Lawyer Dinah Rose KC sues the Times for libel

Lawsuit relates to a story about criticism she faced after taking Cayman Islands same-sex marriage case

A leading lawyer is suing the Times for libel over a report relating to a complaint against her to the barristers’ watchdog for England and Wales.

The story concerned Dinah Rose KC representing the Cayman Islands government in opposing same-sex marriage in a case at the privy council, for which she was criticised by LGBTQ+ rights campaigners, including some students at the University of Oxford, where she is president of Magdalen College.

In a story last year referring to the Bar Standards Board (BSB) headlined “Law chiefs rule against Magdalen College head in Caymans gay rights row”, the Times reported that a gay rights campaign group had said Rose “must apologise” for “recklessness” for claiming that she was professionally obliged to take the case under the “cab rank” rule. It quoted the BSB as having told Colours Caribbean that Rose’s interpretation of the rules “might possibly amount to evidence of recklessness” if “taken at its highest”.

The BSB later issued a public statement clarifying that it had not found her to have been “reckless” or to have acted inappropriately and had not taken any regulatory action against her. It said: “We apologise to Ms Rose if this has not been made sufficiently clear.” It also stated that criticism of Rose for taking the case was “misplaced” because under the bar code of conduct, “a barrister must not withhold their services on the grounds that the nature of the case or the conduct or opinions of the client are objectionable or unacceptable”. The Times article was subsequently taken down.

The Bar Council, the representative body for barristers, later described the BSB’s handling of the complaint against Rose as “unacceptable and inexcusable”, including the fact that it did not give her the opportunity to be heard or comment on the matter.

At the time of the story, Rose tweeted that Times Law “were warned that they were taking a quote from a press release out of context, without the decision being available. They pressed on and published it, regardless. I have instructed solicitors to bring libel proceedings.”

As first reported by the legal blogger Joshua Rozenberg, proceedings have been issued against the Times and its legal editor, Jonathan Ames.

Rose’s solicitor, Mark Lewis, said: “It is not appropriate for us to comment at this time.” The Times also declined to comment.

The judicial committee of the privy council ruled in March last year that there was no right to same-sex marriage under the constitution of the Cayman Islands.


Haroon Siddique

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Times libel ruling restores Reynolds public interest defence

Publication of allegations about police corruption involving extradition of Russian oligarchs was legitimate, rules court. By Owen Bowcott

Owen Bowcott

21, Mar, 2012 @4:22 PM

Article image
Jimmy Savile escaped justice because of libel laws, claims reporter
The Sun tried to expose Savile as paedophile but had to back down over fears of costly libel case, investigative journalist says

Jim Waterson Media editor

28, Apr, 2022 @3:30 PM

Barclays sue Times for criminal libel

A criminal libel action taken by the Barclay brothers - owners of the Daily Telegraph - against the Times was adjourned yesterday so that the French judge hearing the case can consider whether it should continue.

Kim Andre in Paris

10, Feb, 2006 @12:02 AM

Article image
Amber Heard 'placing faith in justice' as Depp lawyer calls her an abuser
High court hears closing remarks in three-week libel case exposing couple’s relationship

Caroline Davies

28, Jul, 2020 @5:41 PM

Article image
Times libel sets 'unwelcome precedent'

11am: The editor of the Times claims the £250,000 libel damages awarded to the chairman of Southampton football club has set an 'unwelcome precedent' for columnists. By Claire Cozens.

Claire Cozens, press and publishing correspondent

27, Oct, 2005 @9:54 AM

Libel ruling against the Times 'is blow to investigative journalism'
Media lawyers express concern as court of appeal rules Reynolds defence does not apply to allegations against detective. By Natalie Hanman

Natalie Hanman

14, Jul, 2010 @11:05 AM

Article image
Arron Banks loses libel action against reporter Carole Cadwalladr
Judge rules Guardian journalist successfully established public interest defence under Defamation Act

Haroon Siddique Legal affairs correspondent

13, Jun, 2022 @11:49 AM

Article image
Libel proposals will have 'chilling effect' on newspaper investigations
Government plans to cut cost of taking libel action against publishers or broadcasters risk vexatious claims, say campaigners. By Lisa O'Carroll

Lisa O'Carroll

16, Sep, 2013 @12:37 PM

Article image
Ex-Times lawyer denies misleading high court judge in Nightjack case
Alastair Brett tells tribunal that incident involving unmasking of police blogger was 'a catalogue of disasters from start to finish'. By Lisa O'Carroll

Lisa O'Carroll

05, Dec, 2013 @3:54 PM

Article image
Ex-Times lawyer suspended as solicitor for six months over Nightjack case

Tribunal rules that Alastair Brett knowingly allowed high court to be misled over hacking of anonymous blogger's email account

Lisa O'Carroll

05, Dec, 2013 @8:22 PM