

Eleanor Gordon-Smith

02, Jul, 2020 @1:32 AM

Article image
'Potential minefield': My daughter's getting married but I can't face her father
You may be hurt, writes advice columnist Eleanor Gordon-Smith, but giving yourself permission to accept your feelings is not the same as permitting yourself to act on them

Eleanor Gordon-Smith

11, Feb, 2020 @4:30 PM

Article image
'I’ve tried to raise my daughter with feminist values but I’m struggling with her clothes. What do I say?' | Leading questions
The cold truth is there’s nothing your daughter can wear to keep her safe, writes advice columnist Eleanor Gordon-Smith. So give her the message the rest of the world won’t

Eleanor Gordon-Smith

03, Dec, 2020 @4:30 PM

Article image
I'm scared of being the granny everyone avoids. How do I get over this? | Leading questions
Christmas brings up questions of worthiness for a lot of us, writes Eleanor Gordon-Smith. The good news is, no one in your family is ranking you

Eleanor Gordon-Smith

24, Dec, 2019 @5:00 PM

Article image
How do I tell my moody 19-year-old niece she has to help out around the house? | Leading questions
Your niece is probably counting down the seconds until she’s independent, writes advice columnist Eleanor Gordon-Smith. So try treating her like an adult

Eleanor Gordon-Smith

21, Apr, 2021 @5:30 PM

Article image
'It feels irresponsible to have a second child and yet I want one. How do I grapple with this?'
The time you most need a child’s input into what they want, they’re not here to ask, writes advice columnist Eleanor Gordon Smith. Life is uncertain – the question is whether it’s worth living anyway

Eleanor Gordon-Smith

21, May, 2020 @12:00 AM

Article image
'Self-isolation is bringing out the worst in some. How do we avoid conflict?'
Things are tough right now, writes advice columnist Eleanor Gordon-Smith, but we must try to keep contempt at bay

Eleanor Gordon-Smith

22, Apr, 2020 @12:00 AM

Article image
My successful only son is miserable to me. Am I wrong to feel unappreciated?
Being a parent plunges you into a sort of unrequited love, writes Eleanor Gordon-Smith, but that doesn’t mean you’re in the wrong

Eleanor Gordon-Smith

12, Nov, 2019 @5:00 PM