All the trains in my son’s train podcast ranked by how much I hate them | Ben Jenkins

Living in lockdown with small children means distracting them with the same thing, over and over again, until you – like Ben Jenkins – are driven insane

Every parent of a young child in lockdown either knows this fact or is about to learn it: you don’t get to choose where they find their joy.

For example, my two and half year old son likes to listen to the Thomas and Friends Storytime podcast. It is, by some margin, his favourite thing to do. By a similar margin, the opening “toot toot” of the podcast is my least favourite sound on the entire planet, which now activates my fight or flight reflex every time I hear it. But due to some quirk of evolution, I find myself unable to deny my boy his train show, as it gives him the kind of happiness unattainable to adults without the use of class-A drugs.

Nonetheless, I am genuinely confronted by how much I hate this show and the trains therein. Some of this can be chalked up to entering our fourth week of lockdown with no end in sight. Most of it can be chalked up to Thomas and Friends Storytime being a bad show about trains who I hate.

There are lots of interesting reasons to hate this show, but I’m not getting into any of them here. This is simply a list of all the trains in the show, ranked by how much I hate them. This ranking is not definitive. Those in a similar position to me may wish to make their own list of trains they hate from their child’s train podcast. It doesn’t need to be a train podcast specifically that’s driving you insane in lockdown. For me, however – and I really cannot stress this enough – it is.

9. Nia

Nia is the least objectionable train in my son’s train podcast, possibly because she’s afforded so little airtime. I can’t tell you much about Nia, other than that she’s painted orange, which is fine, and that she was once tasked with bringing an elephant to the Sodor Animal Park and the elephant ran away, which is not.

8. Gordon

A lot of people don’t like Gordon, who is haughty and rude, but I feel an affinity with this train because the contempt in which he holds all the other trains on the Island of Sodor comes very close to matching my own. There aren’t a lot of Gordon-centric episodes in Thomas and Friends Storytime, but as if to make up for this, the actor shouts each of his lines at an upsetting volume. Gordon doesn’t get into adventures like the other trains, and seems to be very into the core business of “being a train”. It is for this reason alone that he does not rank higher.

7. Henry

Henry, bricked up in a tunnel
‘Henry is not entombed alive in the podcast, which is a great shame.’ Photograph: Publicity image

I’m told that there’s a famous episode of the old TV show where Henry is bricked up in a tunnel for all eternity as a punishment for disobedience. I am not exaggerating when I say that if this happened to any of the trains in Thomas and Friends Storytime, I would take my shirt off and run around the living room like I’d just won the World Cup.

Henry is not entombed alive in the podcast, which is a great shame.

6. Diesel

Diesel is a diesel-powered shunting engine and is the closest thing Thomas and Friends Storytime has to an antagonist. Why is he the antagonist? Well, when the Reverend W. Awdry was dreaming up the magical Island of Sodor to delight and entertain a generation of children, he decided to establish a blood feud between the diesel and steam powered engines. I can only assume he did this for his own inscrutable Protestant reasons, and the end result is a kind of completely incongruous, sectarian tension that runs through the series. Diesel is the head of the diesel faction on Sodor and once stole a Christmas tree. Pathetic.

5. Rebecca

My son has episodes that he likes more than others. Thomas’ Animal Friends, featuring Rebecca, is his favourite episode of all, and as a result I know Thomas’ Animal Friends better than literally any piece of media or art I have ever encountered. I have more clarity around the events that unfold in Thomas’ Animal Friends than anything that has ever happened to me in my actual life, including the birth of my son. It is for this reason that I would like to see Rebecca the Large Tender Engine exploded by huge amounts of dynamite.

4. Cranky the Crane

I’ll be the first to admit that Cranky The Crane is not a train. He still makes my list.

3. James

In 1896, the Lumiere brothers premiered their film L’Arrivée d’un train en gare de La Ciotat. It’s a 50 second clip of a train arriving at a station, and when it was first shown in Paris, the audience were so terrified that they ran screaming from the room. This was prescient, as 125 years on, it is my exact reaction when James The Red Engine appears in any episode of Thomas And Friends Storytime.

James is billed as “the funny engine”. To begin with, this is a lie. James does nothing at any point in any of the episodes that could even be generously described in those terms. The podcast’s insistence that James is comic relief might be what tips me over the edge in lockdown, ripping our speakers from the wall and walking them, and myself, into blessed traffic.

2. Thomas

The only reason that this guy isn’t at number one is that the other day we were at the park and my son held out his arms and ran down the path and said “toot toot I’m Thomas!” with a huge smile on his face which was the best thing to happen to me all week.

Nonetheless, Thomas is a huge piece of shit and no doubt about it. J.R.R Tolkien once said that “cellar door” was the most beautiful sounding phrase in the English language. This was only because he had never heard the phrase “Thomas The Tank Engine has been turned to atoms by a futuristic beam weapon”.

1. Percy

And so, by default, Percy, The Green Engine, is my most hated engine on Thomas and Friends Storytime. He is in most of the episodes and says things like “Last one to Tidmouth Sheds is a broken boiler!” without any consequence from a sane God.

That’s the list. I do not wish to discuss the trains any further.

The unfortunate winner, Percy
The unfortunate winner, Percy. Photograph: ITV/REX Shutterstock


Ben Jenkins

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
From cardboard castles to kitchen ziplines: how are you entertaining your kids in lockdown? – open thread
Parents are coming up with all kinds of creative ways to keep kids occupied while social distancing due to coronavirus. Tell us yours in the comments

Stephanie Convery

18, May, 2020 @10:51 PM

Article image
Orphans, foundlings and fostering in literature: a child’s view of belonging
Some of the most loved figures in popular culture are abandoned children or children without parents. This month, a new exhibition, Drawing on Childhood, opens at the Foundling Museum in London

Lemn Sissay

01, Jan, 2016 @12:00 PM

Article image
David Baddiel: ‘It’s a huge joy to do work your children like’
Inspired by a question from his son about Harry Potter, comedian David Baddiel has written a children’s book about a boy who can choose his own parents

Jon Henley

11, Oct, 2014 @5:31 AM

Article image
My parents at war: Jacqueline Wilson opens up about unhappy early life
Millions of children have been comforted by her books. Now the author reveals that her mother’s death has allowed her to be more open about her childhood

Donna Ferguson

24, Sep, 2016 @11:03 PM

Article image
Again, again! Which kids' bedtime books are you happy to reread?
Imogen Russell Williams: The Dora books stretch my accent skills to breaking point, while Thomas the Tank Engine is full of stifling moralism. But not all favourites are destined to be 'lost' down the back of the shelf

Imogen Russell Williams

25, Feb, 2014 @7:30 AM

Article image
David Cameron's reading to children speech: between the lines
Zoe Williams: The PM has revived this old chestnut to avoid addressing real questions, such as 'How can we redistribute wealth?'

Zoe Williams

19, Jan, 2012 @4:00 PM

Article image
Author who put bad language into bedtime writes sweary sequel
Adam Mansbach’s new picture book offers a lighthearted adults-only take on that other crisis point in a parent’s day: dinner time

Alison Flood

26, Sep, 2014 @6:00 AM

Article image
Experience: I didn’t leave my son’s hospital room for 47 days
Sunny bank holidays were especially hard – knowing people were enjoying clear blue skies when we couldn’t even feel fresh air

James Stephenson

03, Jul, 2020 @9:00 AM

Article image
Being bored is a luxury – and for kids it can be magical
We live in a society that encourages filling up our time with anything and everything but boredom is cheap and good for the soul

Kat Patrick

04, May, 2017 @1:24 AM

Article image
Female role models to inspire change in society | Letters
Letters: We need more books for both boys and girls that normalise girls as adventurous, confident and capable leaders, writes Jean Pollard. And why can no one remember the work of Eleanor Marx? asks John Airs


18, Jun, 2018 @4:30 PM